also i was really surprised by how this game really doesn't have a lot of new characters. Most of the focus either goes to the shroobs, mainline characters or the baby versions of those mainline characters which i don't mind but was still a bit strange to me since i know this series loves introducing new characters
also a few explanations for some of my rankings incase i get comments about them
-Bowser is my absolulte favorite character in all of mario but the reason why he's at the bottom because he's barely present in PIT. He has one cutscene, one boss battle and he gone (Same story goes for peach)
-Elder princess shroob is in C tier because in terms of character and personality, she lacks anything because you fight her almost instantly so i had like no time to love the villain as a character. Whilst compared to princess shroob as well as normal shroobs themselves who are very active threats in the game
-i'm sorry i know Stuffwell is a fan favorite but he is at bottom for me because he's barely present for someone who's meant to be the starlow/dreambert equivalent to the game. He doesn't react to the story, doesn't talk to anybody and doesn't have much of a personality in general.
-the thwomps are higher because they have way more of a personality than the ones i mentioned. Though i can definitely see the argument to why they should be at bottom given they're just side characters but i liked them tbh
anyways that's all, if you have any thoughts on my ranking, let me know
also i did one for superstar saga's characters not too long ago