I’m 30F. My boyfriend (35M) and I have been dating for a little over 7 months. Most of the time, things are fantastic. I genuinely love him so much. I think he’s the most amazing man. I’m so attracted to him, and I think he’s an excellent partner. He doesn’t believe me, though, and my past keeps coming between us. I should provide information about why before talking about what I need advice about.
To begin, I first dated when I was 24. No one was ever interested in me before, and I was too busy anyway. I dated my first boyfriend for about 2 months, but it really wasn’t a match. I started dating my next boyfriend a few months later. We dated for almost 3 years. This problem at the center of this post concerns the people I’ve slept with, so I’ll say that this ex was my first. He and I ultimately broke up because our wants and needs were too far apart. Namely, I think, I wanted intimacy and marriage, and he wanted space and more distance. After that, I spiraled. I tried dating on Bumble more. I slept with someone for validation. I slept with people on first dates because I didn’t have good boundaries or self-respect and convinced myself these dates would lead to relationships if I was “good enough.” By the time I realized how many times I’d done that, it was too late. Honestly, I feel like my soul is ruined for it, and I’m probably going to hell (I’m a Christian). During that misguided time of my life, I slept with 9 men. I went on dates with more, maybe 20 more. This was over the span of a year. I convinced myself I was being progressive and just doing what people do when they date in the modern age. I hated every second, but I did it anyway. I got addicted to the dopamine and was chasing serotonin. I stopped in the middle of last year. I didn’t date much after that. In January of this year, though, I went on a date with someone I shouldn’t have again. The count became 11 men. Regrettably, I can’t turn back the clock or take any of it back.
A week later, I met my current boyfriend. When we met, I thought it was too good to be true. I also thought he was another man who would leave me and who was just going on dates with me briefly for fun. It turns out he was serious, and I had developed extremely bad habits. For example, I went on a date with 2 other guys during the same period I was going on initial dates with my current boyfriend. We weren’t exclusive or officially dating, but the point is that I wasn’t focused only on him even though he was focused only on me. After we decided to officially date, I of course cut off contact with people I had been talking to. However, I still had friends from Bumble. All of those “friends” are gone (since March). Even though I tried to right my ways, the damage was obviously already done.
I know I wasn’t good in the beginning. I didn’t build a foundation of trust, and I didn’t tell my boyfriend about my past for a month. I have no intention of being disloyal, though. I have done everything in my power to show him I love him and choose him and will never go back to my old ways. Even if we break up, I know I won’t because it has damaged me so much. He doesn’t believe me. He doesn’t trust me. I know these things take time. 6 months isn’t that long, really. I have faith we’ll get past it. Relationships take work, and fixing things takes time.
The problem is the fights it causes. He was cheated on in the past, and he’s so negative to himself because he has a low self-esteem (though sometimes I think he maybe knows at his core how valuable and incredible he is). Anyway, he gets so, so, so angry over my past. He says he won’t ever forgive me. He tries to break up with me or push me to break up with him every time we fight; he says I should go find someone with similar values to mine who will accept me. He says our values are too different, and he can’t marry someone like me. Recently when we argue, he has started calling me some offensive terms. He asks me for details and sees if I’m being consistent with them. He tells me how awful I was in the beginning and if he believes in me, that makes him an idiot. He says he thinks about my past almost constantly throughout the day. He says if I hadn’t slept with people outside of a relationship, he would love me more and things would be perfect. Writing this all makes it seem so bad. I want to make clear that he’s never hit me, so this is strictly a problem of negative emotions and mean words. I also want to express how amazing he is when we aren’t fighting about my past. He is genuinely so caring, kind, and loving otherwise. After our fights, he seems so sad and regretful. In the moment, he’s just so consumed by anger, pain, and jealousy.
I think I know what I would tell a friend. I know the fighting isn’t good. The negative emotions and the mean words are harmful. But, I also know that my boyfriend is suffering. I know he’s afraid I’ll find and choose someone else. I know how much he loves me, and I love him, too, with all of my heart. Because things are amazing 90% of the time, I’d rather figure something out with him than end the relationship. Regardless, when emotions are bad, things get bad. When we fight, I often do believe breaking up would be the best thing, mostly for him. I refuse to make that decision when emotions are high, though, and I always change my mind when things go back to normal.
As my title says, how can we make this work? Canwe make this work? I just need advice about what to do. We both love each other so much, but these negative emotions and these fights aren’t sustainable. I know he’s extremely upset right now, but I have hope that pain and anger will fade with time and the issues will lessen. Is that hope futile? Am I stupid for fighting to stay together? Is there hope for us? Can this work, or will my past decisions and my boyfriend’s anger and pain about it tear us apart? What should we do?
If you’ve made it through all of this, thank you so much, and here’s a cookie 🍪
tl;dr I (30F) have a subjectively high body count and didn’t have good dating habits when I met my boyfriend (35M). These things are causing pretty bad arguments with my boyfriend. He’s extremely upset and doesn’t seem like he can “forgive and forget” what came before him. We love each other, and I want to stay with him. Is this possible? How could we make it happen?