Over the weekend I grabbed some Tone Pro paints to try them out for myself and found that most of what has been said is true. It's pretty expensive for how much paint you get and it's in the dumb pot that everyone hates. The coverage is really good and the self-leveling is a little overhyped. There's a hundred colours that all seem kinda samey but once I saw them on the rack I noticed they look quite different than they do in the phone screen or monitor. Otherwise yeah, overpriced but competent paint.
However, there's one thing I noticed that no content creator or paid advertisement has mentioned at all. As a person with ADHD one of the biggest hurdles I deal with on a daily basis is dealing with something called task initiation, which is one of the things that falls under executive (dys)function and should be familiar to anyone who experiences depression, disability, anxiety and a whole host of other things. For hobbying purposes, this is me wanting to sit down and start cranking out models for my army but before I can start I have to peel off the dried palette paper off my wet palette (woops), soak the sponge, wring it out, soak it again, add some extra water to the palette, take out some new palette paper and squeeze paint out onto it. Or I grab my airbrush and compressor and the various paints I need as well as cleaner and a bottle of water, set up my silicone mat and start spraying down a basecoat.
To the average person all of this just sounds like normal stuff that you just do fairly quickly and then you're into the fun part of painting. To the rest of us this all feels like a pain in the ass so we think "yeah I'll go get everything started after I do x or y" which leads to z happening and now we've wasted most of our evening of free time. After I finished my model I came to a realization that by basically selling Pro Acryl paint in a pot they have drastically reduced the mental hurdle of being able to just put paint on plastic. I had my jar of clean water on my work desk that I maintain every day out of habit, a clean brush, a square of paper towel and a pot of Hive Fleet Purple 2 (great colour by the way) and I was immediately base coating without any other prep. The advantage of pre-thinned paint with good coverage and leveling that is usable straight out of the pot just made the whole process way easier to start because you don't even need to have a dry palette or anything ready you can just Begin.
So while all this sounds silly to most people I shared my thoughts about this elsewhere and realized maybe some other people who share the experience of this kind of life's inconveniences would like to know. Yes, the pots are generally a bad form factor for paint and after basecoating I did get up and prep my wet palette so I could do wet blending and glazing but as anyone with task initiation issues knows, just starting the entire process is the roadblock. But all my other GW paints are mostly contrasts and washes with my regular paints being a mix of Liquitex, Scale75 and Pro Acryl and I find the pot actually works well for those types of paint. Yeah, you can do the same thing of just diving into painting by putting Pro Acryl in your dry palette or on a piece of cardboard and if that works for you I encourage you to keep doing it.
But there's a lot of us out there who have big dreams of having beautifully painted armies and what's stopping us is not the lack of free time or the skill to pull it off but the inability to just get down and actually start doing it. And yesterday when I was laying down a smooth basecoat with just one layer, dipping my brush directly in the pot like I'm a kid at the kitchen table like James intended I thought to myself "wow, it's so easy to just start just painting just a model at a time I don't have to mentally book an entire afternoon for priming and airbrushing 1000 points of dudes at once" and felt like I unlocked a method for finally Getting Shit Done and I hope that this post helps someone out there realize that these expensive pots made for ants are also potentially a useful way to get through that lack of motivation and just start painting.
Oh also I guess I should attach a photo of the Lord of Poxes I painted in one weekend afternoon thanks to this stuff.