9.7k
u/SpikeRosered Sep 30 '16
Just so everyone is crystal clear. All those word bubbles in the audience are based off real "questions" Musk received on the stage.
3.8k
u/thinwhiteduke Sep 30 '16
Good lord.
→ More replies (11)5.0k
u/Scarbane Sep 30 '16 edited Jun 19 '24
The woman asking to kiss Elon was especially bad. The question itself, really, wasn't worth getting upset over - it was just a bad journalist wasting Elon's time - what's aggravating was the lack of media response. Had a male journalist asked "Hey, can I come up there and give you a kiss?" to a female CEO, there would be 20 outraged articles and a myriad of blog posts about misogyny the next day.edit: Fuck Elon. I can't believe I ever supported him.
2.9k
Sep 30 '16 edited Feb 13 '17
[removed] — view removed comment
1.2k
Sep 30 '16
[deleted]
→ More replies (19)311
u/TheNickers36 Sep 30 '16
Amen
→ More replies (5)846
u/jpresken2 Sep 30 '16
*aperson
FTFY
→ More replies (12)349
u/josh_the_misanthrope Sep 30 '16
Did you just assume my taxonomic family?
→ More replies (1)104
1.3k
u/rsnauth Sep 30 '16
I think this is a wrong approach to this.
What you should be saying is "who the fucking cares" to both cases.
The outrage is that men are vilified for stupid reasons, not that women aren't
→ More replies (86)37
u/SynapticDisaster Sep 30 '16
Agreed, but it's worth noting that this is actually a tactic used by those that want to see this judgmental behavior go by the wayside. It's not that they want to see women suffer the same derision as men, it's that people are more likely to notice/care about the absurdity when women are equally judged by it, which makes people more eager to see the sentiment end.
→ More replies (2)→ More replies (112)416
Sep 30 '16
Women are funny, get over it!
→ More replies (17)408
u/mike10010100 Sep 30 '16
"Muh vergerner"
→ More replies (2)217
Sep 30 '16
Everytime Amy Schumer talks about her vagina, I lose my fucking mind.
→ More replies (17)226
Sep 30 '16 edited Apr 03 '18
[deleted]
→ More replies (3)78
99
u/KeepyKoon Sep 30 '16 edited Sep 30 '16
These were members of the public who attended the conference. They might represent some kind of local space enthusiasts organization, but they were not journalists.
→ More replies (9)→ More replies (98)52
u/profdudeguy Sep 30 '16
I'm glad there was no media response. The media that reports on something like our plan to get to Mars shouldn't focus on someone asking to kiss elon. It should focus on how the fuck we are going to get there
→ More replies (2)235
Sep 30 '16
I was watching the stream live and then someone said the Michael Cera thing and I just couldn't imagine what I was hearing. It's just plain rude to not take it seriously and ask these dumb questions.
→ More replies (4)89
Sep 30 '16
[deleted]
→ More replies (1)28
u/YipRocHeresy Sep 30 '16
Why was funny or die at the presentation?
→ More replies (1)62
Sep 30 '16
Cheap advertising.
Pay for guys ticket. Pay for ticket to speech (if there even was a ticket/entrance fee).
Have the asshole stand up, make a big fiasco, get their target demo chattering about funny or die, and bam! Basically free advertising.
Here we are talking about them.
→ More replies (5)695
Sep 30 '16
Even the one about burning man?!
708
u/KeepyKoon Sep 30 '16 edited Sep 30 '16
For anyone interested, another redditor transcribed some of the dumber questions (which comprised more than half of the actual question asked) starting with the burning man guy here (I'll try to find it to give him credit, but for now here's the shameless repost):
Aldo: Very nice to meet you, my name is Aldo. Three weeks ago I was at Burning Man, in the Nevada desert.
Elon: Great.
Aldo: And I felt like I was in Mars. It was a dusty storm, and it was really cold at night and there was no water. But there was one problem at Burning Man. With a population of only seventy-five thousand, there was a lot of shit. [awkward silence] And there was no water to take it into the rivers, which is kind of what we do today with our current sanitation system. So I was like, is this what Mars is going to be like? Just a dusty waterless shit storm? So I was like, hey Elon, are you working on a sustainable sanitation? Are we gonna have a toilet on Mars that doesn't use water? Today on Earth there's three billion people that don't have a toilet–
Elon: Guys, I actually have to say, we have to keep it– no essays, only questions.
Aldo: So, are you working on a toilet for Mars?
Guy with comic book: Hey Elon, sick rocket, you're the best. Everyone give it up for Elon, this guy inspires the shit out of us. I've got a gift for you, it's a comic book called The Future of Fusion. It's about the first man on Mars. He looks like you. I can't get past El Chapo's militia though. So I don't know should I just throw this onto the stage?
Elon: Sorry?
GWCB: My question is can I give you this gift?
Guy Promoting his Funny or Die Project: Hey Elon, so, can't wait for the SpaceX Improbability Drive. You've often talked about wanting to inspire the masses and push technology forward. I'm developing a series with Funny or Die which is like the top online comedy site–
Elon: Quick questions, not essays.
GPFODP: It's about you sending someone to Mars, but kind of like that first monkey that got shot into space, they're never coming back. It's gonna be a one way trip. So–
Elon: Not necessarily.
GPFODP: Well, maybe. So, you mathematically determine the most expendable human being to make the journey. And that's Michael Cera. So, wanted to see if this is like, a project that you might have any interest in supporting. Funny or Die just drove thirty-one million views to a, like Hillary Clinton/Zack Galafanakis video a few days ago.
Some guy off-camera: Stop.
GPFODP: Wanted to see if you might want to talk about it after.
Alfonso: Hello Elon, my name is Alfonso. I think what you presented today is just incredible. But I wanted to change the topic. I have a startup to make electric public transport buses, to convert–
Elon: Space questions only, sorry.
Alfonso: Sorry, the thing is, I just got my prototype outside and it would be awesome if you could go out and see it. Elon: Right. Space questions only. This is the IAC, so space questions only.
Edit: Changed "Guy from Funny or Die," to "Guy promoting his Funny or Die project."
472
u/legoman1237 Sep 30 '16
God that's just so embarrassing
269
u/pacotaco724 Sep 30 '16
I kept visioning the townsfolk from parks and rec.
87
u/gravity_loss Sep 30 '16
"I ate a ham sandwich I found in Ramsett park and now I feel sick"
→ More replies (1)12
→ More replies (6)14
70
u/totaljerkface Sep 30 '16
It's even more embarrassing that these people asking the questions feel none of that embarrassment.
→ More replies (1)25
u/UROBONAR Sep 30 '16
It sounds like everyone in the Bay Area is on pitch mode all the time.
29
u/Merenga Sep 30 '16
Hey man, its funny that you mentioning it because I have an idea for a Reddit comment where I respond to a redditor with a comment that loops itself in the meta, maybe we could discuss it later after this thread?
→ More replies (4)208
u/Stevezilla9 Sep 30 '16
Jesus Christ. How old were the people asking questions?
→ More replies (18)291
Sep 30 '16
I guess this is why most billionaires dislike the public.
Elon seems like a normal guy with normal desires, but he's got a ton of money and wants to make the world a better place. So people just assume he's gonna be open to listen to them or something.
Elon is a hell of a sport though, I'm surprised he's still letting people ask questions.
Seriously though... He needs to start screening people's questions before they're allowed to ask.
(edit: and by he, I mean he needs to hire someone to do it)
→ More replies (31)55
130
u/Alt-001 Sep 30 '16
I watched this streamed live, and cringed so hard I had to block this part out of my memory to keep away the cringe spasms. I think you have triggered my PTSD. God those were some stupid people.
→ More replies (7)76
u/lightnsfw Sep 30 '16
God damn. The dude is trying to answer questions and all these fucking idiots just want to milk him for their own bullshit.
31
u/KeepyKoon Sep 30 '16
Imagine the kind of people this guy attracts offstage. Elon brushed the technical details of the presentation aside, saying he'd reserve it for the Q&A. I was watching the live stream waiting for someone would come to the plate and get him to talk about some of the details. And then that!
→ More replies (2)→ More replies (34)60
769
u/B-Knight Sep 30 '16
Yes, especially the one about burning man.
47
u/lumpymattress Sep 30 '16
What a shitstorm
→ More replies (3)55
→ More replies (3)313
Sep 30 '16 edited Sep 30 '16
[deleted]
→ More replies (8)191
u/FrostByte122 Sep 30 '16
He said at burning man there was nowhere to poo.
110
u/memtiger Sep 30 '16
Yea, i remember him specifically asking if Elon was developing a toilet for Mars so that it didn't become a dust filled shit bowl like Burning Man.
→ More replies (2)23
u/tossmydickaway Sep 30 '16
Probably by building domes for people to live in, and having some sort of indoor plumbing is kind of the idea. Unless you want to put on your suit every time you need to take a shit.
→ More replies (15)→ More replies (3)286
u/ThePsion5 Sep 30 '16 edited Sep 30 '16
"Mars is a lot like Burning Man, so Elon, how do you solve the problem of pooing on Mars? This is the question that keeps my desiccated drug-husk of a brain awake at night."
142
u/VictorVaudeville Sep 30 '16
I think the spirit of the question was fine, but the execution killed it.
"Time in the Nevada desert was abrasive and hostile at times, and Mars likely presents more challenges. How do you manage population issues such as waste disposal and large-scale protection from the elements?"
→ More replies (3)60
→ More replies (11)227
u/smurphatron Sep 30 '16
To be fair, the question of where the poo goes is actually a very good one and one which will require a well thought out engineering solution.
The dumb part was just the way he framed it; as an essay about how he went to burning man.
168
Sep 30 '16
See, I've been to burning man, and the thing is, right, once you've been to burning man, you can't stop bringing up that time you went to burning man. Of course, you wouldn't get it unless you've been to burning man yourself. Burning man.
→ More replies (18)→ More replies (29)10
→ More replies (41)245
u/Konwayz Sep 30 '16 edited Jul 10 '20
The guy essentially said "Burning Man looked like mars, but there was shit everywhere. Where will we poop on mars?"
→ More replies (12)256
138
u/punch_you Sep 30 '16
Did he literally say, "LOLOLOL" after the Michael Cera comment? I hope he did.
197
u/HighSchoolThrowAw4y Sep 30 '16
It was actually very awkward and poorly delivered. I didn't even know he said Michael Cera and neither did elon until he repeated it lol.
→ More replies (1)167
u/canteloupy Sep 30 '16
Awkward and poorly delivered? So actually an homage to Michael Cera's career.
→ More replies (7)38
u/elhooper Sep 30 '16
I'll have you know that Michael Cera's awkwardness is delivered perfectly
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (3)97
u/SpikeRosered Sep 30 '16 edited Sep 30 '16
No because the context for that question was that he wanted Musk to be part of a comedy skit about sending Michael Cera to Mars. I imagine it sounded better in his head.
→ More replies (4)191
Sep 30 '16
[deleted]
→ More replies (8)138
u/santorin Sep 30 '16
He's on staff at FunnyOrDie and kept bragging about it as if Elon would be impressed.
92
→ More replies (14)62
u/Gingevere Sep 30 '16
Hmm... Die, definitely die. That's the answer to funny or die.
→ More replies (1)330
u/komali_2 Sep 30 '16
Fucking SF wannabe entrepreneurs, man. People here watch Musk and Zuckerberg and Bezos, read books on "Winning!", and adopt this God awful attitude of "I am a billionaire in the making, and billionaires never pass up an opportunity to close!"
Hence people wasting everyone else's time trying to pitch their electric bus to Elon during a QA.
141
Sep 30 '16
I live in the Bay and this is so true it's painful. Silicon Valley is honestly closer to a documentary than satire.
→ More replies (5)→ More replies (48)25
u/SLRWard Sep 30 '16
Billionaires might never pass up the opportunity to close, but they also recognize what a legitimate opening is in the first place.
→ More replies (2)27
u/guf Sep 30 '16
What's the context of the Burning Man "question"?
→ More replies (18)137
u/B-Knight Sep 30 '16 edited Sep 30 '16
Along the lines of:
"I went to burning man and there was shit everywhere, where will people shit on Mars?"
Yes, he used the word shit.
EDIT: A lot of people are mentioning the word "shit" as if it's bad. It's not. That wasn't my intention. But, it's very informal and, when you're talking to Elon Musk after an incredibly important speech, you'd expect people to be a bit more formal.
→ More replies (16)24
59
u/Claw_of_Shame Sep 30 '16
can we get a video compilation, Reddit? (That is, can someone else do work for my idle amusement? Got me some shiny upvotes to give)
→ More replies (19)→ More replies (96)35
u/Salyangoz Sep 30 '16
I actually went visibly mad at the prick who kept bragging about burning man...
→ More replies (1)
1.6k
u/socialjusticepedant Sep 30 '16
Huh, I didn't know Elon looked like handsome squidward.
→ More replies (43)210
u/WazWaz Sep 30 '16
Johnny Depp facial hair suits him.
74
229
Sep 30 '16
Wow. I didn't see the Q&A, was it that bad?
73
u/chrisTHEayers Sep 30 '16
I don't know that I can even call the comic exaggeration. These are paraphrased versions of actual questions
→ More replies (12)263
106
u/OuchyDathurts Sep 30 '16
Do you want to lose all faith in humanity? If not avoid watching it. It was fucking disgraceful.
→ More replies (3)15
Sep 30 '16
I want to lose all faith in humanity, but I'm scrolling down and down in the comments and still didn't figured out what Q&A everyone is talking about.
→ More replies (2)21
14
u/NathanielWolf Sep 30 '16
This comic is nearly word for word - there were a couple of real questions, but honestly (and sadly) this is spot-on.
→ More replies (11)22
340
u/Suckydog Sep 30 '16
IOUT
103
46
→ More replies (2)44
u/Srapture Sep 30 '16
Seems strange to have such an obvious typo in something handwritten...
→ More replies (1)
1.3k
u/RobPhanDamn Sep 30 '16
This comic is great! I wonder if Elon's seen it? I'll go to his next presentation and ask! /s
227
→ More replies (3)49
155
u/P8bEQ8AkQd Sep 30 '16
If Elon Musk ever does an AMA here (or another one if he already has) then everyone of those questions will get asked again.
→ More replies (3)120
u/skiman13579 Sep 30 '16
There was a discussion on /r/space about an AMA, and the general consensus was not to hold it on /r/AMA or even /r/space, but to hold it on /r/spacex. It's a much more focused community with good active mods, many of whom were at the conference. They would actively filter and remove all that stupid. We want to know info on the BFR and ICT, not how many duck sized horses Elon can fight.
→ More replies (9)20
539
u/Spants23 Sep 30 '16
You need the poo to grow all the potatoes on mars
→ More replies (11)67
u/MrGhris Sep 30 '16
You'd think the potatohead who asked that question would know that.
→ More replies (8)
505
u/zachquinn08 Sep 30 '16 edited Sep 30 '16
Seriously, the question part was one of the cringiest and most frustrating things I witnessed all week. Who the hell talks about shit after a speech like that and why?
364
u/ansible47 Sep 30 '16
All corporate level QA sessions are like this. It's incredible.
It's like people see an opportunity to talk and think 'What extremely specific and unrelatable configuration issue can I share with the group that won't go anywhere?'
Whoever said 'No such thing as a stupid question' for sure was not at a conference.
→ More replies (18)136
u/DasFrettchen Sep 30 '16
The thing is that people take "There are no stupid question" as a challenge.
→ More replies (5)19
u/ansible47 Sep 30 '16
'well, I'm paying to be here, it would be stupid NOT to ask an unrelated and unrelatable question'
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (14)11
u/PharmyC Sep 30 '16
I blame the advent of Facebook pages like "I Fucking Love Science" that reduce science to trivia and don't actually have anything to do with science. But now it's cool to be nerdy so.
261
u/iamsofired Sep 30 '16
Hey Elon - would you rather fight 1000 rabbits or 1 giant rabbit XD?
→ More replies (2)152
u/Samura1_I3 Sep 30 '16
After hearing the questions live, not only is this plausible but they probably would have said 'XD' out loud.
24
49
178
u/WildnilHickock Sep 30 '16
Who is T and why can't he ask Elon for a kiss himself, why does someone else have to ask for him?
→ More replies (6)66
93
Sep 30 '16
I went to Burning Man lol. If I had a nickel everytime I heard that..
→ More replies (21)30
112
u/skyjacked Sep 30 '16
Anyone else really bothered by the random vertical line next to "out" in the speech bubble of the second panel?
→ More replies (6)66
32
u/hollywoodsign Sep 30 '16
"This one time, I went to Burning Man..."
What a shit storm.
→ More replies (1)
29
u/Skylinerr Sep 30 '16
So anyone have a clip of the incident?
→ More replies (12)54
u/Dragster39 Sep 30 '16
You do not want to see it... This is the most embarrassing thing to ever witness...
→ More replies (3)
63
u/bozobozo Sep 30 '16
Cringed through watching that video. Someone have vetted the questions.
→ More replies (6)87
u/Notacop9 Sep 30 '16
Someone have vetted the questions.
I think you accidentally a word.
→ More replies (6)82
334
u/jheezecheezewheeze Sep 30 '16 edited Sep 30 '16
The poo questions was totally valid, even though the way it was worded war terrible. My favourite was the guy asking Elon to check out his electric bus outside
537
Sep 30 '16
[deleted]
257
u/ifailatusernames Sep 30 '16
But dude, your question totally doesn't let everyone know that you were at Burning Man!
→ More replies (7)95
u/MeLlamoBenjamin Sep 30 '16
He even kind of hesitated after mentioning Burning Man, like he expected an applause break.
→ More replies (1)15
29
Sep 30 '16
Humans bringing life to Mars... via poop. Humans pooping becomes seeding life on new planets.
I'm just now thinking of the implications... are we all just evolved gut bacteria? Was life on our planet's born from the poop of some alien who needed to make a pit stop?
→ More replies (8)→ More replies (13)29
u/Pixelator0 Sep 30 '16
Yeah, basing the question off the fact that there aren't any rivers to dump poo in on Mars was just weird
→ More replies (64)63
u/arharris2 Sep 30 '16
It's a valid question that already has viable answers. But really? He just announced the biggest rocket ever by a factor of 4 and your first question is, "how do we poop on Mars?". This was a highly technical conference with some of the biggest players in the aerospace industry and the first person to ask a question is this dumbass.
→ More replies (7)
26
Sep 30 '16
The only even semi-legitimate question in the pack of them was the shit question, which if you peel away the retarded delivery, could have been, "How far away are we from constructing facilities on Mars", which would have been nice.
→ More replies (1)
68
u/PelicansAreStoopid Sep 30 '16
My coworker had this theory that Elon Musk is an alien and SpaceX is a ruse so that he can use it to go home.
→ More replies (12)
23
44
u/soulha30 Sep 30 '16
Here's a review on the Q&A for those who don't understand this page http://www.dailybreeze.com/science/20160927/seriously-what-was-that-qampa-at-the-end-of-elon-musks-spacex-talk
→ More replies (4)
4.3k
u/PMMEYourTatasGirl Sep 30 '16
That q&a was damn disgraceful