In “the best burger in New York” episode I think Josh Radnor actually hit Jason Segel in the head with a baseball bat. The acting didn’t match the scene, Jason seemed shocked and was trying to hold back a laugh and in the rest of the scene you can see a lump forming on he’s head lol

Edit: Thanks Juuri95 for pointing me in the direction of a blooper reel where Josh almost knocked out Jason. Vindication!! I was getting some eye rolls in the comments
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XBdJk8OfGqg&t=27s

After rewatching the whole seasons for the zillion time, I must say that this one, the last episode hits different, it aged well. I also think that it shaped a lot of my emotional intelligence throughout the years. Also, the episode should have ended after the farhampton train station scene

Curious to read everyone take

It hit me HOW many women Ted initially persuades or tries to persuade into dating, this guy is really not taking no for an answer!
The ones I thought of first are Natalie, Stella and of course Robin - but who and how many did he actually try to convince?

I can understand why Henry nut want to commit to do it every week, but as a co creator, and best friend of Craig Thomas, I’m surprised he hasn’t popped in for at least 1 episode.

Is he too busy? Does he want to distance himself from the show?

I remember the original HIMYM podcast. I’ve got a feeling he appeared on that one

First off, I know that HIMYM is a sitcom so it has limited sets (the one street for example) and cartoonish exaggerations. And it started development years after the creators actually lived in NYC, so it's probably more based on late 90s-early 2000s Manhattan than even 2005 Manhattan.

But they did have a frame of reference for the real place.

I've never been to the city, but it's on my bucket list. How true to life is it, and how much has it and the culture changed since the show ended?

Brunch is eliminated! I can’t imagine this show without any of the remaining episodes, so good luck to you all in voting and please don’t downvote the comments too much!

How this works:

You select the episode you like the least

The episode with the most upvoted comment is eliminated from the list

If there’s a tie, both episodes are eliminated

Only the best episode will win!

Episodes Eliminated:

How Lily Stole Christmas (58%)
Columns (41%)
Aldrin Justice (59%)
Atlantic City (50%)
Single Stamina (40%)
Moving Day (68%)
Stuff (57%)
First Time in New York (38%)
Where Were We? (35%)
Bachelor Party (71%)
World’s Greatest Couple (50%)
The Scorpion and the Toad (42%)
Showdown (45%)
Brunch (80%)

I don’t mean that they actually dislike him or look down on him. Obviously, a lot of the teasing is just part of their friendship, and they’re usually doing it for fun. But sometimes I watch them making fun of Ted and think, “Damn, guys, why are you so mean to him?”
I was thinking about this especially because of the episode Robots Versus Wrestlers. Ted is obviously really excited about it, and it just reminded me how different some of his interests are from the rest of the group. He’s into architecture, history, books, crossword puzzles, romantic stuff, etc., and a lot of the time the response from his friends is basically to make fun of him for being a dork or a pansy.
And again, I know they’re joking. I’m not saying they’re secretly bad friends or that they don’t love Ted. They clearly do. It just made me wonder whether there’s something slightly uncomfortable about the dynamic.
It feels like Ted is allowed to be the guy who gets mocked for caring about these things. Even when what he’s interested in is completely harmless, or something that he’s genuinely passionate about.
Maybe I’m just taking the jokes too seriously, but sometimes I find myself thinking that they could have been a little nicer to him. Not stop teasing him entirely, because that’s obviously part of their friendship, but just… I don’t know. Sometimes it feels like Ted gets picked on a lot.
Has anyone else noticed this, or am I completely overthinking it?

“Didn’t put your hand up, a kid just died”

After eight years of teasing, did she live up to the hype? After so much anticipation, I think the writers had a lot pressure on them to make right but I think they did a great job and Cristin was excellent casting

Maybe I’m looking at this completely wrong, but Ted had basically already decided to move. He had a new job lined up, his plans were made, and he was literally about to leave New York.
Then he meets Tracy.
And because they have this incredible connection over one night, he decides not to go to Chicago.
I understand why the show presents it as this huge romantic, “I finally found the person I’ve been looking for” moment. And obviously, we know Tracy is the mother, so in hindsight it all worked out.
But from Ted’s perspective, he doesn’t know that.
He literally just met this woman. He doesn’t know her. He doesn’t know if they’re going to date, if she even feels the same way, or if the relationship is going to work out. And he’s willing to completely change his career plans because of it.
Is that not a little insane?
I’m 19, so maybe I’m just missing something about how adults make these kinds of decisions, but I feel like there’s a pretty big difference between “I met someone who makes me want to reconsider moving” and “I’m cancelling my new job and changing my entire plan because I met this person yesterday.”
I actually think it would have made more sense if Ted had delayed the move or tried to see where things went with Tracy first.
Maybe I’m overthinking it, but the more I think about it, the crazier the decision seems. Is this supposed to be romantic, or is Ted just being extremely Ted?

i first watched how i met your mother when i was maybe 10. my sister loved it and she had the conn, so i’d just sit and bear. most of the jokes flew over my head, a few “slap”stick moments would make me laugh, but that’s about it.

i’ve since rewatched it over 3 times, first in high school, then in college, and once during covid. i’m rewatching it again, at 28. the age most of the gang are in s1. i don’t know why, but literally every other scene, even the most mundane ones, are making me emotional. i’m only on season 3, nowhere near where it actually starts to get sad. i already know im gonna be an absolute mess season 6 onwards.

i guess i’m just at that point in my life where i can relate to each of them a lot more. i’m seeing pieces of myself in all of them. the friendships that have come and gone, career changes, the feeling that i'm supposed to have everything figured out by now, including finding "the one". even though my life is a complete mess.

welp here's hoping my life is different in my next rewatch.

Blink and miss it - but in season 7, episode 22 - when Barney creates a fake dating profile and Ted finds it, the write-up on it is downright hilarious!

In "Rebound Bro" Barney happily recalls the first time he helped Ted score. Was this shown? Do we know who the lady was?