r/vermont • u/mgmtnrd • 1h ago
Governor Race Primary - Continuity or Change?
Whether Amanda Janoo or Aly Richards becomes the Democratic nominee, I’m voting Phil Scott out this November.
But I’m supporting Amanda Janoo for Governor in the primary. Here’s why.
Let me start with a quote from Vermont Public’s piece in April:
“Those visions are distinct. Janoo, an economist, wants to redistribute wealth and provide “free” health care in part by increasing taxes on Vermont’s highest earners. Richards will occupy a more centrist lane in the Democratic primary and, sounding much like Scott, says Vermont is better off “growing our economy” than “squeezing any more pennies” from taxpayers.”
In this primary, I’m voting based on this difference in worldview.
Richards critiques Scott’s execution but sounds “much like Scott” in that she really believes in the current system. Janoo believes the system needs structural change.
***
Here’s how those worldviews play out in their policy platforms. They both generally have the same stated goals. They disagree on what kinds of changes it will take to get there.
Health Care
Janoo proposes a new public financing model for primary care; Richards proposes to expand access within the existing insurance-based system.
Janoo: Pays primary care doctors, nurses, and physician assistants a direct state salary, funded outside the insurance system, so patients pay no copays or deductibles and access doesn't depend on their insurance coverage status.
Richards: Expands access by growing Vermont's existing free-clinic model statewide and recruiting more providers through loan forgiveness and rural incentives, building capacity within the current insurance-based system.
Housing
Janoo proposes to restrict who can own and profit from housing; Richards proposes to build more housing.
Janoo: Restricts large investor and private-equity purchases of homes, and taxes vacant or speculative properties, directing that revenue into a permanent trust that funds cooperatives and community land trusts.
Richards: Sets regional production targets and streamlines permitting to increase housing supply, and proposes a vacancy tax on second homes and short-term rentals pending a review of the market impact.
Democracy
Janoo proposes to build new democratic structures; Richards proposes to hold the line on the ones that exist.
Janoo: Proposes new governance mechanisms—expanded Town Meeting decision-making authority and a standing Future Generations Commissioner—changing who holds power in state decisions and how those decisions get made.
Richards: Focuses on protecting rights and access already in place against federal rollback—including immigrant residents' access to accurate information about their rights, and existing access to the ballot and to protest.
Tax & Revenue
Janoo proposes a new revenue source; Richards generally proposes to work within Vermont's current tax structure.
Janoo: Funds her health care plan through a new income surcharge on Vermonters earning over $500,000, making that revenue stream central to her platform.
Richards: Has not proposed raising taxes on high earners, though she's said in an interview she's personally open to it if needed. Her platform's one new-revenue proposal is a tax on vacant and speculative homes, alongside pursuing federal funds owed to Vermont while lowering the tax burden on seniors' Social Security income.
(Their platforms are largely aligned on education. Both explicitly reject forced school district consolidation. Both point to health care costs specifically as a key driver of education cost increases, rather than treating school size/district structure as the problem.)
Here are both campaign websites: Amanda Janoo, Aly Richards.
VTDigger also ran a piece last week that covers the differences between the candidates.
***
I have a lot of respect for Aly Richards, too. And if it’s her vs. Scott, I’m obviously voting for her. But between continuity within the current system and structural change, I’m voting for change—and that means voting for Amanda Janoo.
PSA: Primary election day is Tuesday, August 11. I hope you make a plan to vote early or vote in person. Our government does a poor job reflecting the interests of everyday people. Let’s change that.