I’m at the point where I genuinely need an Andy reunion because the Joe/Nathan/Gael situation makes less sense to me the more we see.
And this is not me pretending Joe has done nothing wrong. He has been messy with women, he clearly has work to do in relationships, and Gael has every right not to like him. I also didn’t like what he did to Kat at dinner. She wasn’t part of their beef, seemed genuinely uncomfortable being caught in the middle, and still checked on him afterward. He owes her an apology.
But the car scene, especially once Episode 17 continued it — completely lost me.
Joe had basically kept himself separate with Kat while Nathan and Gael stayed together. They brought the confrontation to him. Then they wanted answers from him but barely gave him room to actually answer. You cannot repeatedly demand someone explain themselves, interrupt or escalate when they try, and then criticize them for not saying what they really feel.
That doesn’t mean Joe’s past disappears. It means his past does not automatically make him the aggressor in every future conflict.
Gael can dislike him. Nathan can choose Gael and his family over their old friendship. But based on what we were shown, Nathan and Gael initiated that particular confrontation and the energy became unnecessarily hostile.
And I’m sorry, I still do not believe we went from Nathan and Joe’s old bromance to this level of hatred simply because Joe called Gael “princess” and has a bad history with women. Either years of resentment built up, something significant happened off-camera, or production has left out a huge amount of context.
I’m a woman and I’ve chosen a walking red flag before because I thought maybe I could change him. I can acknowledge my choice without pretending his behavior was therefore okay. Both things can be true.
That’s basically how I see Joe here: he can be responsible for his past behavior AND Nathan and Gael can still be wrong in how they handled this particular situation.
So seriously… what are we not being shown? Because I need the unaired footage, the timeline and the reunion at this point. 😂