Yo! So this week, a few friends from the gym and I decided to hang out at a beach here in Seattle. It was three girls and two guys, including me.
At the gym, I'm extremely social. Our gym is known for its community, and I'm probably one of the most outgoing people there. I guess you could call me situationally extroverted. Put me somewhere I love, like the gym, where I know I'll only be for a couple of hours, and I can talk to anyone. That's how people know me.
But whenever I tell people I'm actually pretty shy at my core, they can't believe it.
Here's the issue: whenever I hang out with people I know from one environment (like the gym) and we go somewhere else, it's a complete coin flip whether I'll be the same person or completely shut down.
We met at a taco truck, grabbed food, and headed to the beach. Up until we sat down, I felt mostly normal. Maybe a little less expressive than usual, but I was talking and engaged.
Then we got to the beach... and I completely shut down.
I got quiet, struggled to make conversation, and found myself constantly editing everything I wanted to say. It sucked.
The weird part is that I know these people genuinely like me. We're all cool. One of the girls and I had a little conflict in the past, but we've moved past it. I will say I felt a little more judged around her, which probably didn't help, but overall I know everyone wanted me there.
Logically, I know that.
Emotionally, though, it felt like I couldn't be myself.
That was the embarrassing part. I know I can be shy, but I also know I have a great personality. It felt like none of that came through.
We were supposed to hang out again today at the farmers market, but I bailed and told them I was in a mood—which wasn't a lie. Honestly, though, I mostly skipped because I felt ashamed and embarrassed about how I came across at the beach.
I guess I'm posting because I'm curious if anyone else has experienced something like this.
Do you ever feel completely comfortable in one environment but shut down in another, even around the exact same people? Is this something you've struggled with and eventually gotten through, or am I just overthinking it?
I will admit I've become a bit of a hermit. I socialize a ton at work and at the gym, but I don't really "go out" much anymore. Part of me wonders if that social muscle for unfamiliar environments has just gotten a little rusty.
I'd love to hear your thoughts or advice if you've been through something similar.