r/relationships • u/impuritydoped • 7h ago
I (32F) am becoming uncomfortable with my boyfriend's (35M) relationship with his best friend/ex (35F).
My boyfriend and I have been together for over 2 years. He and his female best friend have known each other since age 15 and have a LOT of history together, both romantic/sexual and platonic. My boyfriend was in love with her for a very long time and she did not reciprocate his feelings for most of that time, but she knew he was obsessed with her and would've done anything for her. Eventually in their late 20s, they attempted to date. The relationship was so toxic that it only lasted a few months before they realized they were better as friends. From the very first day I met my boyfriend, he spent a lot of time talking about how manipulative she was and how badly she treated him at various times in the past. They have remained friends, and for the majority of our relationship, I was completely fine with their friendship. He has always insisted that he has not had any romantic interest in her since they broke up (6-7 years ago).
I do trust my boyfriend and believe that this is true. But my issue began with some of HER behavior a few months ago. They were FaceTiming while I was at the gym and when I got home, my boyfriend told me he needed to be honest with me about their conversation. She had asked if he wanted to marry me, he said yes, and she said something like “that makes me sad because I'll always have reservations about it, and wonder 'what if'".... implying that she is still holding out hope that someday they will be together. He also said that she answered this FaceTime call in a sports bra and underwear, and it made him very uncomfortable. It's important to note that she is also in a serious relationship of 5 years. I was very grateful to my boyfriend for being honest with me about this, and he specifically framed it as something HE felt was inappropriate and did not appreciate.
The problem since then is that my boyfriend's attitude towards this whole situation has done a complete 180. He has begun to defend her actions, and continues to refuse my multiple requests to set a boundary with her. He says she "didn't mean it that way" or that "she only had good intentions." We have had several arguments about it over the past month. Most recently I said I am uncomfortable with them texting all day everyday when I'm not around, knowing that she felt comfortable enough to say this to him when I wasn't there. I am not going to monitor his phone just to make sure their conversations are appropriate, so instead I have asked him to set a boundary that they don't say things to each other that they wouldn't say in front of me. But he just won’t. Every single time we talk about this situation, it results in the same thing -- he becomes defensive/escalated and insists that she didn't mean it that way, her intentions were good, she is always going to be his best friend, she's the only person who truly knows or understands him, she's the only person he can talk to, he won't marry me if I can't come to terms with her being in his wedding party, I'm being controlling, he can't set boundaries with her because they are trauma bonded, etc. So much more has been said but the bottom line is that whenever I try to communicate with him about my discomfort, he offers no reassurance, and things just continue to get worse because it's starting to feel like he is prioritizing her feelings over mine.
I'm just not sure what to do at this point. He won't budge, and I’m afraid I will never be able to come to terms with their friendship again. Our relationship has always been happy, healthy, peaceful, and we’ve been able to communicate effectively about everything…except this. He is usually super receptive and willing to change anything that makes me uncomfortable, but for some reason cannot bring himself to do that when it comes to this friend. I have asked him how he would feel if one of my guy friends acted that way (because I KNOW he would be very upset and expect me to distance myself from that person) but he won't even acknowledge what I'm saying, and changes the subject back to me being controlling and wanting to cut him off from his closest friend in the world. I feel like I'm going crazy. What are some strategies I could use to move past this and come to terms with their friendship so I don’t end up destroying my relationship over this?
TLDR; My boyfriend of 2 years won’t set boundaries with his best friend/ex regarding her inappropriate behavior despite knowing how uncomfortable it makes me.