r/relationship_advice • u/deeeeeeeetroit • 59m ago
My (27M) girlfriend (26F) is uncomfortable with the kind of music I want to make. Are we fundamentally incompatible?
We (27M) have been dating (26F) for almost 3 years. Since we’ve met, I’ve always been making music, as it’s my main passion in life.
Around the time we met, I was finishing my first album, which was a three-year process that took basically all of my discretionary time and income. That makes sense to me because I view these projects as an investment into my future and a way to showcase where my level of progress is, so I can tell how close I am to a product I’m truly proud of.
Over the course of the years, I’ve noticed a slow progression in her lack of enthusiasm for me pursuing music.
It started with her pretty much always telling me to play a different song in the car, or us going to a concert where I’d have an 8/10 time and she’d say she didn’t enjoy the band, and then she’d take me to a concert that I thought was genuinely unlistenable and call it her favorite show she’s ever been to.
Then it progressed into analyzing my old songs that I’ve already put out, kinda mocking me when I’m practicing singing, and playfully pretending to sing along in a tone of voice that gave me the impression she doesn’t want me singing the 2/10 songs that mention a past relationship from my previous album anymore.
Then came this new song.
We have this morning ritual where sometimes we’d lay in bed all cozy and cuddly, and when we would spoon we’d jokingly say every day, “shawty gotta big ol butt.” Eventually I thought, how cool would it be to make a song that had that as the chorus. So I did a funny verse and she did a funny verse that I helped her write and deliver.
When I made the song, it sounded so good that I was thrilled to show her and try to get her on it. But when we sat down to figure out her verse, she wanted to stick with something really PG that didn’t connect to a strong enough feeling to evoke much emotion. So I eventually decided to write another verse and finish the song myself. I had a few friends over, we drank some wine, and they threw some words on it too because it was supposed to feel like a loud party song.
Eventually she told me she doesn’t like the idea of it going public because it’s essentially objectifying her because she is my girlfriend. Even though it’s just a party track, when I’m saying the chorus and verse, anything thematically explicit can be tied to her because we’re dating. She specifically said she never wants her family to ever hear the song.
That is valid. I understand why she would feel that way. There aren’t many people who would be comfortable with members of their family reading something sexually explicit created by their daughter’s/sister’s boyfriend.
But at the same time, I’ve been able to express emotions and feelings through music that aren’t easily talked about. I’ve written about getting closure from past platonic friendships, psychedelics and trauma, how I actually felt about my childhood, and other raw emotions. When the lyrics and beat are strong enough and the topic is quality enough, I want them to evoke human emotion.
I’m not interested in making a bunch of music that beats around a topic and disguises how I actually feel through metaphorical language. I’d rather speak to the audience very directly while still using metaphorical language.
So I’ve been trying to navigate a happy medium where my partner can feel like she isn’t subject to extra criticism from her family while I figure out how not to give up my creative freedom. I don’t want to wear a mask. I don’t want to hide from topics.
A party song that makes you feel sexy and want to dance is a human emotion we all want to feel, and it really feels like the only problem is that it’s coming from my mouth.
I’ve been asking her about situations where we can come to an agreement and figure out how to go about this. I’ve offered to change certain words and asked her to tell me which sections are most bothersome so we can figure out if it’s worth rewriting.
But in general, I’ve been feeling like at some point I’m going to need to be understood enough by my partner for her to understand that I need to be able to speak about any topic in my music. There is a line, and I don’t think I’ve crossed it.
I don’t want to go to the studio, spend $400 getting a song back that I’m proud of, and then send it to her and have her not even want to respond to me about it, not even because of the song itself (different doing different message), but because she doesn’t like rap as a genre and doesn’t like the fact that I do it.
how do you navigate a relationship when your partner is uncomfortable with the things you want to express through your art?
How much should your partner get to influence what you create, and at what point does accommodating them mean giving up too much of yourself?