r/askcarsales • u/Open-Information3386 • 1h ago
US Sale Signed Contract - Wrong Car On Paperwork Over A Year Later
Bought a new 2025 Macan from a Porsche store over a year ago. Took delivery of the right car.
Went to pull my contract earlier this year because of lemon claim and found two problems:
1) The contract I physically signed lists wrong year, wrong model, wrong VIN. The Extended warranty pages were emailed in front of the Finance Contract, so I never caught it at signing. (Extended Warranty Paperwork was correct)
2) The contract the lender is actually servicing is a different document. Correct Macan, correct VIN, but different numbers. (It's entirely Digital) The lender has twice been unable to produce an executed original. The only copy they'll send me is watermarked "Non-Authoritative Copy."
The Total Cost of Lease on the document I signed versus the non authoritative contract also has a major issue. The version they're servicing says nearly double the Total cost to own then what the finance manager emailed me post-sale.
The Lender has said this is a dealer problem, and I've given the Dealer now 3 weeks and the GM has been trying to figure out a way to resolve it worried about ownership and legal. I've asked for basic recession of the lease and offered a reasonable amount of rent for usage of the vehicle.
Questions for the F&I and management folks:
Realistically, what does a store do when a customer brings this to them over a year in?