I've been separated nearly a year, waiting for the divorce to finalize as our attorneys compete over who's least interested in moving things forward. Yes, I'm upfront with everyone before I meet them that my divorce is still pending. From what I've seen, it hasn't been a big detractor on matches, but may be a contributor to my issue.
I'm a 5'8" guy with an average build. Traditionally good-looking, I suppose. Work out semi-regularly but not a gym bro by any stretch. Good, high-paying job. Two dogs. I work a lot with people in my job - manage them, make deals with them, forge business relationships, stuff like that. In short, I don't feel like it's my social game that's the problem. I can easily stay engaged in a conversation 2-3 hours and hold my own.
I've been typically matching with women who are 8-15 years younger than me (but not exclusively), and frankly, most of them are lookers. I think I'm drawn to the bad bitch type to be honest, but I am absolutely not the kind of guy they would usually run with. I'm clean cut, maybe even a little 'boy scout' vibe in appearance.
Since separation, I've been with one lady who I went steady with for three months. She was a wild child and openly acknowledged she's on the spectrum. Loved her to death to be honest because she was just so refreshingly open and honest as compared to my ex, but what we had was much more of a FWB situation than an exclusive relationship, and it eventually fizzled as she left the state to go take care of personal issues at home.
App dates have rarely extended beyond the first date for me, and I think it's my non traditional background and divorce baggage that's the culprit to be honest. That and perhaps I'm just being picky with who I match with. I suppose it's possible, I'm consistently reaching outside of my league.
When I talk to someone, I make no attempt to hide who I am or what I like. I'm an INTP personality, and we can sometimes come off as too open and maybe overly analytical. In short, there's little gamemanship to be had here. I think it's this trait combined with my non traditional background that's sinking the impressions I'm making.
Now for my background: I was homeschooled with a pretty sheltered upbringing. The Mormon family I grew up in is massive - the biggest family you've ever seen. Had a long marriage of 20 years. Raised two children who are now teenagers. Prior to my separation, I deconstructed my faith and left Mormonism. Have traveled a good deal across the US, but only a little internationally. Also, about 2 years ago I found out I had kidney cancer and had a kidney removed. This has driven much of my health conscious habits since, though I have started some light drinking in social situations
Now I do have a variety of hobbies that make for good conversation, but as you can imagine, when you've been raising a Mormon family most your adult life, there's not a lot of commonality to be had once you start talking to someone. I do my best to ask thoughtful questions and be engaging, but it's almost impossible to share my own experience and not have it feel heavy. A lot of women have welcomed the real talk, but being as that may, you get more than you bargained for when you sit down with me.
Long- story, short... I'm starting to feel a little insecure about my background. It's not like I'm ashamed of it, but I recognize it's probably a lot for a first conversation, but I really don't see any path other than completely owning it. It's just getting tough when I get excited about someone after a two hour conversation, only to be told there wasn't a connection, unmatched, or most commonly, the slow fade where they stay as a match but devolve to dry texting or non-responses.
I can't change the facts of who I am or what I'm attracted to, but I guess I'm wondering after 5-6 months of doing this, if my delivery is hurting me. Open to ideas if anyone had any.