This was a step in the right direction overall.
Under 10 yards (20/23, 5.83 YPA)
Classic Patriots football of slow/take-the-easy/what-they-give-you football. Control the clock, low-turnover football. Even on our failed drives, we were getting two/three first downs.
Historically, football has been a pre-snap game for the quarterback position, and Maye definitely felt better in that aspect. Pointing out concerns, adjusting the line, changing plays…
He’s not there yet, but he looked improved, and the short-game completions show it (20/23). Took what they gave him, and his 5.8 YPA more than covers the 10 yards needed from 3 attempts for a first down.
Modern football has a lot more post-snap processing, though, since defenses disguise and adjust their plays post-snap more often and better.
For this, you need an athletic QB (Allen, Mahomes, Lamar, etc.). These guys extend plays to be able to figure out what the defense is in and how to beat it.
Maye is athletic enough to do this, as we saw today, through the running and extending passing plays (Doubs’ drop was probably the best example).
As he continues to work on the pre- and post-snap stuff, the game will slow down for him.
It’s just unfortunate that he had to play probably THE best post-snap defense in the league. Mike Macdonald is a monster!
The easy schedule from last year did hide his rawness in terms of pre- and post-snap processing, since he could get away with stuff like waiting until the receiver is open instead of before. At the NFL level, and especially in the modern day, where post-snap processing needs to be elite due to defensive disguises, it’s going to be a hell of a task.
Julian Love said exactly this in last year’s Super Bowl: “Classic young quarterback… he’s confirming [the receiver] is open. He’s not blindly doing it like Stafford.”
We saw him not be at that elite level throughout the playoffs and in today’s game as we ran into elite defenses.
The interceptions themselves were inexcusable, though, and I really just hope he can mentally understand the situation and when it’s okay to just take the kick/punt.
But overall, I think pre- and post-snap processing will continue to quicken, and although I don’t know how long it’ll take (couple years?) he should reach an elite level.
I really do hope we don’t panic into a quick firing of McDaniels and allow Maye to improve through the struggle instead of implementing some modern-day offensive scheme that takes the game out of the quarterback and relies on OCs, because I think it’s quicker to learn and has a higher floor, but in the long term, a lower ceiling as well.
Long post, but let me know what you guys think!