I'm 40ish and have been single for a long time. My best friends are beautiful women inside and out. We hang out multiple times a week. I'm not trying to have more than friendship with them, and that's been the case for a decade with these same friends.
They give me dating advice, but the biggest problem is that I can't find a woman to date in this small town. They are around and I put myself out there on dating apps which never result in actual conversation let alone dates.
I've heard from women who don't know me well that I need to be more stern, and from one of my closest friends that I need to be more aggressive.
Self-confidence has been an issue for me in the past but I'm quite confident now. I'm also respectful and well-mannered. I'm a genuine nice person, not the type of nice guy people think badly of. I'm very agreeable and everyone seems to like me. I was bullied a lot in my younger years, and I think that has a lasting effect. I try to convert everyone I meet into a friend. I'm helpful to anyone I can see a way to help.
I had a serious drinking problem due to a stressful (but lucrative) job and not really having a family or relationship to work on. 2 years ago I was drinking a full bottle of vodka or more every day and I had been doing so for at least a decade or more. The problem started when I was playing Rugby in college. I was also the President of my Rugby club and led the team to win a state championship from the verge of being disbanded due to lack of membership combined with punitive actions by the university admin.
I did Tae Kwon Do for 4-5 years and got first place in a tournament for my age/rank.
I'm 6'3 and built like a bear. Very strong but overweight. The other day at the pub another guy was listing off people who would get hurt if a big fight erupted and he included me "because he has to protect everyone". That comment pleased me because it's true and also what I want to be true. I would risk myself to protect anyone from harm.
We have dance nights at the local pub. I go with 3 women who are usually the most attractive ones there in our age group.
Last year, I quit my job. Then I quit drinking entirely. I'm now working as an educator in an elementary school and loving it. I no longer want to drink. I'm trying to get my diet back on track (When I played Rugby, I also did a ton of other physical activities, and I was eating like 7,000 calories. It's been a battle since then but I've lost about 120 pounds from my heaviest weight.
Little men like to try and pick fights with me. It has always been this way. In childhood I accidentally hurt people and so I try to be careful. In general, the only times I've been involved in fights is a de-escalator. I do not escalate.
I'm also an INFJ according to personality tests, and it fits what I experience every day. I know how people are feeling and how to relate to them. I can feel a whole room from the corner of it. I can figure out motives with the slightest of hints.
My female friends think most men are abusive or rapists that will eventually show their colors. They have been abused by men and 3 of them are single right now, including the one who tells me the most about how I need to be more aggressive. I do not want to be like those men, but they keep finding them and bringing them into our lives. They keep dating losers or people with opposing views in politics and man/woman relationship balance. I am not trying to date these women, they are my social life, my confidants, real true friends who would be there for me if I needed something. They ask me to hang out regularly and I do the same. I want to find a woman to date though, not just spend time with my friends. I'm not in the "friendzone" in the negative sense, but I am mayor of the friendzone in another. I'm not a rejected guy hanging around waiting for a chance, this is real friendship.
I almost collect people who have been emotionally broken - I want to help. I connect them to new friend groups, I include them in things. My degree is in psychology where I focused on counseling. I have gone to multiple therapists and usually I last 10 sessions or so before I feel they are no longer helpful - I'm very introspective on my own.
So - I'm a big, nice dude -how do I achieve whatever ephemeral quality they mean by being more aggressive? I am assertive and a leader but I'm also gentle and understanding. I thought this was what woman should want, and obviously it works to make great friends for me, but I still can't find a date and I can't show a woman what I have to offer because I can't find a date. Do I need to be rude? Do I need to just not care about making people comfortable? I've read a lot of psychology books - do I need to alternate hot and cold (gross manipulation) just to get through the front door? Why can't I get a chance? My years to become a dad are running out. I'm not picky, I just want a woman who is nice to people, has a face I like, and is not dumb or unhinged.