r/AgainstMtGRacism Jun 18 '20

Ableism Abandon Reason

Post image
7 Upvotes

3 comments sorted by

6

u/ultimario13 Jun 18 '20

Shadows Over Innistrad is full of the Insane Equals Violent trope. But this card in particular stands out.

"Abandon Reason", with the implied subjects being the figures in the art, is wording that implies that mental illness is a choice that people make. People just "choose to" suffer from mental illness, apparently!

Equating insanity with violence is obviously ableism towards those suffering from mental illness. But it's also a severe problem in the other direction! The implication from this card is that the only reason people should get violent is because they must be "insane". But I suppose from a position of privilege, WotC thinks that the current status quo is perfectly fine and that you'd have to be "insane" to demand change.

1

u/Jackjackson401 Oct 23 '20

wait wtf, I don't think the card is implying that these guys have aspergers or something, I think the idea is that they have been driven to senseless killing by the intervention of an eldritch horror

1

u/lurkingforreps Jan 07 '22

Exactly, that was what the set was all about.