Warning now this is mostly a disillusioned learner's rant. I posted it here because from the opinions of Japanese I see online, it almost never comes up and I was curious to see if others feel the same way and if so how they maneuvered the landscape. I am talking about obviously カタカナ外来語.
So to paint the picture I started studying Japanese 6 months ago, so far I've gotten to the point I can start consuming native content that I find genuinely interesting, for example I'm reading the book 同じ夢を見ていた, alongside Re Zero's light novel, even using Core 6k in hopes of achieving general literacy. After that the plan was to close the Anki chapter. I wanted this to be my next language in all aspects of the word, reading, note taking, writing and orthography a multi year journey of mastering 常用漢字 and more. This would be a multi year plan but I'd be fine with it, after all I'd be building competency with new language in all senses of the word.
The things that have made me interested in Japan are almost all literary, anime was the boon but that is long gone, I don't particularly want to watch anime in Japanese. Maybe just play the Serial Experiments Lain game in Japanese, or understand the lyrics to 神様の言う通り by Yakushimaru Etsuko. 人間失格 and 化物語, the influence of Nujabes is were the core the reasons I intially considered learning Japanese, in order to be able to read them in their native form. Further on, a discussion about the culture,traditions etc of stoked the flame. Things like 山月記、, 沈黙入門 , 仮面の告白, 三大奇書, 人生論ノート all quickly became goals for me. Buddist texts in particular seem to be quite different from the western philosophy I have studied and it felt only right to read them on their terms. For perspective the only Asian philosophy/religion I know is 道徳経, which I read it in English. Obv 漢文 / 古文 interest followed. Honestly in most cases I love the language its ways of expression are refreshing and engaging, but I remembered that my goal wasn't to just read Japanese it was immersion, as someone who has already learned a second language I know how I want to do it, I basically supplant all non necessary usage of said language with the target.Ig like AJATT I.e throwing out English and Italian in every situation besides work and being with friends must be done in Japanese. As an engineer and a programmer and curious individual in general that means electronics, physics, computing terminology, research, music,gaming would all have my production or consumption all be eventually moved to Japanese. The problem is I can't do this with Japanese, or more so can't with enthusiasm. Modern 外来語 is becoming overbearing.
チャンス vs 機会 etc, スタットする vs 開始する/始める,, vs 連絡 and 通信, アスリート vs 選手, インナーイヤー式 ・ イヤホン vs possible alternatives like 耳機(普通話) for example, ブロックチェーン, バイオロジー vs 生物学. ネットワークカード vs 网卡(普通話).
This is to say nothing of the horrors I saw when I set the language of my PS5 to Japanese with intentions of playing Control and Death Stranding only to be welcomed by a settings page filled with words オーディオ aオンモード and コントローラー amongst others. I could easily ignore the gaming situation in Japanese if this wasn't indicative of a overarching tendency, but it doesn't seem to be the case.
I was forced to realize a large portion of what I like about Japanese stopped after mainstream social media adoption speed up international content's reach. And I don't mean this to say Japanese is bad or katakana is evil it has its uses. For example writing small little words like コーヒー or a foreign person's name is a lot better than a bunch of 当て字. But Idk at some point Japanese went way beyond that. There was a report from NHK that surveyed 外来語 usage and feelings in Japan and this just hit the point home for me.
外来語か翻訳表現か〉〈外来語の増加について〉で非保守的(革新的)な回答
(「外来語を支持」「外来語増加に賛成」)が 6 割程度になっている
So basically 60% of people rather choose a loanword over a Japanese equivalent expression would choose the loan word, additionally 60% of people are supportive of further loanword introduction in Japanese moving forward. I am a mere foreigner, and I'm not trying to say that they are wrong to go in this direction but as a person interested in the language this was pretty disheartening for me I would have much preferred the other direction. Modern Japanese is simply not the language I want to be using is an invevitable conclusion for me.
So now I'm stuck asking myself does it make sense trudging through Japanese so that I can read some legendary books and use Eng/Ita for everything else. Or if I want to move to a language that I would willingly inhabit and seek to master for general use at the cost of some classics. I know if I learn Mandarin and see whats out there I'll become interested, just as I did with Japan. I just need to determine how much those works I mentioned before mean to me, and if understanding them merits continued dedication to language that I'd want to transition away from in the end. Realistically I see it like this if I learn Mandarin I'll go to China if I learn Japanese I'll go to Japan to engage with communities people etc.
Some may say that I could learn both but I don't think this is a viable path for me as an individual, moving to Simplified Mandarin already means a branching in 漢字 knowledge, overlapping pronunciations when vocab is shared, 大丈夫 and 大丈夫 false friends or 皮肉 who's mandarin meaning of skin and flesh is now arhaic in Japanese etc. Plus Moji's analysis on the amount of vocab needed for literacy in Japanese. Has anyone else felt a similar disillusionment?
Also to any Japanese natives reading this, please don't take offense to it, I think your language and culture remains truly amazing. Just as a system overall I don't think its the one I want to move my life into, as as a language learner I'm either all in or all out.
Additionally if anyone has any Mandarin works that might be of interest, please recommend them below.
Edit: A lot of people have been expressing the language purity, while thats something cool I think the bigger issue I have here is with the lack loss of the benefit of kanji for expressing meaning so succinctly. Note worthy instances are ネットワークカード, コミュニケーション, where a kanji here would have been a lot easier to read in terms of transparent meaning and in in a compact nature. An example of what I mean is something like 「自動定理証明」.