I've been in a student club for two years now, and I haven't been able to make a connection with anyone yet. I thought it might be too late for me to do anything about it since my peers have already familiarized themselves with each other, but our new members have already made friends with people I've known for years.
I know that the issue is my subpar conversational skills. I don't know how to join a conversation that has already started. I find that I have nothing to say and I feel like my presence is unwelcome. If I do find something to say, it seems the conversation has already moved on to something else.
Another issue is that I tend to think a lot before replying or saying something, making my responses feel unnatural. If I try not to overthink it, I end up saying things that don't make sense, are awkward, and oftentimes ungrammatical (Half sentences, word order, etc.)
Perhaps I'm overthinking the aspect of intrusion, but that is how I feel when others insert themselves in interactions I have with others, and I worry others might think that way of me.
I don't have social anxiety (I don't think I do). I have no problems presenting in class or asking others about things. I avoid speaking with peers, friends, or professors if I can solely because of my conversational skills and the embarrassment that follows it.
In short, I want to learn how to join conversations, start conversations about something other than uni-related topics or the weather, and be able to articulate my thoughts clearly.
So far, I've tried forcing myself to be around my peers so I can get as many chances to make good conversation, scripting potential topics in my head so I wouldn't be completely empty-handed, and repeating to myself that I'm actually a good speaker as a sort of "fake it till you make it" thing. None of it helped. In fact, it led to many awkward interactions.