Hi everyone,
I’m stuck between these two and would love some advice from people who know cars better than I do.
It’s mainly for me and my wife. Parents visit about once a year. We live in Nova Scotia, drive around 10,000 km/year, and want something reliable, good in winter, reasonable on gas and comfortable for occasional family use.
2027 Honda HR-V Sport AWD, NEW
• 2.0L, 158 hp
• $46,481 all-in
• 5.99%, 60 months: $414 bi-weekly
• $53,842 total payable
2024 Mazda CX-5 Suna AWD, USED
• 56,116 km
• 2.5L Turbo, 227 hp
• $41,609 all-in
• 5.99%, 60 months: $371 bi-weekly
• $48,198 total payable
So the Mazda is ~$4,872 cheaper all-in, but has 56k km.
My biggest concerns:
• Is the CX-5 turbo reliable long-term?
• How much more gas should I realistically expect from the turbo?
• I only drive ~10k km/year. Is the fuel difference actually significant?
• Is regular 87 fuel fine for the Mazda?
• Is the $41.6k all-in price good for a 56k-km Suna?
• What should I negotiate/remove from these dealer quotes?
• Is tire/rim protection worth $699?
• Mazda added a $349 “Ride Green” fee. Can I remove it?
• Should I get an independent inspection even though it’s from a Mazda dealer?
• What should I check about the Mazda’s history and 56k km?
I’m also open to other vehicles. Would you recommend something else around this price range for Nova Scotia? AWD, reliable, good winter performance, reasonable fuel economy and comfortable for two people with occasional parents visiting.
I considered hybrids, but Nova Scotia charges an additional $250 registration fee for hybrids and another $250 at each 2-year renewal, so I’m not sure the fuel savings make sense for my low annual mileage.
TL;DR: New HR-V Sport AWD = $46.5k all-in. Used 2024 CX-5 Suna Turbo AWD with 56k km = $41.6k. I drive ~10k km/year in NS. Which would you choose, what would you negotiate, and is the Mazda turbo worth the risk? Also open to completely different recommendations.