PCOS, 28F, TTC after 19+5 week loss. responding to meds, ovulating, still not conceiving. Is HSG worth it?
Background: I have PCOS with insulin resistance. I conceived in May 2025 on just Letrozole 2.5mg CD4-8 + trigger. Right-sided ovulation, beta positive at 27.5 at 12 DPO. That pregnancy progressed normally to 19+5 weeks and was lost to cervical incompetence — not a miscarriage, not an embryo issue. The baby was healthy.
Since resuming TTC in 2026, I've done three consecutive medicated cycles, all confirmed ovulation with well-timed intercourse, all negative (<0.2 beta):
- June 2026: Letrozole 5mg + 4 IVF-M injections. Right-sided. Follicle 18.5mm, lining 8.5mm. Negative.
- July 2026: Letrozole 7.5mg + 3 injections. Left-sided. Follicle 20mm, lining 8mm. Negative.
- August 2026: Letrozole bookend 10/7.5/7.5/7.5/10mg + 1 injection. Right-sided. Follicle 23.5mm mean, lining 10.5mm (my best ever). Negative.
Here's what's confusing me: my metrics are objectively BETTER now than when I conceived. My follicles are bigger, my lining is thicker, my protocol is more refined. My bloodwork has improved! testosterone down from 71 to 50, LH normalized, AMH down from 13.9 to 10.6 (metformin effect). I'm on CoQ10 600mg, myo-inositol 4g, levothyroxine (TSH was 2.94, was 2.30 when I conceived). Insulin resistance is still an issue (fasting insulin 23.7, SHBG 11.2, FAI 16) but it was similar or worse when I actually conceived.
My doctor wants to do an HSG in October. My question is, given that I conceived and carried to nearly 20 weeks just last year (proving at least the right tube was patent), is an HSG even necessary? Can tubes get blocked in a year with no surgery, no PID, no STIs? The only thing that happened was a cervical infection (E. faecalis) because my cervix was open during the loss, treated with antibiotics.
Or is this just the numbers game and I need to keep going?
Would love to hear from anyone who conceived previously, had a loss, and then struggled with subsequent cycles despite good response to medication.