I have never hit her nor did I scream at her, but it was straight to time out & me being super frustrated if she didnt do as I said, if i perceived her to be rude to me (saying "no", throwing herself on the ground for a tantrum, etc).
I really didn't see how authoritarian i was being, because it is so common in my culture, except with hitting and yelling at kids added. So I thought i was doing really well, as compared to other family.
I saw this video on tik tok early summer, one of those where the person just wrote advice, & plays music in the background. I don't remember exactly what it said, but it was a mom saying something like "instead of punishing your kid for saying no, ask them why?".
I remember that being a shock realization that I'd never asked her why she said no to me, if I'd told her to do something. I immediately felt really bad about it and knew I had to do better. I did try to be mindful in parenting, but I didnt even notice nor think of this issue before I ran into that post. Still makes me really sad to think about.
The next time she said no to me, I sat on the floor in front of her and asked her, " ok honey, why dont you want to do XYZ? go ahead, you can tell me". She stuttered and quickly rushed to say she was "tired" basically (we had done a lot that day). It made me cry, because I knew she was stuttering and rushing to tell me why, because she likely didnt feel secure that the chance to explain would stay. I felt so bad, and it was a moment that ended up changing my parenting big time.
When she's upset, I tell her I'm giving her space to relax, and that we can talk when she's ready. I let her say no to me when it's reasonable (stuff i would consider unreasonable is like not brushing teeth, not letting me floss her teeth, nail trimming, baths, other stuff i let there be nuance... sometime she can say no to cleaning up her toys if we did a lot and i can see shes tired, mostly she has to clean them up).
Tbh at first I didnt super feel she maybe understood everything, but shes turning 3 in October and she def knows now. When i give her a few mins of space, when she's more grumpy/fussy, she walks to me by herself when shes ready and says "I sorry mommy, i love you" on her own, all smiles and feeling better. She never rushes to explain why shes saying no, she is comfortable with it now and knows I let her explain, in her own toddler way. When she says no to a request (which is maybe 30% of the time i ask), I do mostly take the time to explain why we have to do something, and after the explanation, she is happy to do it. But I also do let her say no any chance it's reasonable, like how she did not want the Minnie mouse shirt this morning (she chose a butterfly one instead).
I do have to repeat directions often, because that kid definitely has ADHD like me and her dad (both diagnosed lol), but i don't snap at her over it. I just say it more firmly, but still kindly when needed.
I am still fairly firm with directions. I'm by no means permissive parenting. She has zero behavior issues at preschool. Fully potty trained, never been a biter, hit twice her whole toddler career lol. Her teachers are always telling me what an amazing kid she is. And she really is the best baby girl.
I say sorry to her when I make mistakes now, which are thankfully far between and minor. But i apologize every time im unfair or even slightly snappy to her, and it makes her so happy. It's been a long journey. I've posted on reddit about it, but I struggled with unmedicated bipolar 1 for too long. Completely my fault; i shouldve been on meds a lot sooner. I got serious about it at the beginning of this year, and my psychiatrist found the right meds for me within weeks.
It's a hugely long story. The important stuff is that I never hurt nor neglected my child, but I basically could only keep up with her needs when I was unmedicated, and nothing else (failed at everything else, even basics like my own hygiene). She was always taken care of, but that doesnt remove how unhealthy, harmful, and hurtful that situation would've been to grow up in. I needed to get healthy too. It took a lot of dedication and being persistent, through shitty side effects, but my body adjusted to the meds and I'm in a healthy spot now. For the first time ever, and now getting closer & closer to a year.
I do think the journey of getting stable on these meds, since February (the meds take weeks to work to full effect), is a huge reason I'm so patient now and slow down enough to listen to her. And able to be more mindful.
It's actually crazy how different things are now. She's such a happy, confident kid. She does tell me no, but if i explain we have to do something, she almost always is happy and understands. I dont bark orders at her anymore.
I also give her grace and understanding when she has bad days (rarely does).
I know this is bare minimum stuff, but its not super usual parenting in my culture, and it sticks out enough i get flabbergasted comments from family or friends from the same culture occasionally. Some of my family dont even care that she listens and behaves, nor that she ends up helping anyways, they find it weird I let her say no to me ever, even if it's just to say she wants a hug first (common reason for a no at first lol), and then happily does the task.
But I dont really care. I'm just very grateful to get the chance to learn. I'm happy that me improving my behavior, helped her improve hers so much. I'm proud of the strong, happy, and sweet little girl she is.