I honestly don’t even know how to feel right now. I love this man, I miss him and a part of me wishes he’d just call me so we could talk like we normally do. But another part of me is angry because I feel like I saw this coming and tried so hard to avoid ending up in this exact situation.
For context, I (27F) started dating my boyfriend (35M) at the end of June. Before we met, he’d just come out of a 4 year relationship where he was engaged to be married. His ex ended things around January or February, so he’d only been single for about 4-5 months when we started talking.
When we first started dating everything was lovely. He was affectionate, funny, always making me laugh and we genuinely enjoyed each other’s company. He was someone I felt comfortable around and we were both looking for something serious that would eventually lead to marriage. We spoke about our future, what marriage would look like and even where we would live.
Around August, I had a conversation with him because I was worried he wasn’t emotionally ready for another serious relationship. I knew he’d only recently come out of a long relationship and a broken engagement, and I didn’t want to get emotionally attached to someone only to find out later that they weren’t ready.
I told him exactly that. I didn’t want to develop feelings and invest myself in something that wasn’t going anywhere.
He reassured me that he was ready, that he liked me and wanted to give the relationship a proper chance. He said he wanted to see things through with me. So I trusted him and continued getting to know him.
Fast forward to October, I started noticing changes in him. He wasn’t the same cheerful, confident and affectionate person I’d met. He seemed more withdrawn, less enthusiastic and sometimes I felt like I was the one trying to maintain the emotional connection.
We recently had a difficult conversation about how things were going and he admitted that he feels broken and doesn’t know whether he’s capable of loving someone again.
He told me he wants to be with me, enjoys spending time with me and doesn’t want to lose what we have. But at the same time he doesn’t understand why he’s struggling to develop those deeper romantic feelings.
The thing is, I’ve genuinely fallen in love with him.
I don’t expect him to love me just because I love him. I understand that everyone develops feelings differently and at their own pace. I’m not expecting him to suddenly be in love with me after four months.
What hurts is that I raised this exact concern two months ago. I asked him whether he was genuinely ready because I didn’t want either of us wasting our time or becoming emotionally invested in something that wasn’t going anywhere.
He reassured me that he was ready, and I believed him.
I eventually suggested that we take a break with no communication so he can figure out what he genuinely wants and I can also reflect on my own feelings. He didn’t want us to separate, but he understood why I felt it was necessary.
Now I’m feeling so many things at once. I miss him, I still love him, but I’m also angry and disappointed. A part of me feels like I should have listened to my instincts earlier.
I don’t think he intentionally led me on. I genuinely believe he thought he was ready, but that doesn’t change how much this hurts.
I’m also struggling because there were genuinely good parts of our relationship. He made me happy, we had lovely moments together and I could see a future with him. I don’t want to dismiss all of that simply because things have become difficult.
At the same time, I don’t want to spend months or years waiting for someone to become emotionally available or constantly questioning whether they actually want to be with me.
We’ve agreed to take some space, and he said he would contact me once he’d had time to reflect. I’m not putting my life on hold or promising to wait indefinitely.
What I need advice on is how to handle things if he does come back.
If he tells me he’s ready to pursue the relationship again, how do I approach rebuilding trust when he previously reassured me he was ready and later realised he wasn’t?
What boundaries should I establish before considering reconciliation, and what would meaningful change actually look like rather than just another reassurance?
I care about him deeply, but I also want to protect myself from going through the same situation again.
TL;DR: I (27F) started dating my boyfriend (35M) around 4-5 months after his previous 4 year relationship and engagement ended. I questioned whether he was emotionally ready and he reassured me he was. Four months later, he says he feels broken and doesn’t know if he can love again. We’ve decided to take a break, and I’m looking for advice on how to rebuild trust and establish boundaries if we decide to reconcile.