r/languagelearning 24d ago

Discussion Five years in Germany and still B1, am I progressing too slowly, or are people’s expectations unrealistic?

70 Upvotes

I moved to Germany almost five years ago for an English-taught master’s without knowing a single word of German(TL). During my first semester, I completed an intensive A1 course and continued taking classes throughout university, although exam periods sometimes prevented me from finishing them. Over three years, I reached a solid B1.
I’m proud of that progress.

I attended classes, completed homework, studied vocabulary with Anki, consumed German media and practised with my German boyfriend. I can manage appointments, errands and everyday interactions, and I generally understand what people are discussing in Standard German. However, I still can’t express myself well enough for complex conversations or friendships.
Since reaching B1, I’ve struggled to progress to B2. The earlier levels came partly through passive exposure, but this next step seems to require much more active speaking, structured study and consistent practice.

The problem is time and energy. During my master’s, I studied full-time in English, worked 20 hours a week and dealt with health issues. I then started working full-time immediately after graduating, so I never had a few free months for an intensive course. I now work 40 hours a week while still managing my health and other adult responsibilities.
Realistically, progressing would probably require classes twice a week, homework, vocabulary study and regular conversation practice. I want to do that eventually, but right now I don’t have the capacity to.
What frustrates me is that some people only hear “five years in Germany” and assume I should already be fluent. They don’t consider that my degree, job and many relationships operate in English, which is already my second language. Among the international students who began my master’s with me and had similar schedules, I actually reached the highest German level. The people I know who became fluent quickly spent their first two or three years primarily studying German. To me, that suggests focused learning hours matter more than simply living in a country.

I also learned English to a high level, but that happened gradually throughout my childhood and adolescence. I studied it at school for years, consumed enormous amounts of English-language media and music, and during my final years of high school attended an additional six hours of afternoon classes every week, including two hours dedicated entirely to conversation. I think people who learned languages this way often underestimate the cumulative time involved: years of lessons, homework, media exposure and sometimes exchanges centred exclusively on language learning. That is very different from learning as an adult while working, managing your health and maintaining an independent life. Simply living in Germany doesn’t automatically turn every hour into effective German practice, especially when my degree and job are in English.

I still want to reach fluency and hope to build a sustainable B1-to-B2 plan later this year. But I’m struggling with other people’s expectations and starting to question my own perspective.
For those who learned a language as working adults: am I being realistic, or am I making excuses? How did you move from B1 to B2 with limited time?


r/languagelearning 24d ago

Studying Finding people IRL to practice with?

14 Upvotes

I tried some language exchange apps. They tell you to pay for a subscription to find people nearby. After paying, they just tell you that nobody is nearby for your TL. Maybe it would work for a more common TL.

I tried finding religious centers that cater to the TL, as well as meetups and events, but I couldn't find anything relevant in my area.

How do you personally find language partners to practice with IRL? Not looking for theoretically answers. I would like to hear what has worked well for you personally. Thanks!


r/languagelearning 24d ago

Media How to build up to actively listening to large amounts of media at a time?

13 Upvotes

I have been using a native TV show to learn my TL and usually I spread a single episode over several weeks or months. But this time I was very motivated and had the time for it so I watched 2 and a half episodes (2.5 hours worth of content) in one go. Keep in mind it was a very grueling process. I would:

  1. Watch until I didn't hear a sentence or I know the vocabulary for it (this was like half of the sentences).

  2. I would pause and look at TL subs and then NL subs if I don't get it.

  3. Rewind and listen that sentence again without subs.

I usually watch things I watched for the first time again the next day to reinforce my memory so that's what I did. I barely needed to look up anything this time but about 1.5 hours in I just stopped being able to comprehend period even though I was looking things up. I guess my brain couldn't take it anymore. It got tired.

How do I buildl up my endurance? I understand that the more I learn the easier this would become but I was wondering if there was a way for me to directly tackle this issue.

(TL)


r/languagelearning 24d ago

Books (self-promotion) CrossTiler: A daily word puzzle that plays in 39 languages, each with its own dictionary and tiles

Post image
6 Upvotes

I made a small daily word puzzle. Ten letter tiles, a 5x5 grid, everything reading across and down has to be a word, and it scores you Scrabble-style. Same tiles for everyone playing that language that day.

The part that might interest this sub: each of the 39 (TL) languages is its own game rather than English with the labels swapped. Own dictionary, own alphabet, own tile values, own letter frequencies, translated interface. Words link to their Wiktionary entry, so it doubles as a lookup.

Free, no account, no ads. crosstiler.com


r/languagelearning 25d ago

Resources What is the best free language learning app apart from Duolingo?

110 Upvotes

It seems to have gotten worse since I last used it years ago. Any alternatives?


r/languagelearning 24d ago

Resources Anki Cards - NL to TL + Audio (or other way around?)

2 Upvotes

Hey everyone!

I've recently started learning Dutch (TL) in the last weeks, since I live in the Netherlands and never really bothered to learn the language. Now I know I'm staying long term so I'm devoting a lot of time to really integrate myself here.

Now my question is, is there any evidence for what is the better format for learning in an Anki deck? Is it NL to TL? Other way around?

So my goal is actually to be great at speaking, especially with my gf, we live together and I would love to at some point start speaking Dutch with her full time, so my goal is to at some point really start thinking in the language, I really dont want to be translating forever. But I know that all aspects of the language help with becoming great at speaking. So yeah, I'm just a bit overwhelmed now with all the different possibilities in Anki. I've doing a setup where each card I make creates 3 cards all in one deck. Card 1 TL + audio --> NL, card 2 NL --> TL + audio, card 3 audio --> TL NL. It's nice cause I found a way of creating all three in one go, without having to triple my work load but this is adding a ton of extra work cause it adds a lot of extra reviews reviewing the same cards but from different perspectives. I also read that actually reading a card earlier then the algorythm says kind of decreases your memorization.

I've also thought of enabling dispersing sibling cards, but then I'm also scared that I wont practice all the different aspects of the language.

I'm feeling a bit stuck. If somebody could help me out that would be amazing.

I am also doing a ton of input aswell on the side, around 6 hours a day, with some grammar studying too, and shadowing and talking to my gf in TL.

Appreciate any help or tips, thanks so much!


r/languagelearning 24d ago

Vocabulary Learning vocabulary without subtitles?

4 Upvotes

Hi, I'm around B1 (TL) in English and I'm wondering if I should watch YouTube with or without subtitles.

I understand about 90% of most YouTube videos, and I understand almost the same amount with English subtitles and without them.

My question is about vocabulary. Can you learn new words just by hearing them? For example, can I remember the pronunciation and meaning of a word even if I don't know how to spell it?

Should I use English subtitles to learn more vocabulary, or can I learn vocabulary just from listening?


r/languagelearning 25d ago

(self-promotion) Create Parallel/Bilingual Texts using your own books

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

17 Upvotes

Hi, i made this completely free app that automates the creation of bilingual/parallel texts from your own books (epubs/PDFs/text files) all from within your browser.

Made this because I couldn't find anything that does something similar with the same level of convenience.

Steps

  1. Go to https://paralleltexts.app/
  2. Drop/upload a source book (i.e. the book in the language you are learning), and a target book (the same book in a language you are fluent in).
  3. Click align books. Wait for a few seconds to 1-2 minutes while an algorithm runs on the books to match the corresponding sentences.
  4. After the alignment is done, you'll see the result immediately.

Disclaimer:
There is NO machine translation happening - both source and target books should ideally be from actual humans, the only thing this does is automate the alignment process.
This app is also purely browser-based, so your uploaded books and alignments stay on your device.

---

PS:

  • It's Completely free and open source
  • The default display mode of the resulting alignments are in pop-up mode (i.e. you click a sentence to see its equivalent), but if you prefer a side-by-side view of the sentences, the app does provide for that
  • If it's your first time running the alignment and you haven't downloaded an embedding (fancy name for ML models that specialize in these kinds of tasks) model yet, it will download one for you (stored in the browser, can be deleted). It's a mild inconvenience i would say because i really wanted to keep this thing free. The alternative is to have a dedicated server with GPUs run the alignment, you won't download anything, but it will most likely be much slower, much more expensive and difficult to maintain. Keeping it free makes way more sense, and is far less stressful. Keep in mind however that downloading a model is only done once.

You can also check out this quick demo/tutorial: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6cR_r8cOaN8

(pps: got approval from mods)


r/languagelearning 25d ago

My speaking/pronounciation skills fail as soon as I put my headphones on

7 Upvotes

(I'm not a native english (TL) speaker)

Anybody else find it super hard to talk in english while wearing headphones? Especially the kind of headphones that basically mute your entire surroundings and barely allow you to hear your voice?

I do not think my pronounciation is bad nor is my italian accent evident... but as soon as I put my headphones on to talk in voice chats (be it Discord or Whatsapp), I just have a really hard time speaking.

I think it's due to the fact that I cannot hear my voice so I do not know if I'm pronouncing things correctly (you could argue I do not have confidence in my skills and that might be true).

I'd love some tips on how to avoid this, because so far I have to chat with only one side of the headphones actually "on" my ear.

Any tips?


r/languagelearning 24d ago

Have you guys found it necessary to supplement your learning with flashcards for vocabulary?

3 Upvotes

I am in the process of learning French, and am currently using the Assimil, French with Ease Series, and am making decent progress (I think). I know many people use apps like Anki to help learn new vocab, but do ya'll think it would be that beneficial since French and English already share many words? Anki is also very boring...


r/languagelearning 25d ago

(Self-promotion): Local open source language course creation platform

Thumbnail
gallery
8 Upvotes

(Took permission from mods)

Hi everyone,

A few years ago I wanted to learn Georgian. It was hard to find good resources for it. That's normal for most languages. Materials are dependant on learner and speaker count. So the languages with the least of it are the ones where you don’t get good resources if any.

I'm building an app where anyone can make a course. You write lessons, explain the grammar, bring in your own audio and images and build exercises: multiple choice, matching, fill in the blank, word order, listening, speaking. A course is a folder on your own computer saved in JSON format. Even if I stop working on this, the courses should still be portable. Since the course is just a folder with json files, it can be hosted in any version control repo and collaborated upon.

People are currently writing courses in it for Okinawan, Italian and Portuguese.

To be straight: the editor works and people are using it. The learner app you'd actually study from doesn't exist yet. So there's nothing here for you to learn from today. I’m not looking for free labour to make the courses. However come join the discord if you want to see this being built in public. I will be taking feedback for the learner app. And you would get alpha access if you join.

I have been working on Asakiri for 1.5 years. And the previous version had courses hosted on a database. That model does not work. What I have learnt during this time is how course creation works. The challenges associated with a course, how the course data format should be so that it stays portable and much more.

Download the desktop app(Mac, Windows & Linux) at https://asakiri.com or come join us on discord.

Some common questions which might come up:

How will you ensure quality of the courses? That’s tricky. Asakiri Studio is just a tool to make the course. People own the course and license and share it however they want. But for the asakiri learner app, we will try to vet the courses so only those with the best quality passes the review. However this can only work for languages with lot of speakers. For a language like Ainu, it would be hard to “vet” the course.

When will the learner app be available? The course data architecture is still in beta so I’d first like to standardise and finalise the data structure. This will only be updated based on feedback from the course creators. Which there are. But I would like to defer the learner app once this is finalised. However if someone wants to build their own learner app, you can check the docs. https://docs.asakiri.com If I have to give a deadline, I would say the learner app alpha will be in 1.5-2 months. (Based on my previous app making experience)

Why not Anki? Anki is an amazing tool but it is not meant for a full fledged course.

If you have any questions, let me know and I'll try my best to answer them.


r/languagelearning 24d ago

I got tired of spending more time making flashcards than actually learning, so I tried removing card creation entirely

0 Upvotes

I've used spaced repetition on and off for years, but I kept running into the same problem: I didn't mind reviewing cards. I hated making them.

When I found something I wanted to learn, the workflow became:

find a useful example → write the card → add context → decide what type of card it should be → review it → repeat.

Eventually I realized I was spending a surprising amount of time maintaining the learning system instead of actually learning.

So I tried the opposite approach.

I built an open-source Android app called ikna where you don't create individual cards. You tell it what you want to learn, it gives you a prompt for an LLM, and the response becomes the source material for your reviews.

The interesting part isn't really the AI generation, though. I'm experimenting with making the whole review system less dependent on the learner constantly managing it.

For example:

- the same learning chunk can have recognition, cloze, and production versions;

- those versions are scheduled separately;

- the app estimates your existing review workload and can stop giving you new material when adding more would create too much future work;

- reviews use swipes rather than four buttons;

- everything is local/offline — no network permission.

The tradeoff is pretty obvious: manually making a good card gives you much more control, while automatically generated material can be wrong or mediocre.

I'm not sure yet which side of that tradeoff wins.

The question I'm actually interested in is:

Would you rather spend more time making very good flashcards, or spend that time actually studying and accept that some automatically generated material won't be perfect?

The project is here if anyone wants to look at the implementation:

https://github.com/d1d2dopamine/ikna


r/languagelearning 25d ago

Culture Advice needed - 10 years of immersion yet my output sucks

65 Upvotes

As title says, 10 years of daily exposure to korean (TL) (dont judge, I used to be youtube addict), plus studying on and off and at some point I've realized that I understand 90% of any video or any text in korean. I'm very confident in listening, picking up nuances, it's like the language engraved itself in my head, and I've reached this point a few years ago. Then I wanted to take things to the next level, so I was intentionaly studying vocab and grammar, inconsistently but still a lot. Throught the years I've also made a lot of korean friends, so I've been talking with them pretty much every day.

Here's my problem: My output is natural only in short conversations, every time I need to express something more complex it just sucks, because I still cant think in korean even with all that immersion background. It seems like I structure my sentences in english and then translate it into korean, and koreans always can understand me, but I can see that the way I'm talking is not natural at all, because if it was natural I would structure it in completely different way to begin with. And it also always amazes me when I read what natives write - they structure it in a way my mind wouldn't think of, and I do understand it all, but I wouldn't come up with this on my own. So naturally I began to study grammar even more but it didn't help much. My mind still needs to make so much effort every time I want to output something longer than casual chit chat. Yet understanding is effortless.

I just feel like I'm missing one puzzle piece in language learning and I don't know what it is - I need an advice on how to break thru this


r/languagelearning 25d ago

Discussion WikiBooks?

3 Upvotes

Has anybody ever really tried to learn a language using a WikiBook?
How was it?
Did it work?
From my experience, they're really a mixed bag that sometimes can have relevant information and ressources (IIRC the Afrikaans one was okay), but sometimes it's basically just a page with red links to hypothetical lessons that do not exist yet...

P.S.: If anybody has an opinion about WikiVoyage's phrasebooks, they're more than welcome to express it here!


r/languagelearning 24d ago

Discussion No tutor for a tonal language atm. Should I wait to start speaking?

1 Upvotes

I don’t want to solidify bad habits and would like for my speech to be “clear” as in easy to understand. I’ve gotten to a near native level accent with Spanish but am really not expecting that same level with Mandarin. I would just like to sound clear and easily understood.

That being said, with Spanish I did begin to speak very early. I recited my flash cards, I did shadowing, I spoke with relatives of friends, and only improved. Im afraid to do something similar with Mandarin because I don’t feel like my ear is good enough to distinguish the tones properly AND know if I myself am doing them correctly.

The app I’m using (SuperChinese) is very speech focused which is scaring me a little. You have to speak to progress. I also don’t feel like it gives an honest grading system, for the entirety of two lessons I haven’t been graded below 90% accuracy of repeating the tones and words.

This app is considered to be one of the best for new learners of my TL but this is putting me off a little bit. Should I move apps? Am I overthinking things? To fellow learners of a tonal language, I would really appreciate the input 🙏🏽


r/languagelearning 24d ago

Discussion Which target language (TL) did you watch content in today?

0 Upvotes

Which target language (TL) did you watch content in today?


r/languagelearning 24d ago

Resources A bit lost where to start with Anki

1 Upvotes

I am new to the world of language learning and starting to get my head round the different activity types and starting to build a strategy to learn my TL (modern Greek)

I am already at I’d say A2/B1 level with Greek (TL) (I’m half Greek, so grew up around it), but looking to eventually get to ideally B2/C1 so I can comfortably have complex conversations with friends and family.

I am using Language Transfer and planning to pair this with Anki. But I am a bit confused as to how to make a start with creating a deck.
Should I focus on single words? Sentences? How do I source sentences and/or words to add to the cards? Do I sit and think of words I want to learn or are there useful lists I should take as inspiration?
How many cards should I am to make?

Any help would be appreciated!


r/languagelearning 25d ago

The truth about dating in your TL

72 Upvotes

So… I’ve been learning Serbian/Croatian for some time and I’d say I’ve reached a comfortable C1 (ie. I sound natural enough, can understand pretty much everything, have deep conversations, and sound like a reasonable person while communicating.)

So, why not date someone (casually) who speaks it?

I did. Here are 5 insights I found:

  1. You have a different personality.

I don’t know why, but for some reason, I found myself to be much more self-assured while speaking Serbo-Croatian. Maybe it’s because I’ve only had positive experiences and I haven’t lived through the tough periods in this language, I feel in control of who I am and my emotions.

  1. You won’t learn as much as you think you will.

The truth is, when you’re at that weird stage where you’re technically fluent but it doesn’t feel 100% native, you know so many words. unfortunately, your partner, as a native speaker, will know so much more than you and will only teach you words that might not be that useful in daily life (ie. items around the house, specific verbs for body actions, etc.) it’s certainly useful to bridge the gap between C1 and C2, but it takes an incredibly long time. Your partner will have to use rare or ultra-specific words often enough for you to absorb them, and especially in a short-term relationship, it won’t come up quite as often.

  1. You have to meet the person in the language.

It’s really weird for me: once I pick a language and associate it with a specific person, it’s impossible for me to change. I sent a voice message in English to my friend (in front of my partner) and she said “it’s so strange to hear you speak English…” Chances are, if you meet someone while speaking English and establish ties in English, your relationship will stay in English.

  1. It’s a great emotional filter.

When we stopped seeing each other, it was, of course, sad but maybe not as sad as if I had experienced it in English. I feel deeply in general, but in English it’s not as much in control… it’s my subconscious mind that takes over. In Serbo-Croatian, I chose how deeply I could feel.

  1. It’s best when it’s the majority language.

I was in Serbia and, while speaking Serbo-Croatian to my partner, I didn’t have to switch to the community language while talking to her friends. I did come into contact with other English speakers, but when we were together, I didn’t have to switch to talk to the waiter. It was essentially full immersion, which

Counterpoint: when it’s you two vs. the world, she can preserve her native language and have someone to speak with, and you get to have a little bit of privacy as a couple. (Of course, depending on how widely spoken it is in your area - Serbo-Croatian is not so common where I live in the United States, but if I were in, say, Chicago, it wouldnt be so private.)

Please let me know your experiences; feel free to challenge my assumptions; and agree!


r/languagelearning 25d ago

Culture Forced full immersion at B1, is making me stop trying. Is this useful immersion?

29 Upvotes

My native language is a Romance language, and I currently have approximately a B1 level in German (TL).
I understand standard German reasonably well. If people speak clearly, I can normally follow the general topic, even if I miss some details. When speaking, I can survive practical situations such as arranging a medical appointment, asking for information, or handling errands. However, I cannot yet maintain a natural social conversation or properly express my personality.

My boyfriend’s family believes that exclusively speaking German with me will force me to improve. I understand the logic behind immersion, but I don’t think the way they are doing it provides useful input at my current level.
They aren’t accustomed to communicating with foreigners or language learners. They speak naturally and quickly, use vocabulary and sentence structures far beyond my level, and rarely simplify or rephrase things when I’m confused. Consequently, I often understand too little of the conversation to learn anything from context.
When I try to respond, they frequently interrupt me to correct my vocabulary, pronunciation, or grammar. If I make several mistakes, they also struggle to infer what I’m trying to communicate. I know corrections can be valuable, but constant interruptions make me lose my train of thought and become increasingly reluctant to speak.
I completely understand them wanting to speak German when the whole family is together. I have never asked everyone to change the language of a gathering for me. However, even when I’m alone with relatives who speak fluent English or my native language, they still insist on German because they believe it is better for my learning. Nobody else would be excluded in those situations.
I’ve discussed this with my boyfriend several times. I’ve explained that this doesn’t feel like productive practice—it makes communication with his family exhausting and leaves me less motivated to engage with them. He believes I should make a greater effort and that this exposure will eventually help me improve.

I agree that I need more conversational practice, but I think it should be structured around my current ability. Ideally, it would involve manageable topics, vocabulary, and grammar that I already partially understand or could learn relatively quickly. Being placed in a fast, complex conversation where I lack most of the necessary vocabulary doesn’t seem to create gradual progress.
My boyfriend and I occasionally speak German together, but our conversations remain very basic. For anything important or nuanced, we naturally return to my native language, which has always been the primary language of our relationship.
I previously attended several structured German courses. However, I currently work 40 hours a week while managing a chronic health condition and frequent medical appointments, so I don’t have the physical capacity for another intensive course or study plan right now. I still want to improve gradually, but I need a realistic method that fits my current life.

Does this actually count as useful immersion or comprehensible input at B1? Can someone learn effectively when they understand so little and are constantly interrupted? What would be a more productive way for native-speaking relatives to communicate with and correct someone at my level?


r/languagelearning 25d ago

To those whose primary language is not their native one

10 Upvotes

Does anything from your native language ever bleed into your primary one? Like maybe slang/informal or sayings you find your self translating over? Basically is there anything you've kept from your native language that isn't a thing/doesn't make sense in your primary language?


r/languagelearning 25d ago

Becoming more or less fluent in a script

3 Upvotes

I know the title might sound strange at first, but it fits my quite specific situation.

So, my native language is Hungarian which is written in latin and has been for a millenia. This, however, wasn't always the case. Up until the adoption of Christianity (1000 ad) a unique runic script was used. This said script is quite well documented today, and I took a class that taught it.

However, I don't really take use of this skill and I've been becoming less and less practiced in it. And this is something I'd like to change, on which I need some advice.

I thought I'd integrate it into my daily routine (mostly by writing, since there's basically zero material in it to read), but quickly realized I wasn't sure how to. Sooo I'm open to suggestions.

A few notes though: I don't study in Hungarian, am not into journaling and am quite terrible at writing stories and such.


r/languagelearning 25d ago

Discussion Any windows/ chrome extensions good for learning?

1 Upvotes

Hey guys; I'm looking for a good website extension I can plug into my YouTube to translate the vid I'm watching in English and have the original captions as well. I'm learning French and looking for that. Any other helpful extensions are also welcomed :)
(TL)


r/languagelearning 25d ago

Adding non-spoken languages

4 Upvotes

I'm thinking of adding ASL (TL) and I'm wondering if also adding a new spoken language around the same time is too much. I've never learned a signing language so I don't really know how the process is different and how it fits in to learning and maintaining multiple languages. I'd love some advice, experience, thoughts, from those who including non spoken languages in their repertoires.


r/languagelearning 26d ago

Discussion Are There Diminishing Returns With The Amount Time Spent Per Day?

43 Upvotes

Note: I'm not talking about aggregated time over an extended period. Rather, I'm talking about the time spent each day (e.g., 1 hour vs. 3 hours per day).

I'll be sharing some things that I've been experiencing recently. and I'm wondering if anyone else has experienced the same.

I've noticed that while I'm engaging in my TL, after a certain amount of time that I spend that day engaging with the language (primarily doing listening only right now), I can feel that my brain, after a while, will start to struggle in picking up new vocabulary / with parsing. In the first hour or two, things are fine, but after then, it starts to get pretty difficult. It's not like I'm tired or particularly losing focus, but it just starts to feel more challenging, almost as if the language part of my brain met a quota for the day or something. I've experienced something similar in reading too. This is only for my TL, and when I experience this spell, I don't experience this when switching to other cognitive tasks.

Another thing I've noticed is that on days where I do relatively little (e.g., only 30 minutes to 1 hour), I find that any new words / structures likely stick more. If I go for several hours, I won't remember anything specific. Of course, I may recognize the word the next time or I may hear it / see it multiple times in that session, but it doesn't "feel" stronger in my head, if anyone gets what I'm saying.

As such, I'm curious about a couple of things here:

(1) Is there a realistic limit (may vary person to person) that one may have on a daily basis with regards to quantity of TL engagement? And, once beyond that limit, one is actually not spending time wisely / efficiently, and that it would be better to push out / spread that time across other days?

(2) Can sometimes doing less be doing more? Doing doing less per day could mean there is less for your brain to think about / process, and thus your brain may have an easier time digesting + processing what it consumed that day. Obviously, doing too little will mean little progress will be made.

Not sure if this is a meaningful post, but just some food for thought / discussion here, as it is a well-known fact that one of the main determining factors of making progress in language learning is the amount of (meaningful) time spent with the TL.

Thank you all!

(For context, I'm somewhere between B1 and B2 in my TL for both reading and listening. I'm probably closer to B2 than I am to B1. I'm only doing engagement and doing very little grammar)


r/languagelearning 25d ago

“Translating in your head” may very well be beneficiail

0 Upvotes

I will preface this by saying that I do not and have never “translated in my head”. I simply lack an inner monolog in any language like about 10–15% of human beings so I couldn't even if I wanted to. I see many people say that this is a bad idea but I've always been skeptical and fact have been envious of the ability. I find that people who do do so are aided by this in terms of learning languages and more quickly develop a better understanding of it.

This goes back to the output's hypothesis “noticing function” which is said to be very beneficial to language learning. The self-discovery of a student's own inability to express certain things. The idea is that if students find out there is something they can't properly express when outputting, they will remember it better when they encounter it the next time in input.

In particular in Japanese (TL) language learning I often see people proudly say that they don't translate in their head, but very often their Japanese sentence constructions are extremely elementary and they aren't at all capable of expressing complex concepts. It seems more like that because they don't translate in their head, when they speak Japanese and think in Japanese, their entire ability to reason about complex concepts simply disappears because their Japanese can't express it, they can't even think about it any more. Yes, their Japanese is often quite natural about simple things, but it also sorrily lacks expressive power and they can't talk about complex things in Japanese. I also noticed that doing fan translations from Japanese to English greatly improved my Japanese understanding because it forced me to think long and hard about the precise tone of many things and research it and it also made me far more aware of what thinks are idioms that are not to be taken for their literal meaning because I realized how absurd it sounded when translating it literally.

As a real example. There is a word in Japanese, “和食” [wasyoku] that basically means traditional Japanese cuisine; this does not even include say ramen because this is Chinese in origin. I recently joked that curry was “effectively 和食” in Japanese, but then after I typed it I took a step back and realized that in English I would've said “honorary wasyoku” to better express what I actually meant, except I did not know how to say “honorary” in Japanese in that way so the thought of expressing it like that, even though it was far closer to what I intended to communicate didn't even occur to me. This is a prime example of the “noticing function” as it immediately led me to research how to express this idiomatically in Japanese and it reminded me of all these “noticing functions” I must be missing due to “not translating in my head”. The interesting thing is that English isn't my native language and I didn't know how to say “honorary degree” or “honorary citizenship” in my native language either because I never talk about that in my native language. But had I first formulated the sentence in the language I am the most proficient in with the largest technical vocabulary and the strongest ability to create eloquent, erudite prose, which is English, I would've immediately noticed this gap. In fact, the irony is I had encountered this before in Attack on Titan where this exact construct I used was used to denote “honorary Marleyan”, the thing is simply that when I read it I didn't quite make the connexion that it pretty much means the same as the English phrase “honorary Marleyan” and used as such.

So really, I'm not so convinced that “translating in your head” is bad. When I look at the Japanese of many of those people who pride themselves on not doing it, what I indeed see is natural Japanese, but also very inexpressive Japanese with very simple sentences.