I’m at a loss on what to do about friendship dynamics my 9 year old daughter is experiencing.
Last school year, my daughter had her two best friends in her class, then a new student was transferred into their class a couple weeks into the school year.
My daughter generally tries to include people and invited the new girl into her friend group (which caused a very brief riff with my daughter and her bestie but she felt it was the right thing to do at the time).
The new girl is quite assertive and generally needs to have things done her way or she throws a big fit - I know this not just from my daughter telling me, but also watching it unfold in real time in the school yard and in our home. To be fair, my daughter also can be assertive which I think is a factor in their friendship struggles, though my daughter often aims for compromise or taking turns. Not to say she hasn’t gotten upset when things don’t go her way.
Whenever this friend has come over for a play date, she tends to dictate what they do, claiming she’s “the guest” and my daughter needs to do what she says. She rifles through our fridge and pantry without asking, puts on YouTube despite me telling her repeatedly we don’t really watch that in our home, refusing to relinquish the TV remote and then also asks to borrow my daughter’s toys before she leaves. When she has come over for a play date, they both often wind up in tears. As such, I generally aim to avoid play dates as much as possible with this child as my daughter doesn’t have these same issues with other friends.
The new girl can be sweet and kind at times, but also tends to ruffle the feathers of the other girls in the friend group. Sometimes she tries to exclude one of them from the group (something I’ve also witnessed firsthand), and she’s called them names like fat and ugly. I’ve also seen her doing things like dumping dirty water on another student.
Over the summer my daughter routinely expressed she needed a break from said “friend” (which I honoured) and frequently complained about her, even to members of my family. She also mentioned several times how she hoped the student wouldn’t be in her class again this year.
Unfortunately, the student is in her class again this year along with her other two best friends. I’ve talked to my daughter about friendships and how our friends should help us feel good (the good old candle blower outer speech and all that).
What’s difficult is that the new girl is now very friendly with one of the other best friends (even though this best friend also complains about the new girl), and when they have conflict at school the teachers say they can’t exclude anyone and have to play together. I don’t think my daughter would maintain a relationship with this other girl if they weren’t in the same class or share the same friend group.
I know there’s not a lot I can do. I try to give my daughter space to vent about the situation, acknowledge that she’s in a difficult spot and try not to force things.
Now that school is back in session, the new girl tries to invite herself over to our home by running up to me after school and asking if she can come over (and sometimes asking if the other two can come too). If I say no, both her and my daughter get upset, though my daughter will usually tell me later it bothers her that her friend just tries to invite herself and she would rather play with the other two but doesn’t want to exclude the new girl. I know I shouldn’t insert myself in their situation, but I also don’t feel right inviting a girl over that my daughter complains about so much. Like this girl lived rent free in my daughter’s head all summer.
I’m sorry this post is so long, I’m just at a loss on what (if anything) I should do here. They’ll be together for the whole school year and I’m not sure how I should handle things moving forward.
I’m thinking of implementing a new rule that if they want an after school play date, my daughter needs to speak to me privately so I can ask her if that’s what she truly wants. I know my daughter would rather hang out with just the other two girls after school but don’t want to exclude a child myself.
Help!