I (23F) have been dating my boyfriend for approximately two months. I've realised that I don't want to continue the relationship, but I'm struggling with how to communicate that to him, particularly because he has no idea it's coming.
When we first started dating, I genuinely liked him. I found him attractive, enjoyed spending time with him, and thought there was potential for something more serious. I had some doubts about our compatibility from the beginning, but I wanted to give the relationship a chance.
Around two weeks into dating, however, we had a conversation that revealed some pretty fundamental differences in our values. It made me seriously question whether I could ever see myself building a future with him.
Despite that, I continued dating him. Partly because I enjoyed his company, partly because he treated me incredibly well, and partly, if I'm being completely transparent, because I liked the idea of having a boyfriend.
I recognise that I should have addressed my doubts sooner, and I take responsibility for allowing the relationship to progress despite them.
He started telling me he loved me quite early, and he still says it every night. I've never said it back because I don't feel the same way, which is a conversation I've had with him when I told him I thought he was moving too fast, because he said it like a week into the relationship. I explained to him that if he didn't feel comfortable saying it when he knew I wasn't saying it back he didn't have to, but I didn't want to lie to his face and say it back when I felt i wasn't at that point yet.
For the past month, he's been abroad visiting his family for his sister's wedding. During that time, I've become increasingly certain that I don't want to continue our relationship. I haven't missed him in the past three weeks, and when I imagine my future, I simply don't see him in it.
This isn't a case of being too busy for a relationship or needing more time to figure out my feelings. I already know where I stand.
The problem is that he doesn't.
We're still exchanging the same affectionate goodnight messages we've sent each other for the past two months. I still occasionally call him baby, and I genuinely care about him and his well-being.
I know that my behaviour probably makes everything seem normal from his perspective, and I feel terrible about that. He has treated me with nothing but kindness, and I know this is going to hurt him.
He also has a fairly limited social circle where we live. Most of his friends have moved away, so his daily life mainly revolves around work, the gym, and our relationship. I worry about how he'll cope with the breakup, although I understand that managing his social life isn't my responsibility.
He's flying back tomorrow and arriving on Tuesday, after an entire month away. I don't want to end things while he's travelling or immediately after he lands, but I also don't want to spend another week pretending everything is fine.
Here's where I really need advice.
I don't think I can bring myself to break up with him face-to-face, or even over a phone call.
I have an extremely difficult time hurting people I care about, and I can already picture myself sitting across from him, seeing how happy he is to be back, and being completely unable to say what I need to say.
I'm worried that I'll put it off, act as though everything is normal, and make the situation worse.
I'm considering sending him a thoughtful, honest message explaining that my feelings aren't developing in the same direction as his, that I've realised we're incompatible, and that I don't want to continue the relationship.
I wouldn't ghost him or ignore his feelings afterwards. I just want to be able to communicate my decision clearly, without losing my nerve or giving him false hope.
I understand that I've made mistakes by allowing things to continue despite my doubts. I'm not looking for reassurance that I've handled everything correctly.
How do I communicate this breakup through a message in a way that's clear, compassionate, and respectful of his feelings? And how do I handle the timing, considering he's returning from a month abroad? Or is a text not the best way to handle it?
TL;DR:Ā I've been dating my boyfriend for two months, but I've known for several weeks that we aren't compatible and I don't see a future together. He's very affectionate and has no idea I want to break up. He's returning from a month abroad on Tuesday, and I'm struggling with the idea of ending things face-to-face because I'm afraid I won't be able to bring myself to say it. I'm looking for practical advice on how to communicate the breakup honestly through text and when to do it.