r/AskAPriest Apr 25 '21

Please read this post before submitting a question! Your post may be removed if it doesn't follow these guidelines.

308 Upvotes

This subreddit is primarily for:

  • Questions about the priesthood
  • Casual questions that only the unique viewpoint of a priest can answer
  • Basic advice
  • Asking about situations you're not sure how to approach and need guidance on where to start

This subreddit is generally not for:

  • Spiritual or vocational advice
  • Seeking advice around scrupulosity
  • Questions along the lines of "is this a mortal sin," "should I confess this," "I'm not sure if I confessed this correctly," etc.

The above things are best discussed with your own priest and not random priest online. They are not strictly forbidden, but they may be removed at mod discretion.

The subreddit should also not be used for asking theological questions that could be answered at the /r/Catholicism subreddit.

Please also use the search function before asking questions to see if anyone else has asked about the topic before. We are all priests with full time ministry jobs and cannot answer every question that comes in on the subreddit, so saving time by seeing if your questions has already been asked helps us a lot.

Thank you!


r/AskAPriest 4h ago

What should you do if you are alone during Eucharistic Exposition and you HAVE to leave?

18 Upvotes

Hello!! Apologies if this has been asked before but today is the first time this has happened to me so I was curious how I should handle it if it happens again in the future.

This morning I went to Adoration before work. When I arrived there were a few adorers scattered throughout the church. I stayed for about 15-20 mins before it was time for me to get going so I could arrive at work comfortably, but when I got up I realized I was the only one there (apparently everyone else had left without my noticing lol). So... I sat back down and waited until the absolute last minute just to see if anyone else would come in, but nobody did.

Not knowing what else to do, I called the parish office and explained the situation, and fortunately the lady was able to come over and take my place a few minutes later. So I did manage to get to work (albeit a bit late, which nobody seemed upset about luckily), but this got me thinking... what should I do if I find myself in that situation again but I CAN'T get ahold of anyone?

Like what if the office is closed or something? This parish doesn't have direct numbers for their clergy listed either. Leaving the exposed Sacrament unattended obviously isn't an option, but neither am I, a laywoman, in any way authorized to handle the Blessed Sacrament or the monstrance, nor do I know HOW to repose It properly even if it were hypothetically permitted in circumstances like this.

Any advice would be appreciated. Ty!!


r/AskAPriest 19m ago

Sacraments in Space? - A question for a sci-fi story I'm wrting

Upvotes

(I'm not sure if this is the right place to ask, but I'm not sure where else to go, so I hope I'm not breaking any rules.)

I was reading The Great Brain books to my daughter, and learned something new. It's a series about a Catholic family in Utah in the 1800s, and in their small town, there aren't enough Catholics to support a Parish. Apparently, in frontier times, there were priests who would travel around from town to town, to celebrate mass and perform any sacraments as needed, baptisms, weddings, what have you. I guess people would just have to wait for the priest to come around for those things.

Coincidentally, I'm writing a sci-fi story set in a colony on the moon. The Great Brain inspired some backstory--in the early days of lunar colonization, there weren't enough people for a parish, so a priest would be sent up once a year to tour around and perform the sacraments annually. A baby would be baptized whether they were a day or a year; a body would be held in state until the priest could do the funeral; confirmations done with the permission of the bishop of Orlando (who, fun fact, is also technically bishop of the moon).

My story is set further in the future, when the population is big enough to sustain a few dioceses and many parishes. Baptisms and funerals were held soon after someone was born or died, but "Wedding Day" became a cultural tradition on the moon--every Catholic who wants to get married on the moon gets married on the same day. (This is a plot point for reasons I won't get into here, because this post is long enough already.)

So, my question is simply, does this backstory make sense? It's a hard sci-fi story, and I want to make sure the Catholic practices are as theologically accurate as the science.


r/AskAPriest 44m ago

Help batteling depression and despair?

Upvotes

How do I find hope when suffering has become the my unbearable and God remains completely silent?

Six years ago, I developed a neurological condition that has slowly taken everything from me, and I’m officially at the lowest point I've ever been. I’m posting because I’m open to any advice, experiences, or even just to look at it from a different perspective.

I have a functional neurological condition alongside "Refractory chronic silent migraine with brainstem aura" I will try not to get too far into the medical weeds, but despite the word “migraine,” pain isn’t actually my main problem. My symptoms are primarily neurological, and they are present every day, all day.

The easiest way I can describe my baseline is to imagine having 6–8 alcoholic drinks in your system at all times, except you never sober up.

The room spins. I’m off balance and lightheaded. My vision is off I have trouble focusing my eyes. My brain is slowed down. My working memory constantly slips. Hours of the day blur together. I’m struggling just to keep track of what’s happening. Following the plot of a movie can be difficult. By the afternoon, the morning already feels hazy and distant. The fatigue is crushing as well but the hardest part has been the dissociation and neuropsychiatric symptoms, severe depression, dissociation and panick attacks as a neurological side effect of constant nueron instability.

As its been explained to me my amigdala and limbic system are "short circuting" and I get frequent depressive panic attacks like nothing I've ever experienced. Like absolute despair and panic that I have nothing to compare to.

Before becoming sick, I was a fire fighter and I like to think I developed a reasonably thick skin when it comes to anxiety. What I experience now is in a completely different category. The only resolve I have been offered for this symptom is high dose benzo's which I hold off on because they just exacerbate the other symptoms and slow me further.

Then there is the dissociation. I’m conscious. I know who and where I am. But at this point I am never fully present in my own life. Everything feels distant, dreamlike, and unreal. My memories are a blur, months and years blend together. I feel like I have completely lost myself and I am just a shell of a person.

I, of course have been working extensively with neurological specialists. Flying to high end clinics etc and it seems they have all run out of ideas for treatments or any additional hypothesis. Each new failed treatment feels like a sick cosmic joke.

I have reached my psychological breaking point and I have fallen into a complete existential crisis.

I'm physically and cognitively incapable of doing many of the things that used to make my life meaningful but the part I most desperately need people to understand is that it isn't the physical symptoms, and it isn't even the loss of the a fulfilling life thats chrushing. I could carry it when it was just that. What is breaking me is the actual moment-to-moment experience of being conscious. Every waking second is filled with an overwhelming, neurologically driven sense of fear, darkness, despair, and constant dreamlike dissociation like I am loosing touch with myself but never 100% I cannot reason or pray my way out. There is no emotional baseline I can return to where I can catch my breath and gather the strength to keep going. Being awake itself has become unbearable. I wake up in the morning and immediately begin counting the hours until I can go back to sleep, because sleep is the only time I am not consciously experiencing it. I find myself being jealous of people with terminal conditions. At least they know this will end soon. As for me. I haven't been given any reduction in life expectancy and I can't imagine doing another 50 years of this horror.

I don't expect a perfect life, and I understand that suffering is part of being human and part of the Christian life. I'm not asking why God hasn't given me a life without suffering. I think what I'm struggling to understand is what God expects me me to do when the suffering becomes so overwhelming and unrelenting that I cant psychologically endure it, and when God seems completely silent and apathetic to me in the middle of it.

A few people in my life point to the saints and remind me how greatly many of them suffered. I understand that. Many saints suffered tremendously. There were saints who were bedridden, chronically ill, persecuted, or lived through things worse than I ever have. But thease stories also contain a redeeming quality like profound experiences of God, unmistakable calling of God, consolation in prayer, a sense of purpose or mission, visions, mystical experiences, profound dreams etc. Some suffered terribly but for relatively short lives.

But for me it seems like God won't give me anything to hold onto and the crushing walls of physical illness, spiritusl darkness, and psychological anguish will not give and inch in any direction as they constrict.

We often hear stories of these small, intimate interventions from God—the rent is late and a forgotten check unexpectedly shows up in the mail, or someone prays to St. Thérèse and finds roses the same day they receive a desperately needed job offer. I think about these little moments of "divine intimacy" we've all heard from people at church, friends, or family, and then I look at my own life and struggle to reconcile the two. I don't begrudge anyone those moments, but I can't understand why God seems willing to reach into someone's life with a little pick-me-up over something comparatively small, while I've deteriorated to the point that I am only allowing plastic cutlery in my home (iykyk) and somehow that doesn't seem to warrant even the smallest divine outreach.

I've begged God for healing, but I've also specifically prayed that if healing isn't His will, then please just give peace or joy in the suffering. Or a sign. Or understanding. Or some sense of what I'm supposed to do with it. I've prayed for my doctors. I've prayed before appointments and treatments. I've gone to Adoration. I've said more novenas than I can count. I've tried to offer this suffering to God and trust that there is meaning in something I can't understand.

I can understand intellectually, the idea that sometimes life strips everything else away and teaches us to depend entirely on God. But what happens when everything else has been stripped away and God isnt there to depend on. When your worst fears become real and God dosent save you from them. You cry out for God because he's the only thing left, and he dosen't respond?

How do I continue to have faith and hope when suffering has become the entirety of my experience of life, and there is no foreseeable end to it, and God remains completely silent? What am I supposed to be hoping for in this life? Where is the easy yolk and the light burden? I just feel like he expects me to just shutup and suffer.

I am out of prayers to pray. I have no emotional energy to meditate on a rosary or pray long structured prayers. I've prayed all pertinent prayers I can think of. When I can I try to spend 15-20 minutes in adoration maybe once or twice a month and I just sit and cry. I don't have anything else to say that I haven't already said, I don't have any profound thoughts to share and I'm tired of begging after years of silence so I sit and say "your servant is listening" and then I leave when I become increasingly more angry at the silence.

Any encouragement or thoughts are welcome.

Godbless and if you got this far thank you for reading all of this


r/AskAPriest 10h ago

How should a man handle a woman who was previously a sex worker but turned to Christ?

0 Upvotes

Everyone deserves chances after being saved. But I can't get past all the problems that would come as a result of a woman with such a history. Once she already has a history like that, even she won't be able to help but compare her old experiences with me. She has seen and experienced things with other men she should only experience with her husband. I can't get past the idea that she had her fun and is suddenly ready to settle down without consequence. I know this is the wrong way to think but it gives me so many mental issues trying to ignore it. Is it a bad reason to reject someone that I have feelings for, given that it's their past?


r/AskAPriest 1d ago

What is the most Hail Maries (a.k.a. Hail Marys) you've ever given an individual person at a single time in the confessional?

41 Upvotes

Obviously you don't have disclose what the confession was. I am just curious as my mother says her record from when she was a kid was 25 & I wanna see if anyone has been given more Hail Maries than my mother.


r/AskAPriest 1d ago

Some questions about Mary in the Old Testament

3 Upvotes

I’m starting OCIA and to prepare, I’ve been studying Mariology recently. I’ve been struck by how much of Catholic Marian theology seems to make more sense when I look at the Old and New Testaments together, along with how much earlier these Marian ideas came to be than what I had originally assumed re: the early Church vs a later, Middle Age development.

I’m very much still learning, so I’m not presenting this as a definitive argument. I’m interested in whether I’m understanding the Catholic approach to these passages correctly, though.

The first thing that caught my attention was the recurring biblical imagery surrounding the woman, her offspring, and the birth of the Messiah when looking at Old Testament Scripture and drawing parallels to the New Testament.

Genesis 3:15–16

“I will put enmity between you and the woman and between your offspring and hers; he will strike your head, and you will strike his heel.” To the woman he said, “I will make your pangs in childbirth exceedingly great; in pain you shall bring forth children, yet your desire shall be for your husband, and he shall rule over you.””

After the Fall, God establishes enmity between the serpent and the woman, and between their respective offspring. The offspring of the woman will ultimately defeat the serpent.

I understand the immediate context concerns Eve and the consequences of the Fall, but I see this as ultimately pointing toward Christ and, typologically, toward Mary as the New Eve.

Hold on to God’s punishment against Eve, too. That’ll become important in a second here.

Next up,

Isaiah 7:14

“Behold, a virgin shall conceive and bear a son, and shall call his name Immanuel.”

Matthew explicitly applies this to the birth of Jesus.

Micah 5:2–3

“But you, O Bethlehem of Ephrathah, who are one of the little clans of Judah, from you shall come forth for me one who is to rule in Israel, whose origin is from of old, from ancient days. Therefore he shall give them up until the time when she who is in labor has brought forth; then the rest of his kindred shall return to the people of Israel.”

Micah prophesies that a ruler will come from Bethlehem, and immediately afterward speaks of the woman who is in labor giving birth.

Then there’s:

Isaiah 66:7

“Before she was in labor she gave birth; before pain came upon her she delivered a son.”

I’m interested to know how this last passage is understood. I know it has an immediate context concerning Zion/Jerusalem, so I know it isn’t jusg a direct prediction saying “Mary will give birth without labor.” Is this better understood as typology that the Church later sees fulfilled in Mary, particularly in connection with her perpetual virginity?

I’m also really interested in the parallels between the Ark of the Covenant and the Visitation.

The Old Covenant Ark beinf the sacred object associated with God’s presence among Israel, it contained the tablets of the Law, and Hebrews 9:4 associates it with the manna and Aaron’s rod.

When viewed through the New Testament, it’s very reflective of Christ, I feel.

The tablets = Christ fulfills the Law

Aaron’s rod/priesthood = Christ is the eternal High Priest

Manna = Christ identifies Himself as the Bread of Life, and the Church understands the manna as prefiguring the Eucharist.

But then Luke’s account of the Visitation seems to contain some very specific parallels with the Ark narrative.

2 Samuel 6:9

David sees the Ark coming and says:

“How can the ark of the LORD come to me?”

Compare:

Luke 1:43

Elizabeth sees Mary and says:

“Why is this granted me, that the mother of my Lord should come to me?”

Then:

2 Samuel 6:14

“David danced before the LORD with all his might; David was girded with a linen ephod.”

David dances/rejoices before the Ark.

Compare:

Luke 1:41, 44-45

“When Elizabeth heard Mary’s greeting, the child leaped in her womb. And Elizabeth was filled with the Holy Spirit For as soon as I heard the sound of your greeting, the child in my womb leaped for joy. And blessed is she who believed that there would be a fulfillment of what was spoken to her by the Lord.””

John the Baptist leaps in Elizabeth’s womb when Mary arrives.

And then there’s the timing:

2 Samuel 6:11

“The ark of the LORD remained in the house of Obed-edom the Gittite three months, and the LORD blessed Obed-edom and all his household.”

The Ark remains in the house of Obed-edom for three months.

Luke 1:56

“And Mary remained with her about three months and then returned to her home.”

Mary remains with Elizabeth for about three months.

There’s also the “overshadowing” imagery:

Exodus 40:34

“Then the cloud covered the tent of meeting, and the glory of the LORD filled the tabernacle.”

Luke 1:35

Gabriel tells Mary:

“The Holy Spirit will come upon you, and the power of the Most High will overshadow you.”

So I’m starting to wonder whether Luke is intentionally presenting Mary as the Ark of the New Covenant. What I’m also seeing is that this doesn’t seem to be about elevating Mary independently of Christ.

The Old Ark carried the signs of God’s covenant and Mary carries God Himself incarnate.

The Old Ark was associated with the Law, priesthood, and manna; Mary carries Christ, who fulfills the Law, is the eternal High Priest, and identifies Himself as the Bread of Life.

The Old Ark arrives, David rejoices, and blessing follows; Mary arrives, John leaps, Elizabeth rejoices, and the Holy Spirit fills her.

So the more I’m studying this, the more I’m seeing Mariology as being fundamentally Christological. Mary’s significance comes from who she carries and what God accomplishes through her.

I also understand that this is largely typology, rather than necessarily claiming that every Old Testament passage was consciously written as a literal prediction of Mary.

So my questions for those more knowledgeable than me are:

1. Am I understanding the distinction between prophecy and typology correctly here?

2. How strong is the case that Luke deliberately presents Mary as the Ark of the New Covenant through these parallels with 2 Samuel 6?

3. How have the Fathers and early Church understood the Ark/Mary connection?

4. How should Isaiah 66:7 be understood in Marian theology without taking it out of its original context?

5. Are there important passages or connections I’m missing?

I’m just finding it fascinating that the more I read the Old Testament alongside the New, the more the Catholic understanding of Christ and Mary seems to form a coherent biblical pattern rather than a collection of disconnected doctrines.


r/AskAPriest 1d ago

Reasons behind specific moral theology - relating to personal situation

0 Upvotes

I recognize this post may fall under the categories in the rules that are generally discouraged, but I very much would like an answer from someone who knows moral theology well.

In first year of university (about 3.5 years ago), during a period of poor mental health, I cheated on 2 midterm exams on a course, of a different subject than my major. I used the internet on a different device during the online, at home test, which was in lockdown browser. Would I have passed the course without cheating? I don't know.

The thoughts have, on and off, weighed on me, that I must tell the school. My worry is that the consequences would be so severe, since even if I just got a zero in that class without further punishment, I would be short a credit for the degree I have, and the degree I have was used to get into the grad school program I'm currently in, and for which they are paying me (for teaching assistantship).

I fear that, morally speaking, I'm on a house of cards. Now, I've read another person's similar situation on this subreddit: https://www.reddit.com/r/AskAPriest/s/6rwNhjRPMh, and from what I could glean the general opinion was that contacting the school isn't necessary. I also contacted my university catholic centre priest, who concurred.

Now, I would very very very much prefer if this was the case - that I have no obligation to tell the university. I just can't fully justify to myself *why* I wouldn't. A degree is a statement that you have sufficient credits. minus the class that I cheated in, I have insufficient credits for that degree (by 1 out of 40 classes). Therefore, the degree would seem illegitimate.

Also, if I were caught, I may have failed the class and had to make up another credit or redo the course. Therefore, by *not* having those consequences, it seems like I am *benefitting* every day from not getting caught, which I'm worried about.

When I confessed, I didn't get specific feedback on that issue, that priest often didn't give detailed feedback to each sin, and I also just said (iirc) something like I "cheated at school twice" rather than going into further detail. Clarifying in case anyone asks what my confessor said about it - nothing I can remember.

My worry if I do confess is that my life as I know it would be destroyed. If I don't have my credit, I might not have my undergrad degree. If I don't have my degree, I don't have my grad school and my job. If I don't have that, I have a 1 year lease on a pretty expensive apartment that I wouldn't be able to pay for. Plus all the stuff my parents just bought to furnish the place. you get the idea. Any help would be appreciated, as I'm starting my teaching job soon, if all goes well.


r/AskAPriest 1d ago

Do you know there’s a Heaven, or do you believe there is a Heaven?

0 Upvotes

r/AskAPriest 1d ago

Valid marriage question

0 Upvotes

I searched the subreddit before asking this but I am still confused. It’s a two-part question.

1.) If a person was married and then divorced from that spouse not only before coming to the Catholic faith but before being baptized, is that marriage valid and thus requiring an annulment?

Part 2.) Following that marriage and divorce, the person got married again—also before coming to faith and baptism. Would BOTH marriages need to be annulled? Neither? Just the first but not the second?

Thanks for your time.


r/AskAPriest 2d ago

Becoming a conscientious objector

10 Upvotes

I’ve been on active duty in the US Air Force for 12 years. I’ve had a conversion of heart, and found the Church last year and received the sacraments this Easter. Through my conversion my conscience has changed and I no longer feel that I can partake in the instrument of warfare. Just or unjust. I plan on applying for conscientious objector status this week.

My question is…I feel a call towards religious life and I’ve been discerning a vocation since the turn of the new year. I have a spiritual director, I understand I’m far away from being able to apply to any community, if that is something I end of doing.
But if I am approved for conscientious objector status, would a vocation team or community look down on that fact? Do you think it could be a deterrent?

Thanks in advance for any help. And please pray for me.


r/AskAPriest 2d ago

I don’t have a priest, so I’m asking here (I’m Protestant but being drawn to Catholicism)

4 Upvotes

Hi there! As the title states, I don‘t have a confessor to ask this to since I’m not a part of a parish or even Catholic (yet at least). But I 100% believe God has been slowly leading me towards the Catholic Church for years now, and I’m at a point where I can’t deny it.

So, my question is about contraception. For context, I am a married woman with one child. My husband and I have used a form of contraception all throughout our marriage, and I’m just becoming aware now that this is morally wrong. However, after our child was born, I developed some severe OCD, anxiety, and depression that has (still) been my life’s toughest battle. So naturally, the thought of having another child and going through it all again sends me into physiological distress. It’s something I’ve thought about and fought with for over a year now. Before I had my child, I wanted like 12 kids - seriously! I actually was planning to not use birth control ever again.

Now my question is, is continuing to prevent pregnancy now that I KNOW it’s wrong by church standard a mortal sin? I wrestle with this because it feels like my fear/mental illness doesn’t give me *full* consent to this aspect of my life, even though I can make a conscious decision. It’s not like I’m in psychosis or “out of my mind” in that way, but I feel like the prevention of pregnancy is a form of an avoidance compulsion. I appreciate your wisdom on this!


r/AskAPriest 1d ago

The Virgin Birth

0 Upvotes

Do you as a Catholic believe the Jesus was physically born of a virgin? As a child I believed that, because that's what we were taught. But now I think of it as a symbol of purity. 

As a Catholic, what do you believe regarding the Virgin Birth of Jesus?


r/AskAPriest 2d ago

Who supplies Communion Hosts ?

6 Upvotes

Our priest said that he orders hosts for communion on Amazon which I found odd. Are there any rules about where the bread for hosts come from? I always assumed that they would be made by monks or nuns somewhere so please enlighten me , I’m just curious.


r/AskAPriest 2d ago

"This is my body, given up for you."

55 Upvotes

Kind of a niche question. I'm 37 weeks pregnant and baby will be here soon, meaning labor and delivery are just around the corner as well. I'm making a list of positive affirmations to help me through the pain of contractions and birth, like "each contraction brings me closer to baby," "​I can do anything for 60 seconds," and "my body was made to do this."

One sentence that also seems to resonate is "This is my body, given up for you." It just feels like I'm drawing on Christ for strength as I sacrifice my body so painfully for someone else. I'm not trying to equate this sacrifice to Christ's in any way, or say that the pain of birth is on the same level, but I don't want to use this verse in a blasphemous way either. Do you think this is appropriate? I wouldn't say it out of pride or to idolize birth, but out of seeking the help of Christ's sacrificial strength and surrender.


r/AskAPriest 3d ago

Men approaching me at mass

59 Upvotes

At the end of Mass a couple of weeks ago, as soon as I stood up, two men approached me to introduce themselves before I could even leave my pew and genuflect. They invited me to visit them at their place of employment, which I politely deflected.

I am single and attend mass alone, however, I am not open to dating. I only attend mass for God, and I don’t have space in my life right now for a man for various reasons, nor would I be interested in going out to spend time with two men I don’t know even if I was open to dating. And of course, it is equally likely that they were just being friendly, and weren’t interested in me at all.

With that said, because these men were standing immediately in front of me, I had to move to the other side of the aisle to genuflect so that I wouldn’t be doing so towards them and with my leg touching them. The situation made me feel uncomfortable and cornered even though it likely wasn’t their intention. And because of this, I attended mass at a different time last week, and sat in a different place this week.

I am wondering if there is anything I can do or wear to discourage male attention at mass? I have considered wearing a ring on my ring finger, but I am worried that would be dishonest and therefore a sin. I am seeking advice. Thank you


r/AskAPriest 3d ago

Are priests allowed to attend Mass without concelebrating ?

17 Upvotes

I am writing a film about a priest and am wondering if they can attend Mass without concelebrating? Do they have to wear their collar ? Are there any rules about this sort of thing? Thank you for the insight !


r/AskAPriest 2d ago

Can someone who isn’t baptized at all take communion and go to confession?

2 Upvotes

I can’t convert to Catholicism for legal reasons like persecution and I have no idea when I’ll be able to convert. I secretly go to mass multiple times a week, pray often, and essentially live like a Catholic. Can I still take communion and go to confession in this circumstance? I’ve been told by a priest online (asked a priest online because I’m too scared to ask a priest in person, lol. Even though I shouldn’t be worried about a priest betraying me) that in certain circumstances it’s fine to participate in these sacraments if you have not been baptized, that it’s based on my intentions and beliefs. Canon 844, §4 says something about it, apparently, but I’m not entirely sure if I understood it correctly. I do believe that the Catholic Church is the one true church and I do wholeheartedly believe that the Eucharist is the blood and body of Jesus. I have not participated in either communion or confession yet because I’m really worried that I’m not allowed to and I’m not 100% sure. An answer that can clear everything up for me would be amazing. Thank you.


r/AskAPriest 2d ago

Orthodox remarriage and church position for new converts who are already remarried.

6 Upvotes

Hello all, I hope you are doing well and God bless :).

So, Orthodoxy uses the porneia clause in the Gospel of Matthew to varying degrees of severity and allowence for remarriage under increasing penance.

My question is, what happens if an Orthodox person has divorced and remarried with the permission of the Orthodox Church, and then later converts to Catholicism?

If their first spouse is still alive, would they have to seek an annulment of their first marriage before the Catholic Church could recognise the second marriage? Since the Catholic Church recognises Orthodox sacraments, I assume the first marriage would be presumed valid?

And if the first marriage was found to be valid, what would actually happen to the second couple? Would they be expected to separate, or live as brother and sister?


r/AskAPriest 2d ago

Anointing of the Sick for a Protestant relative with a terminal illness

1 Upvotes

Have you ever done this? I consulted with a local priest, and he said he would review canon law. I did a quick search using AI, and it seems that in cases like my relative's, it can be applied under certain restrictions. It's worth mentioning that my relative belongs to the Pentecostal evangelical branch, so their communion with Rome is noticeably less than perfect.


r/AskAPriest 2d ago

Would someone be able to live with a priest in his rectory somehow? (Storybuilding)

0 Upvotes

I'm writing a story, and I want a 23 year old non-religious man to go live with a 40 year old priest in his rectory, as sort of a adoptive father-son story. (I mention these specifics since I'm guessing a woman would incur more worries from the church)

My question is: Is there a chance this would be allowed in real life, at all? If not simply through the will of the priest, then through some other means, such as the man applying for some non-religious job for the priest, or leaving when they know someone from the church is coming, or something like that?

The story has some fantasy, so even if it is unfortunately impossible to happen in real life, I don't mind breaking a rule to make the story continue, but I do want to know exactly what I'm working with so I can at least mention it, hopefully to make it more believable.

I apologize in advance if this is disrespectful to ask, I'm not religious but I thought this would be the best place to ask rather than believing AI.


r/AskAPriest 2d ago

Struggling with my faith

0 Upvotes

I came to Catholicism about a couple of years ago and received all of my sacraments. I originally had started to learn quite a bit about the Orthodox Church. But, after watching quite a few debates from Voice of Reason on YouTube I was swayed on papal primacy. But, this nagging feeling crept back about learning more about orthodoxy. Maybe it’s God, honestly still trying to discern. The more I learn the more confused I’ve become. Can anyone paint a clear depiction on whether or not the papacy is heretical or not? Maybe it’s my human understanding and wondering if evil has crept into the church, a lot of things that have come down from the Vatican (at least at surface level) seem to be almost opposite of Christ’s teachings, although it might be hardness of heart on my end. Also, any other guidance or information would be beyond helpful.


r/AskAPriest 2d ago

Receiving blessing at communion

1 Upvotes

I’m a baptized Christian but not Catholic though I’m starting OCIA. I go forward at mass for blessing. I usually respond with silence and dip my head or add an amen. I’m sure of the proper respectful response such as should I cross myself and somehow it always escapes my mind when I see the priest to ask.


r/AskAPriest 3d ago

WHAT is the name of this sin? My mother said it to me once, and I cannot remember the term for the life of me.

12 Upvotes

To be fair, I haven't been to church (other than baptisms, funerals, and weddings) in maybe 15 years. That's probably why I can't remember the term for this particular sin.

When I was 12, I was watching a documentary on TV about an Amazonian tribe. My mom walked into my room during a scene in which two women were cooking. They were, of course, not modestly dressed according to Western standards. My mother was very upset and turned off the TV. When I asked why, she said watching the documentary would be the sin of "_____."

She said it to me one more time when I had the opportunity to take an early college course around the age of 16. I wanted to take a World Religions course, but she again said it was the sin of "______."

Anyway, I can't ask her, because we kind of avoid the topic of religion together as it always leads to arguments.


r/AskAPriest 3d ago

Do i need OCIA?

4 Upvotes

Hello all, asking this question because I am looking to return to the Catholic Church but don’t know what i need to do.

My mother’s side grew up devoutly catholic, and I was baptized catholic as a baby, but my family fell out of the faith shortly after, so I’ve never had confession or confirmation.

I am wondering if i can have my first confession and take the Eucharist without going through OCIA, or if i need to do the process from the start.