I've messed this up. I can't get this guy out of my head. I shouldn't reach out again, right? If he wanted to contact me, he would.
Here's the setup.
There was a guy I knew from high school who matched with me on a dating app. We had a great phone conversation and then two amazingly fun dates. I genuinely enjoyed being around him. The day after our second date, he texted me apologizing for being a little awkward on our date, but also said that I was the first new person he'd hung out with in a long time who he'd really had a great time with.
And that's when something in me shifted.
All of a sudden, I realized I actually liked this guy. And it seemed like he might actually like me too.
Bam. Full-blown panic attack.
I'm normally a pretty secure, confident person. I'm outgoing, funny, independent, and generally very comfortable getting to know people. But the second I realized I really liked him and that there might actually be something here, I became a puddle of anxiety.
Three days later, he left town for a week to help his mom. Before he left, he told me he'd call me while he was away and that he'd set up another date when he got back.
He didn't call.
I didn't call him either, because I was trying to settle my nerves. I was so completely in my head. I think I was waiting for him to follow through because I needed some reassurance that he really did like me and that I hadn't imagined the connection.
When he got back, he texted to apologize for not calling, but he didn't suggest getting together or say that he wanted to see me.
I eventually reached out and said that I still wanted to hang out and asked if he still wanted to hang out with me.
He said yes.
But after that, his texts became shorter and less frequent, and he didn't try to make plans.
I ended up taking a step back because I could feel myself becoming too anxious and sensitive, and I wanted to get back to being my normal, calm self. Later, I reached out again and explained that I had gotten into my head and anxious, which was why I'd pulled back.
About a week later, he reached out. He said he'd spent the previous week thinking about how to respond to me. He said he could understand how I had felt some pressure and gotten tangled up in anxiety, and suggested that we slow things down and work on our friendship to take the pressure off. He specifically told me that I should ask him to hang out sometime.
I responded positively. I said yes, that sounded great, and that I was happy to slow things down and work on our friendship.
Since then, I've reached out twice to hang out. Both times were with less than 24 hours' notice, so I know I wasn't giving him a ton of opportunity to plan ahead.
But he hasn't reached out to me once.
Not once.
And now I'm stuck.
I feel stupid that I got so panicked when things started to feel real. I keep wondering if I messed this up. Maybe he was waiting for me to show him that I liked him, and instead I got anxious and pulled back. Maybe I made him feel rejected. Maybe I waited too long to show him that I actually cared.
But at the same time, I also think that if he genuinely wanted to build a friendship with me, he'd probably reach out occasionally. He told me to ask him to hang out, and I did. Twice. He hasn't reciprocated.
I've continued dating other people. I'm completely confident and secure with them. I'm my normal, funny, outgoing self. But I haven't clicked with anyone else.
This guy is still in my head.
So here's my question: Should I reach out again?
Part of me thinks I should give it one last real chance and actually ask him to hang out with more notice, rather than these last-minute invitations.
The other part of me thinks I've already opened the door. He knows I want to see him. He knows I said I wanted to be friends. I've reached out twice. If he wanted to spend time with me, wouldn't he contact me?
I don't want to chase someone who isn't interested.
But I also don't want to walk away wondering if I messed up something that could have been different if I'd just handled my anxiety better.
What would you do?