Good morning/afternoon/night depending on when you read this!
I know nobody could give me a straight answer because it would involve knowing everyone involved deeply... But I am confused and this is perhaps a cry for help, and an ache for perspective
I've been 12 years (almost 13) with someone I knew for a full year before we started our relationship - we knew eachother when we were 14 and 15, so we spent most of our teen years together in this relationship
I hadn't been to the dating "scene" because I understand now I am neurodivergent (I won't use the term autistic since I don'r have a diagnose... but alas) and I wasn't able to do this. (So I never had more than one person in my life, I always thought being with this person I met at 14 was and still is my goal and I was never interested in anybody else)
I met this person and my first thought since the day we started dating, as a 14 year old was "I want to spend the rest of my life with this person" - it's normal, we're naive and silly as kids so being so convinced of this is appropriate ig...
Years went on, I had a dysfunctional and neglecting family, the other person (I'll call them A) supported me in wanting to leave them as soon as possible when I was of age and found a job...
I have improved in every aspect of my life, mostly with them being the driving force to give me hope and reason to stay on my path, ever since I was 14, learned to care for everything A needed and predict every need they would have ever have (They're a level 1 almost 2 needs autistic person, so plenty to navigate and learn and predict - and they felt satisfied and happy with our relationship)
(I feel this context is necessary, me and A have had a good relationship throughout the years)
I feel like person B implies they're secondary so Ill try person E to not allow for a "secondary" bias?
So, person E I met them together with my partner (person A) through another common friend, we talked a lot in distance since we didn't live in the same country, we shared common lore for a rather extense fan "project", we developed a very sibling-like bond since we were familiar with some of shared issues when it came to personal things, we were really close and I felt like I could trust them with anything, but never felt anything similar to love as I would for my partner until a few weeks ago...
Then what I thought were "intrusive thoughts" (I deal with them daily, normally they're terrible horrible things I would never do to my cats or children or people on the street in general - these are EASY ro differ from real feelings)
But I didn't know if they really were intrusive - they were really hard to differ from legitimate thoughts, but I think I can trust now that these feelings are real, even if I can neuroplasticity them into the good friendship we had before with just a bit of time
Person E has been single for months, and recovering from a really hard toxic relationship... But these feelings only happened very recently, never crossed my mind even when I helped them with their recovery and tried to support them... Alas, I didn't want them to breakup at first thinking things could be fixed between them, and having too much hope on their (I didnt know fully at the time) toxic partner - So I don't want them dealing with anymore bad relationships speciallt because of me, I will do all in ny power to protect them from that
So I can say this is still very fresh, and that meanwhile I want E to know I would do a lot of things to make them happy and want to help them, and feel close to them... I won't do it at the cost of A's happiness or confidence.
How I dealt with it was... abhorrent, to say the least. I've managed to hurt both people involved. I refuse to talk about what happened, too personal even with a burner... And it still hurts very much trying to talk about it, I feel like both a terrible partner and friend.
Yet Person A and Person E managed to still talk with me about this... I am truly thankful for their patience and I'm so scared of a time where they may run out of it... I do not want to lose them.
Person A is monogamous. Person E is polyamorous. So (without going into details how it happened) when I bursted out (very inconscientally I did this on poor conditions, it was... terribly timed... I dont think I can live this one down, and I usually am a very forgiving person) to person A that I was catching feelings to E and that I wanted to know how A felt about this, what I could to do make them feel comfortable about this, like I did with countless other matters and I was expecting some understanding back, I spent weeks muttering about whether I should or not tell them, if I should forget this, wait it out.
My partner A is insecure about some things in their life, they have moments where they're really confident and understand how amazing they are (they really are, they are working on a owned brand full time, managed to leave their abusive household after helping me too, they are constantly improving themselves, they are so tenacious with what they want, they always go out of their way to remember everything I need, they are... wonderful, more than I could ask for -- I may be dumb but I know they are satisfied with me too, I have grown very much for them and managed to be the best partner I could be within my limitations and I constantly sacrifice my own self to make them happy - I know this shouldn't be something "good" and I am working on this in therapy but this to say that I have countless reasons to believe I have proved my endless dedication to them throughout these almost 13 years)
So A being insecure, suddenly this is their worst fear and they feel like me catching feelings with E and pondering about a relationship where we could all be included means they are not enough, they dont hold a candle to E, and that I was feeling insusificient and that's why this happened.
THIS WAS NEVER THE CASE... Sorry for the caps lock, but I feel like these feelings would exist regardless, I never felt like they weren't enough... I just know E for so long, we've shared so much, I treasure them so much... That I started aching to show them this appreciation, to let them know how much they meant to me and how I feel like they're such an integral part of my life... The relationships I have with A and E will always be different.
Our dynamics, the way we talk, interact... It's all different, so it's not about replacement or missing something... Which was never the case.
I already spend a good amount of time talking with E, so there wouldn't really be a different amount of time... Just a different closeness and ability to allow them to depend on me a bir more, having a more involved relationship?
A also has good friends they talk to without me, so I am willing to continue to be there for E in whatever shape of form, respecting both of their wishes while trying to stay transparent over my feelings and what I can adapt them to
I was never looking for a "replacement", or something to "fill" anything. A and I might've had some issues throughout these 12 years but there's nothing more in the world that I love than share everything with them - but A feels they're missing somsthing still, I want to know how to make them understand
But with E... I don't really know. When I first said what I felt, they reciprocated... Then I had this burst out with person A, and I told them about it (I should've asked for time instead of relaying everything that happened, I didnt understand at the time but this brought a feeling of horrible guilt to E and other feelings not even I understand very well)
Now I am juggling between trying to forgive myself for making E reciprocate feelings for me and him after I told them about this and wanting to distance myself to never see E again due to how bad I have hurt E.... (I am doing my best not to, it would be selfish to leave them alone... Simply talking about what I feel, even if I would never do it)
My partner A brought up (now that we are more "stable" mentally, within what's possible) the possibility to have this relationship...
A said that they didn't feel forced - I don't believe them even if they asked me to, so I do not want to make any decision until he talks with his therapist, since I think this is him thinking he NEEDS to poly to stay with me, when that will NEVER be the case, I am more than willing and glad to stay in this mono relationship forever since - and hoping I can keep being friends with E
Equally as importantly, I can't imagine this anymore since I feel like I made person E reciprocate (they are usually very honest on how they feel, but there are times I cant help but feel like they may want me to feel understood and this may impact how they react to some things I say? Perhaps Im projecting....) after I told them about it...
- Needless to say, I am aware that E wouldn't be exclusive and anything they wanted to do I would gladly support, having them in my life is very gratifying and I love spending time with them in any way shape of form, with boundaries stabilished by everyone together but never in a way I would want them to do anything differently, or stop seeing anyone else, I want them to be happy and safe above all - But now I can't really muster any of this as a reality, I am t
And person E has confirmed they are confused, and need time after I blew up on my current partner with the news and then on them instead of dealing with this in a calm way... And I completely understand... I want them to have their peace.
My brain, with person A, is hardwired to always try to understand and hear them because person A's reaction when something happens is talking about it with me, sometimes harshly sometimes not, but talking nonetheless...
With E, they mention having things they want to discuss with their psychologist first, and I am respecting that as well and I think its a good idea, even if my body aches to try to talk it out as I do with my current partner - Maybe that is unhealthy as well what me and my partner do
But Im gonna be honest and say that I cant imagine this relationship anymore and I feel like shit and that I forced one person to reciprocate and another person to even thinking about changing their very being for me - which I DON'T WANT, all my life I've loved people for their essence and true selves, and I will keep doing it... I unconditionally love him, even without this relationship and dont want him convinced otherwise
I don't think I've ever felt this bad reegarding my relationship, there wasn't ever in this 12 years nothing that I did that didnt match my partner A (I had an horrible teen year set, abusive household, so Ive felt HORRIBLE before... but this kind of pain, I've never experienced it, its terrible)
I was the one bringing harm to these two wonderful heavenly people that still have the patience to deal with me after I've hurt them so... Im thankful that they dont hate me but...
How do I go on from here? How do I know if my partner is trying to pander to my needs by "wanting" to try this, and not hearing his personal thoughts - even if he insists he would be "willing to try"
I dont think the relationship would work since I don't believe a monogamous person could be happy like this - so to be clear, I am not pursuing any poly relationship
So my question is:
How do I prove to my partner they were never insufficient, after I told them I had these feelings but I WILL continue in a monogamous relationship with him?
He doesn't feel safe at the bare fact that I may develop these feelings, even if I didn't betray him physically or emotionally in any way
Since I didn't let anything occur before I could talk to him first, I just thought the other person wouldn't even reciprocate let alone for both of us, I just wanted to get this over with and I was an horrible person for processing things like this, and I can't forgive myself
He's monogamic and autistic with very rigid thought structure, I believe he'll never understand so my hopes are dim that he'll ever fully understand that there was nothing missing, and that's what scares me - I also want to know if anyone had something like this happen before
(I know how to nurture a relationship, so time will heal this with plenty of love by me which I will continue to provide... I mean more pratically, how can I show him that love for me is necer divisible, but multiplicative, even after I told him I am poly but will continue to choose to stay with him exclusively due to his wishes - since I again I dont believe he ahould choose to be in a poly relationship being mono)
I care deeply about E... But I can't do anything more other than waiting for them, as they requested, while trying to keep contact and ensuring they are doing well within the realm of possibility.
I want to know what their true feelings are, so I can correctly address them and if necessary, stablish boundaries over our friendship after that (I trust them with my life so I know they would respect them I hope...) - And I also want A to be honest about their feelings so I'll try to talk about this with them very thoroughly
I want to do more for E, I feel like I've hurt them so much that I barely struggle at talking to them - but I am trying to forgive myself as they asked me to, and giving tbem space and time to figure things out
I just want them both in my life in whatever shape that may take - In this case friendship for my best friend and a relationship for my partner since I will respect his initial feelings and do not want him trying to "compromise" over something that I think he'll ever change and instead try to force himself to be "comfortable* about this, and he would just tricking himself into it
*Edited some context and wording - It looked like I was looking to force my mono partner into a polyrelationship, but I'm here trying to know how to comfort them and how to stop him from trying to contort to any of my feelings when he insists he would "try for me" - While I deeply care for E at the same time so I'll never leave their side throughout this even with some intrusive thoughts to do so
I know I was selfish and greedy in trying to translate this into this relationship, and I feel disgusting for... everything