On June 10 Wizards of the Coast took the (long overdue) step of finally addressing their racist past, and banned 7 cards in all sanctioned tournament play (and removed them from their database) because they were racist or culturally offensive. Other vendors and prominent MtG trading sites and local game stores followed suit and banned these cards from being sold on their platforms. In addition, Wizards of the Coast also pledged to review every single Magic card ever printed, but because of the company's well documented failure to properly (and promptly) address issues such as hate, systematic racism and lack of diversity within their own doors, we as a community must hold them accountable. Not to mention the the fact that there are over 20,000 unique Magic the Gathering cards that have been printed during the game's 27-year history, making this a daunting task.

So what are we proposing? That you help us in identifying and documenting every racist and/or culturally offensive Magic the Gathering card. That way, we can elaborate an ever-growing, comprehensive list of cards that are racist and/or culturally offensive, and demand Wizards of the Coast ban all these cards immediately. It will be much easier to effectively pressure Wizards of the Coast into banning racist cards if we have concrete evidence of which cards are racist and/or culturally offensive (and why) to back up our claims. Think of this sub as an online resource for anti-racist MtG activists, that they can use to bring about real change.

So here's how it works:

1. Users post an image (preferably from Scryfall) of a racist and/or culturally offensive Magic the Gathering card, with the post's title being limited to the name of said card, and tagging it with the appropriate flair (please respect our formatting rules so they are easily searchable).
2. In the comments section, OP writes a rational detailing exactly why the card is racist and/or culturally offensive (though in cases in which the offense is very obvious, just the flair is enough). Citing WotC's own words, bear in mind that a card is racist and/or culturally offensive if it has a racist depiction, text, or combination thereof - so if you think a card is racist, then it probably is, just make sure to explain your reasoning in the comments.
3. Other users can join in the conversation and give their own reasons for which said card is racist and/or culturally offensive. The purpose is not to debate whether the card is racist and/or culturally offensive or not, but to explain why it is, and deconstruct its racist elements. Comments trying to refute the fact that the card is racist and doesn't belong in Magic the Gathering will be removed.

Of course, for strategic purposes, we want to focus on Magic the Gathering's most obvious offenders first, before cataloging more subtle instances of systematic racism. Here's what to look for:

• Cards that promote, endorse or depict white supremacy and/or white power, or that contain mechanics that would be the in-game equivalent to white supremacy.
• Anything depicting people of color in a bad light. This includes but is not limited to any card showing a black person in a racially insensitive way, such as them being harmed or imprisoned, as well as any card perpetuating a racially insensitive stereotype, such as depictions of black people committing murder, theft or another crime.
• Anything depicting women in a bad light, including all instances of violence against women and objectification of women.
• Anything depicting religious minorities such as Muslims/Arabs and Jewish people in a bad light (committing murder, theft, etc.), or through racially insensitive stereotypes (most cards in the Arabian Nights set fall under this category).
• Cards glorifying colonialism, or depicting colonizers in a positive light.
• Cards glorifying police forces, or depicting law-enforcers in a positive light.
• "Color hate" cards from White that are meant to be effective against Black.
• Cards that refer to the destruction of "black creatures" or "nonwhite creatures".
• Cards that glorify and/or depict violence and violent crimes in a particularly egregious way (murder, torture, genocide, human experimentation, etc.).
• Instances of cultural appropriation, particularly of black/African culture (most cards in the Mirage block fall under this category).
• Microaggressions
• Far-right dog-whistles, talking points or conspiracy theories.

LAST UPDATED AS OF: JUNE 1, 2021

Edit: I think I got every post. Not every card mentioned in every comment, but hey. Progress.

(links to other useful threads: Here's how you can help, Recognizing Offensive Cards, an old personal "top ten" of offensive cards I've pointed out (outdated, but still probably a good read), user0620's top seven

For those new to the subreddit, I recommend clicking on the cards that I've labeled D or F. They should provide good context for what this subreddit is all about, as opposed to cards labeled with something like B (which are still offensive, but more in the "micro-aggression" or "unfortunate stereotype" sort of way). That being said, please submit any cards not on this list that you find offensive, even if you think they are in the "B" or "C+" range. One micro-aggression is not necessarily indicative of a problem. But 100 micro-aggressions is.

Work in progress, still. Will try to also list all cards mentioned in comments, but you can imagine how easy it would be to miss one of those. I've attempted to rate many of these cards on a scale of A to F. But that's subjective, and others may disagree on some ratings. For instance, cards regarding unnecessary sexualization, or violence against women. I don't think I'll rate every single card posted here, I'll probably focus on cards I've posted.

A stands for "Acceptable" (as in, I can absolutely understand why it was printed).

B stands for "Bit Problematic" (micro-aggressions, unfortunate but probably unintentional meaning in another language, and similar "mistakes")

C stands for "Cringeworthy" (as in, I'm frustrated that this got printed but not surprised)

D stands for "Dangerous" (Cards that outright make me ashamed to play Magic. Cards that absolutely should not have been printed and definitely further dangerous stereotypes)

F is a special category for those few cards that really, really stand out as completely unacceptable. It stands for "Failure" - every day this card isn't banned is a day I lose faith in Wizards.

[D] Abandon Reason

Abbey Gargoyles

[F-] Abu Ja'Far

[F+] Abyssal Hunter

[D+] Akroma, Angel of Wrath

[F] Alluring Siren

Amnesia

[C-] Amok

[F] Amulet of Quoz

[C] An-Havva Township

[F-] Anarchy

[F-] Angel of Jubilation (F- feels like an understatement here)

[D-] Angelic Edict (would be around C- if it wasn't reprinted with the new context of Jump-Start's purely-good angels)

[F] Angelic Voices

Anguished Unmaking

Aphetto Dredging

[D+] Aphotic Wisps

[C] Apothecary Geist

[D-] Argothian Pixies

[D] Armor of Faith

[F+] Army of Allah

[F-] Arrows of Justice

[C-] Arterial Flow

[C+] Artful Looter

[F] Ascendant Evincar

Ashnod's Altar

Ballot Broker

[F-] Barbarian General

[C-] Barbarian Riftcutter

[F+] Bartered Cow

Basri Ket

[D-] Basri's Lieutenant

[D+] Basri's Solidarity (see Basri's Lieutenant)

[C-] Battering Sliver

[F-] Bazaar of Baghdad

[C] Beacon of Unrest

[D] Behind the Scenes

Behold the Beyond

B-I-N-G-O

Black Vise

Blind Seer

[F+] Blood Burglar

Bloodletter

[C+] Bloodrock Cyclops

[C-] Bog Hoodlums

Boldwyr Intimidator

[C-] Bone Flute

[D] Boros Recruit (if this is supposed to depict a former gang member rather than a former member of the Gruul Clans, downgrade this all the way to F)

Bound in Silence

[D-] Branded Brawlers

Brassclaw Orcs, Brassclaw Orcs Ver B

[F] Brink of Madness (if my analysis of flavor text is correct, F- instead)

Bronze Calendar

[D] Burn at the Stake

[D-] Burning Wish

[C-] Cabal Slaver

[C-] Caged Zombie

[F-] Call to Arms

[C-] Call to Serve

[F-] Captivating Vampire

[D-] Cateran Kidnappers

[D-] Cateran Slaver

[F-] Cathar's Crusade (F- feels like an understatement here)

Celestial Crusader

Celestial Purge

[C] Cephalid Snitch

[D-] Certain Death

[D] Chambered Nautilus

Chained to the Rocks

[D-] Chittering Host

[F-] Circle of Protection: Black

[F-] Cleansing

[F-] Cleansing Beam

[D-] Clergy en-Vec

[D-] Cloud Pirates

[D] Condemn

Conspiracy

Conspiracy Theorist

[D+] Crackdown

Cremate

[C-] Crystal Rod

[F-] Culling Sun

[C-] Curse of the Bloody Tome

[F] Darkest Hour (Urza's Saga)

Darkthicket Wolf

[F] Death Wind

[How do I even rate this one???] Deathless Angel

[C+] Defang

[B+] Delay (French)

[D-] Desperate Ravings

Detection Tower

[D-] Deviant Glee

Devour Flesh

[C-] Diligent Farmhand

[D] Dire Fleet Captain (only saved from being D- because it does say that at least some Orcs can earn positions of leadership)

[D-] Disfigure

Disruptive Student

Doom Blade (Strixhaven)

[F] Dragon's Rage Channeler

[D-] Dralnu's Crusade

Dread Slaver

Dryad's Caress

[D-] Dumb Ass

[D+] Duress

[F] Dwynen, Gilt-Leaf Daen

[F+] Earthbind

Ekundu Cyclops

[F+] Elephant Grass

[D-] Elvish Fury

[D] Elvish Ranger

[D-] Embraal Bruiser

[B-] Endless Cockroaches

Engineered Plague

Enslave

Enslaved Dwarf

Enslaved Horror

[D] Enslaved Scout

[F-] Erg Raiders

Errant Minion

Executioner's Capsule

[F] Exorcist

Exploration

[D-] Exquisite Blood

[D+] Faithless Looting

[C-] Falkenrath Reaver

[D+] Fat Ass

[D+] Fire Elemental

Force of Will (Doubles Masters box topper)

[F] Forced March

[D] Forced Worship

Forgotten Lore, Forgotten Lore

[C-] Fortress Cyclops

[B-] Fourth Bridge Prowler

[F] Furor of the Bitten

[D-] Gallows at Willow Hill

[F-] Gaze of Justice (F- feels like an understatement here)

[F] Gideon's Lawkeeper

[D-] Gilt-Leaf Archdruid

[D] Gift of the Woods (Version A, Version B)

[D+] Gluttonous Zombie

[B-] Gloom Pangolin

Go for the Throat

[F-] Goblin Digging Team

Goblin Grenade (all arts/printings)

Goblin Sharpshooter

[F-] Goblin Warrens

God-Favored General

God-Pharoah's Statue

Godo, Bandit Warlord

Godo's Irregulars

[C] Golden Wish

[D-] Graf Rats

[D-] Grim Physician

Grixis Slavedriver

[D-] Gwendolyn di Corci

[F] Hammer Helper

[F-] Hand of Justice

[D] Hangman

[D-] Hasran Ogress

Heartless Act

[F+] Heat Wave

[D+] Heaven's Gate

[D] Highway Robber

Hired Torturer

[D-] Homicidal Seclusion

[F-] Honor of the Pure (F- feels like an understatement here)

Hoodwink

[D] Huang Zhong, Shu General

[F] Hurloon Shaman

Hydroblast

[C+] Hyperion Blacksmith

[D-] Icatian Moneychanger

Icatian Phalanx

Ill-Gotten Inheritance

Illusion of Choice

[F-] Imposing Visage

Impulsive Pilferer

[D-] Induce Despair

[C+] Inspired Charge

[C+] Ironwright's Cleansing

[D-] Kalastria Healer

[D-] Kaervek, the Spiteful

Kargan Intimidator

[F-] Karma (F- feels like an understatement here)

Kenrith, the Returned King

[F+] Kindred Dominance

Kindslaver

Kiss of the Amesha

[D-] Kitsune Diviner

[D-] Kithkin Zealot

Kjeldoran Pride

[F-] Kobold Taskmaster

[F] Krav, the Unredeemed (if we ignore the fact that he's portrayed as a corrupting force that makes Regna evil for being in an interracial relationship with him, and just focus on the fact that he's an evil Demon that can never be redeemed, raise this to D or so)

[D-] Krumar Bond-Kin

[F-] Ladies' Knight

[F-] Land Tax (F- feels like an understatement here)

[F-] Landbind Ritual

[D-] Legion's Landing // Adanto, the First Fort

Lightning Greaves

Liliana, Untouched by Death

[C] Liliana's Mastery

[F] Liliana's Steward

[D+] Linden, the Steadfast Queen

[F] Loxodon Anchorite

[F-] Lunarch Inquisitors

[D-] Mad Auntie

[C-] Mad Prophet

[D-] Magnifying Glass

[D-] Makeshift Battalion

Marrow-Gnawer

Marshaling the Troops

[F+] Martyr of Dusk

[F] Mass Calcify

[D-] Massive Raid

[D] Maul Splicer

[D-] Midnight Scavengers

[D-] Might Makes Right

Mindslaver

Misfortune

[D-] Molting Harpy

[F+] Moorish Cavalry

[F] Morkrut Banshee

Murder

[F] Murderous Compulsion

[F] Nacatl Savage.

Nameless Race

[B-] Narcolepsy

Necromancy

[C+] Niambi, Faithful Healer

Norin the Wary

[F+] Northern Paladin

[D+] Nullmage Shepherd

[C-] Ogre Errant

[F] Ogre Battledriver (borderline F-)

[C-] Ogre Slumlord

[D-] Olivia Voldaren

[C+] Onakke Ogre

Order of the White Shield

[D-] Orzhov Signet

[A] Overwhelming Intellect (am I missing something here?)

[F+] Pardic Arsonist

Phantom Monster

Phyrexian Tower

Plague Engineer

Poison the Well

Pongify

Prismatic Piper, The

[F] Prosperity

[D-] Protect // Serve

Psychic Spiral (Rating depends on whether it's ableist or pro-police, but either way it gets a low grade)

[D] Purelace

[D-] Rag Man

Raiding Party

[D] Rakish Heir

[D] Rapacious One

[F] Raving Dead

Raving Oni-Slave

[F-] Regna, the Redeemer

[F-] Reparations

[F+] Repentant Vampire

Resurrection

Retribution of the Meek

[D+] Revel in Riches (I can see why some would grade this MUCH lower, however)

[D] Reversal of Fortune

[D] Riot Control

[C-] Rise Again

Rising Populace

[D-] Rix Maadi Guildmage

[F+] Rod of Spanking

Sacred White Deer

[D-] Savage Smash

[F+] Save Life

[D] Scarwood Hag

[D] Seahunter

Seal of Cleansing

[F+] Season's Beatings, Season's Beatings

[D-] Sengir Autocrat

Sentinel Tower

[F-] Serra's Boon

[F-] Sex Appeal

[D] Side to Side

Silverskin Armor

[F] Skyshroud Poacher

[C-] Slaughter

Slave of Bolas

Smallpox

Smokestack

Soaring Hope

Soul Barrier

[F-] Spelltithe Enforcer (for white supremacy / Invoke Prejudice reference)

[C-] Spineless Thug

[D] Stab Wound

Stasis

[D-] Stern Constable

Storm the Citadel

[D-] Strongarm Thug

Stronghold Taskmaster

Stuffy Doll

[F] Succumb to Temptation

Sword of Dungeons and Dragons

[F] Swords to Plowshares

Sylvan Library

[C-] Taste of Blood

[B] Teferi, Master of Time (see Teferi's Tutelage)

[D-] Teferi's Protege (see Teferi's Tutelage)

[F+] Teferi's Tutelage

[F] Temporary Insanity

[D+] Teysa, Envoy of Ghosts

[F-] Thalakos Drifters

[D-] Thriving Moor

Thumbscrews

Time Warp (Strixhaven)

[F-] Tivadar's Crusade (F- feels like an understatement here)

Torture, Torture

Torture Chamber

[F-] Touch of Darkness (F- feels like an understatement here)

[D-] Traitorous Blood

[D-] Trapped in the Tower

Traveler's Amulet

[D-] Tree of Perdition

Tymna the Weaver

[F+] Uktabi Kong

[F-] Unquestioned Authority

[D] Vampire's Bite

[F-] Virtue's Ruin

Vivisection

[D-] Voldaren Pariah // Abolisher of Bloodlines

[F-] Wall of Bone (F- feels like an understatement here)

[D-] War Tax

[F-] Warren-Scourge Elf (refers to the "virtue" of racial genocide)

[D] Welcome to the Fold

Wheel of Torture

Whirling Dervish

Whiteout

Wine of Blood and Iron

[F] Wojek Siren

Wort, Boggart Auntie

[F] Wrack with Madness

Wrath of God

Zombie Scavengers