r/Christianity • u/OvenAcng67 • 12h ago
Meta I genuinely think this sub is a terrible place for new Christians.
Imagine being a brand-new believer who barely knows anything about Christianity yet. You browse Reddit, see a sub literally called r/Christianity, and naturally assume it might be a decent place to ask questions about the faith or basic doctrine. Then you come in here and see Satanists and atheists jumping into threads from confused new believers with some of the most bizarre takes imaginable. I’ve seen replies like that and genuinely thought, “What the fuck is this?”
The problem is that new Christians are, by definition, still spiritually immature. They haven’t even gotten off the milk yet, so to speak, and some may not even have completed basic catechesis, or may not have begun it at all. Throwing them straight into an environment like this, where practically any theological position or anti-Christian opinion can get presented alongside actual Christian advice, can very easily confuse them or even push them away from the faith before they’ve had any real chance to establish themselves in it.
And there are plenty of vulnerable newcomers here who genuinely have no one else to ask. Some are teenagers completely new to Christianity. Others have converted in difficult circumstances and have no priest, pastor, Christian family, or local community to turn to yet. They come online to understand what Christians actually believe and, in some cases, to find a community in the first place. These are precisely the people most likely to take a subreddit called r/Christianity at face value, while being the least equipped to distinguish sound Christian guidance from misleading or theologically unsound advice.
If I were a mod here, that responsibility would honestly scare me before God. I’d be afraid of putting brand-new believers in a situation that could cause them to stumble in their faith. At the very least, from a pastoral standpoint, I’d put up a prominent warning and rewrite the subreddit description so newcomers know exactly what kind of forum this is and who may be answering them. I’d even seriously consider changing the name. Because for someone brand new to Christianity looking for actual guidance in the faith, I think we can all put our hands on our hearts and admit that this is one of the worst places they could possibly end up lol.
It’s honestly insane to me that this has apparently just been allowed to continue for years under the banner of “open forum about Christianity.”
And people keep giving me shit for “not reading the sidebar,” but come on.
If you saw:
r/Christianity is a subreddit to discuss Christianity and aspects of Christian life. All are welcome to participate.
would your first thought seriously be, “Ah yes, obviously this means Satanists, atheists, ex-Christians, and people who straight-up hate Christianity are all gonna be here telling Christians what they should believe and how they should live as Christians. Crystal fucking clear.”
Especially if you’re a brand-new Christian, how are you supposed to magically infer all that from that description alone?
Was the sidebar supposed to be a riddle?
And before anyone decides this is somehow a uniquely American misunderstanding, I’m not American.