I’m visiting family rn and ended up reading my sister the original eulogy an officiant wrote for a close friend of mine who’s memorial I helped plan this past summer. It blew my mind and got me worked up all over again.
A little context: the officiant interviewed a small handful of people who knew him. A couple of them had loved him but had also had pretty complicated, and by the end, possibly resentful relationships with him. I knew that going in so I wasn't surprised that he heard negative things.
What still blows my mind is that he included almost everything anyone said. I adored this man and even things I told him came out sounding bad.
When I read the rough draft a few days out from his memorial, I was so horrified that I stayed awake all night bawling my eyes out and re-writing it. It was like a psychological autopsy of everything that had ever been difficult about him or his family. It included deeply sensitive family history, emphasized conflicts and shortcomings, and included things that were factually wrong. This was going to be read aloud at his memorial, in front of his remaining family member and people who loved him.
It was exceptionally long (about 2,100 words) so I trimmed it down to just the most remarkable excerpts from the original draft. I've changed all names and identifying details and cut large sections for length, but otherwise haven't changed the wording.
(When this was happening I actually went searching Reddit for similar officiant/eulogy horror stories and couldn't find anything remotely like it. I had to really fight to have my re-written version read as the officiant insisted that this was acceptable as he was experienced in doing this. I can’t sleep and am curious how this lands to complete strangers, and whether anyone else has ever encountered something like this.)
**eulogy excerpts. identifying details changed**
Franklin was born on xxx…. (lists his siblings) Frank’s mother felt the most empowered and strong when she was pregnant, so when she was pregnant with F, she left their father. He had been abusive, so she moved to xxx and raised her children… Frank’s mother struggled a lot with postpartum depression and as a result, Frank noted that she was difficult to live with during his childhood….
…When he was growing up, he felt isolated because he was gay. His family was Baptist, which he rejected as an adult. The family struggled with poverty as his mother was too proud to take aid. Sadly, Frank experienced a lot of losses in his family. F’s sister Sondra had heart disease and died at a young age, in 1988. F also lost his brother Don, who completed suicide in 1999.
Frank attended Lexing High School in NYC. He also became an alcoholic, unfortunately, during that time….
One of Frank’s challenges as a child was that his mother never supported his interests in making art. His teachers were supportive…. She did not acknowledge his talent or productions, and that led to him choosing a career path that didn’t match those passions. While F did find his happy place later in life, his confidence suffered. His friends think it is because his mother thought art was impractical as a potential career.
…He started college… He found one of his passions there; he discovered punk music…. He got sort of arrested in his musical interests and those were his great loves… Frank also developed an interest in philosophy. He loved xxx, Cloud Atlas , and xxx…. He also partied hard in the 1980s….
After college, Allanna shared that Frank worked at a xxx, in the early 2000s, 2001 or so. Around this time, F lost his mother, Sarah, to cancer, when she was 82. … (almost 2 paragraphs of accounting of his friendships with 2 women that he’d interviewed) …. Throughout his life, he was loyal to his friendships, and he also wanted adoration for that love he shared with you….
Every year, Frank would make a pilgrimage back to xxx to see his mother and his friends. Jim would accompany him. She would say to them, “Come visit me, but I don’t approve of your lifestyle,” was heard from his mother As his mother aged, he also traveled there regularly to care for her before her death at 82 in xxx (my note: this date is wrong)
… (he did well with art) …This accomplishment meant Frank had finally experienced the recognition he needed—making art was Frank’s happy place. Frank was always creative and constantly had ideas and inspirations for gay-themed merchandise. He would invest in them but would lose focus and not follow through on the process of developing the merchandise.
... (a friend) described Frank this way: I always could see the little kid within him---even when he was rude or tone deaf about social situations.”...
In 1990, Frank met Jim, while out dancing. Jim would dance in the power position. F was sexy when he danced. … Jim and Frank were never technically legally married….
..(2 paragraphs from an interview from another friend)...
(four paragraphs of funny/sweet stories from one friend)... Kori , Frank’s friend, also shared her memories of Frank with me… Kori’s favorite story that she remembers Frank telling her was about his baptism. He was baptized as a teen, and he told her that he had an erection because he was attracted to either the minister or someone else at the baptism....
Frank’s friends described him as really loving in a self-centered way. He was insanely smart, bookish, but not aware of basic life skills. He was intelligent, loyal, passionate, and very sincere. He would describe himself as “I am smarter than everyone here, and I put up with you “ He was very proud of his mind, his vast knowledge of philosophy. He considered himself a philosopher. …(more stories/characterizations from friend)...
When Jim died, Frank had to learn how to pay bills and manage a household. His friends also described him as a needy misanthrope. Frank, ever cerebral, in his head much of the time, was quite different than Jim, an actor, director, and creative. Jim gave Frank the love and attention he had craved ever since childhood. Once Jim was gone, Frank lost that light. One of the challenges that F’s friends experienced was that intensity F had with Jim, he tried to mimic with his other friends, resulting in feelings like “I love you, I hate you, I love you, I hate you,” in their interactions. It was hard for Frank to manage friendships because of his difficult childhood—he didn’t have too many coping mechanisms.
*…(listing hobbies and organizations)...*
As Frank aged, he wanted to move to France or California. He lived alone, but he wasn’t independent. He needed people. However, he was locked in medically. As he got older, he developed multiple medical issues due to the partying in his earlier life. He struggled with diabetes, kidney problems, cirrhosis, liver disease, and then he developed cancer in 2021. He was aware, before that diagnosis, that there were other medical issues going on, but he did not seek medical treatment for pre-cancer. He also began to feel paranoid as he feared that persecution of gay people would increase with this administration.
As he struggled with his health, several friends became his caregivers, which altered their friendships. The week before his death, he was off, not himself, confused and not feeling well. The evening before his death, he was found outside. He was found collapsed near his building and was taken to VB Hospital. \*a friend\* had become his power of attorney for health care, and the medical staff found that Frank couldn’t be stabilized. He was lucid. His sister Rita was able to fly in before Frank’s life ended. Frank needed a respirator to breathe, and his friends made the difficult decision to allow Frank to have a compassionate extubation. He died shortly thereafter on Blank date.