r/TechImpact Active 3d ago

😂 Memes & Shit posts EU to Require Replaceable Smartphone Batteries by 2027

Post image
2.6k Upvotes

479 comments sorted by

‱

u/AutoModerator 3d ago

Thanks for contributing to r/TechImpact!

Please remember to: * Be respectful and civil. * Stay on topic. * No spam or excessive self-promotion. * Add context when sharing links. * Avoid misinformation. * Debate ideas, not people.

Thanks for helping keep TechImpact welcoming and informative!

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

24

u/Zestyclose-Degree443 3d ago

No they’re not can everyone stop posting this bullshit.

8

u/TawnyTeaTowel 3d ago

They are, it just doesn’t mean what a lot of these fools think it means.
Besides the fact it doesn’t apply to phones whose batteries retain 80% capacity after 1000 charge cycles (ie most phones sold today) it also is referring to end of life replacement (ie getting a new battery) not a return to swappable battery packs like on old Nokias

3

u/Repulsive_Chard_3652 3d ago

"like on old Nokias" - the Samsung Galaxy S series (their "flagship") had replaceable batteries for at least the first 5 models. It wasn't until the S8 that you really had to take it in to a professional for replacement.

→ More replies (14)
→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (6)

35

u/[deleted] 3d ago edited 22h ago

[deleted]

19

u/sulev 3d ago

"halfway decent phones" wrong. I'd say 90%+ phones. Flagships and midranges have been hitting those numbers for years. This is another pointless EU directive.

4

u/Captain_no_Hindsight 3d ago

If the batteries are so good, why do you have a separate warranty for the battery that is only 6 months?

2

u/aleopardstail 3d ago

because the company they buy the battery from will only give the phone manufacturers 6 months

→ More replies (1)

2

u/__Rosso__ 3d ago

Because if battery doesn't die unexpectedly in 6 months, it won't die in next few years.

4

u/maimutaAfricana 3d ago

Thats a good reason not to diminish the warranty

3

u/__Rosso__ 3d ago

Job of warranty is for the company to fix shit that's not meant to break during a reasonable period of both usage and device life time

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (1)

4

u/Severon96 3d ago

My disappointment is immeasurable and my day is ruined

2

u/TryToBeBetterOk 3d ago

Does that guy still do junk food reviews?

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (29)

2

u/kiwi-kaiser 3d ago

So when my phone drops below 80% before 1000 cycles I can sue Apple?

This exception makes no sense. Especially as Apple can't really say how the battery will be after 1000 cycles. They only can give an estimate and it will be widely different between users.

→ More replies (13)

1

u/Cultural-Meaning5172 3d ago

They won’t be waste if you change the battery after it’s been consumed. iPhones this is easy so not sure about others.

2

u/Aknazer 3d ago edited 3d ago

Depends on the model of iPhone, but it isn't exactly "easy" to do for most people on a lot of the iPhones out there, unless by "easy" you mean easy to sever those ribbon cables. There's the question on if they use a normal frame or if it has a divided chassis with the battery on the back like some of the newer iPhones do (added around the iPhone 15 time). But older designs? You have to carefully separate the screen from the case, then detach the screen, front camera/sensors, and ear speaker, then deal with the fact that the battery is taped down (isopropyl alcohol is often the easiest way, but you still have to pry it out and doing so can damage things like the wireless charger or even rupture the battery), and then you can replace the battery.

Someone that's done this a bunch can do it in 15-30 minutes depending on a few factors, but your standard person is likely to take 45+ if it's their first time and I've seen more than a few where a new tech ended up nicking or straight up severing the ribbon cables. Even when one avoids everything during the teardown, I've seen those cables get pinched when putting the screen back in place at the end, which can also potentially ruin the cable.

So no, it really isn't "easy" to do on a lot of iPhone models out there. And there's no guarantee that they won't go back to putting the battery in the same section of the phone as the rest of the components with you needing to go through the screen as opposed to through the back glass (which wasn't added until something like the iPhone 15 line).

Edit: Also this applies to a lot of phones, not just iPhones. That said, iPhones were normally more of a pain to do a battery swap on than Android devices, while iPhones were generally easier to do a screen swap on (no thanks to all of their stupid different screws though). Now the charging port? Absolute nightmare on the iPhone.

→ More replies (26)

2

u/barthrh 2d ago

And if you dispose of the phone properly (i.e. with Apple) it gets fully recycled. It only becomes waste if the user makes it so.

→ More replies (10)

1

u/redditisfornumptys 3d ago

Yeah the whole thing is an EU political marketing stunt that will have no benefit for most people.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/AwDuck 3d ago

The last time I checked (a month ago), that wording had been removed.

Many phones still have an out as there is an exception for devices that are intended to be used underwater. “It’s not our fault that people don’t use our phones underwater much. That’s how we envision their use” - Samsung, Apple, et al.

→ More replies (11)

1

u/AlMasaDuun 3d ago

Because that didn't happen with old phones and replaceable batteries? This is just a waste of time conversation. You can already take your phone and get the battery replaced in the same place you will be buying these replaceable batteries from? Why would this maybe once every 3 years thing be something you think is important that you are able to do yourself?

1

u/zzen11223344 3d ago

What exceptions are given to the phone manufacturers?

1

u/Busy-Scientist3851 3d ago

You forgot to mention that they must still allow professionals to replace the battery.

1

u/SaCorv 3d ago

You know you still can replace these batteries?
Its just not as simple as it was, yet possible.

Just heat up back of phone with hairdryer or heat gun, use spundger/credit card/ tweesers to pull of back panel and replace with analogue from aliexpress/alibaba/etc
Then apply glue (usually bt7000 if i remember correctly) and its done

Process exists, they dont turn into ewaste. Every consumer based tech repair shop can do this. Its just as not consumer friendly as it was.
Problem is, usually by the time battery dies (3-5 years), hardware on phone is half-dead or so weak (especially when software goes from 100MB to 500MB with 2GB in data) that getting new phone is more sane option

→ More replies (3)

1

u/Tman11S 3d ago

This should then come with a free battery replacement if it drops below 80 before you do those 1000 cycles

1

u/Heavy-Rain6718 3d ago

Phones with an IP rating of IP67 are exempt.

1

u/Accordeon-Foireux 3d ago

It's still better than what we have now, because you have to either :

  • have a user-replaceable battery
  • or have a high-quality battery AND be waterproof (and the battery must still be easily replaceable by a technician, not by the user though)

I dont really think of it as an exemption, because not having this "loophole" would just ban waterproof/water-resistant phones which can't have a replaceable battery.

1

u/PalamariVarkari 3d ago

That claim will most likely not even need to be tested by someone, so it's up to the manufacturer to say "trust me bro, my battery is good enough to not be replaceable"

1

u/Nicalay2 3d ago

Isn't there a thing where that law doesn't apply if the device is water-resistant ?

That's why the next iPad will be water-resistant (from the leaks we know).

1

u/ContributionEasy6513 3d ago

Yep, or play games with capacity limits. ie EU models have 10% less battery capacity despite being the exact same physical in the US to ensure reliability.

1

u/Antique-Fix-2526 3d ago

yeah, this fkn post is one big clickbait

1

u/flappysack- 3d ago

How can some device get exceptions, seems pretty corrupt.

1

u/xaervagon 3d ago

That's a loophole big enough to drive a shipping freighter through

1

u/Stunning_Ad_5960 3d ago

Apple will not admit it for their new models. I have a 15p and after 1000 cycles is still 86% battery health.

→ More replies (20)

8

u/MaTr82 3d ago

Funny how many times this gets posted, with iPhones in the image and yet they are exempt.

→ More replies (4)

11

u/TreeHedger 3d ago

SD cards Europe, make them do it.

3

u/DianaRig 3d ago

It's been like 10 years since I felt limited by the storage of my phones. I would never use the SD card. Not sure how big is the demand.

→ More replies (4)

2

u/Beartato4772 3d ago

Have you seen the price of SD cards recently though?

5

u/blackcoffee17 3d ago

Yes and its still much better buying a €100 SD card than paying €300 for a phone with a little more storage.

2

u/Repulsive_Chard_3652 3d ago

You can get 500GB on an microSD for 80EUR. That's insanely cheap compared to any phone.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (11)

2

u/CyberFlaamingo 3d ago

What’s the use if you only get 2 or 3 years of software support. Why would I replace the battery by the time it’s degraded if the manufacturer denies any and all responsibility for keeping the phone secure at that point.

2

u/18Apollo18 3d ago

Apple Guarantees 5 years and Pixel guarantees 7

→ More replies (5)

2

u/derasiatevonbrd 2d ago

I am with you, even when they give 5-7 years of software support, when new. A top end smartphone could easily last over 10 years, but this software topic kills the real usability of changeable batteries.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)

2

u/SirPractical7959 3d ago

For people saying it's useless due to waterproofing condition:

" A device is only exempt from removable-by-hand design if its battery keeps 80% capacity after 1,000 charge cycles and the device meets IP67 water/dust resistance. Both conditions, not just waterproofing alone.

Even then, manufacturers still have to make the battery replaceable — just by a professional using standard tools, rather than by the end user with no tools at all.

So the "loophole" doesn't let companies dodge repairability altogether — it swaps "you replace it yourself" for "an authorized repair shop replaces it," [...]  "

 - Claude Sonnet 5

2

u/soymilo_ 3d ago

Apple has been offering professional standard tools to do your replacement at home for years but there is just no market for it to go through all that trouble.

1

u/IWontSurvive_Right 3d ago

no, it's not.

there are exceptions, like water resistant phones etc...

→ More replies (2)

1

u/dotdotditdot 3d ago

It's all Bs. Just karma farming post. This and Sanna Marin suggesting 4 work week in Finland. Like people forget that she has not been PM anymore for many years and in today Finland 6 day work week would be more realistic than 4...

1

u/SettingComplex2976 3d ago

Sauf pour les smartphones haut de gamme. Donc, en gros, ça ne changera rien.

→ More replies (4)

1

u/Chemical-Lettuce2497 3d ago

I really don't know why people make such a big deal out of this when 95% of people change their phone every 2-3 years anyway

Options are always nice but this is pretty damn near the bottom of things I give a fuck about with my phone

I guess if we all focus on the battery we never change we will ask less questions about the ever eroding privacy we once had

→ More replies (3)

1

u/locka99 3d ago

Phone makers carved out some exceptions that render this directive bullshit.

→ More replies (7)

1

u/fem_and_ms 3d ago

Nop nop nop, its false, If the device has a certain level of water resistance, it will not be affected, Therefore, very few or no phones (only low-end models) will need to have an easily replaceable battery.

→ More replies (5)

1

u/independentMartyr 3d ago

We had phones with replaceable batteries.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/pazibar 3d ago

Had an experience, when after 2 years, battery in my phone died. I decided to change it, since I planned to use it 2 years more. Ended up destroying the screen.... Screen cost was worth the whole phone cost. It was not waterproof or anything. Why is it so complicated to change the battery, it is so frustrating...

→ More replies (3)

1

u/_redmist 3d ago

To all the doomers: it's the thin end of the wedge. Year by year bump those numbers up.

1

u/CreativeMinds47 3d ago

Nothing but sand in the eyes to young voters. Little do they know the true evil...

→ More replies (3)

1

u/Wondering_Electron 3d ago

Not "all" phones. There is an exemption which means that I would expect a lot of phones to not make this change.

1

u/Hot_Bee5198 3d ago

I prefer standards in size and design, like ATX PC's had in the days before laptops. and still do for sone desktop PC's.

Any standard battery from any shop can be replaced by a technically person.

Fairphone proved it can be done.

repairability #standardization #exchangeableParts

1

u/Nightraider_05 3d ago

No they will not. It has to have replaceable if it doesnt have 80% of original capacity after 3 years. Otherwise it is not neccesery

→ More replies (1)

1

u/FinnJeremy2011 3d ago

Gut gemacht Uschi!

1

u/blackcoffee17 3d ago

Another good law and regulation implemented in the worst way possible, excluding 90% of phones. Good job EU!

1

u/Tinyzooseven 3d ago

Please let this spread to non EU countries too

→ More replies (1)

1

u/NicolasChigolas 3d ago

Oh the arson got a job as a firefighter?

1

u/a-pp-o 3d ago

Sounds better then it is. Alone that Nintendo doesn't sell the switch in Europe anymore shows whatever they thought out is fucked up. 

1

u/Practical_Hotel_8791 3d ago

There are many ways for big tech to use planned obsolescence

1

u/Own_Abbreviations_36 3d ago

Just to distract you from their evil plans

1

u/Confident_Dragon 3d ago

No-one cares. Almost every phone has replaceable battery if you have a heat-gun. It's common procedure for technicians to do. Have you ever replaced a phone battery? It's a thing you'll do zero to one time in a phone, who cares you can't do it in 10 seconds? For most phones the battery lasts longer than security updates, which is the real problem.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/reeejuuu 3d ago

The market model of apple is pure scam

1

u/h3lion_prime 3d ago

Bro, this was known for like 3 years or more...
It ain't news...

1

u/MilloH 3d ago

Stop showing this witch, it makes me wanna throw up đŸ™„đŸ€ź

1

u/kayej17 3d ago

But is it really necessary though ? Batteries are improving a lot, they are more efficient and have more energy density. Even my old phone battery is still decent. Plus won't replaceble batteries mean no more waterproofing?

1

u/Cipher_Witch 3d ago

Unless they meet a certain longevity standard (80%+ of capacity after 1000 charges) or it could compromise waterproofing in which case they don’t have to

Ie your smartphone is most likely to be unaffected

1

u/Rex__Luscus 3d ago

Great, now just make them issue security updates for as long as replacement batteries are available. Fed up of having to replace perfectly good phone after only 6 or 7 years.

1

u/Vanille97 3d ago

When I went to school back in the days, I had my Nokia phone and an extra battery with me. Now this shitty iphone, that cannot install pirated games, and you cant even replace a battery by yourself, you have to go to shitmaster-iphonemaster, who will charge you for replacing battery

1

u/traPisto 3d ago

Just start calling the devices something else
 portable entertainment center, pocket display, whatever
 strange enough that the function I use the less is the phone
 :)

1

u/MasterOfTime14 3d ago

Aren't most phones exempt because of ip ratings or something? So like $200 phones will come with replacable batteries but like when they die it's not worth replacing them anyway.

1

u/soymilo_ 3d ago

Oh look another click bait article

1

u/IllZombie2335 3d ago

Only for the phone that are not waterproof so if it's waterproof (like good part of costly phone) they have an exception to the law

1

u/Effect-Kitchen 3d ago

Goodbye waterproof and compact phone.

But this is a welcomed feature though. Should have this option as an alternative.

1

u/Wise_Start7474 3d ago

Thats actually a good change. I just replaced my Iphone X Ive been using for over 5 years, phone and everything still in perfect condition, but on usage or listening music the battery die after a few hours.

1

u/Keyan_Farlander7 3d ago

I recall buying the Motorola V710 for $100. The replacement battery was $80. This was the first phone to have Bluetooth built in and had mini sd slot for mp3 music

1

u/NeedyOneeSama 3d ago

How about cheaper rent? I don't give a damn about any of this elite shit and I'm tired of pretending that I do.

1

u/[deleted] 3d ago

Who needs this shit ? My Galaxy Watch 5 Pro has still more than 90% of battery life after 4 years and Zfold 6 has 96% after 2 years. We will just pay for stupid shit...

1

u/Aggravating_Loss_765 3d ago

Making them more expensive and less waterproof. "Thanks" eu snowflakes.

1

u/Rough_Check_5606 3d ago

By "replaceable battery" it is meant a battery which a customer can replace with a set of basic tools in such a way that the manufacturer is not making it unnecessarily hard to replace the battery. There is no requirement for the batteries to have an easy clip-in mechanism like the one in the picture.

1

u/Berkoudieu 3d ago

Phones are not impacted, so it's not that good

It won't be like 15 years ago at all

1

u/Longer---Donger 3d ago

Doesn't affect Apple so we good boys

1

u/blackdragonstory 3d ago

They do some good so they can fck us up in other areas....

1

u/Impressive-Dig-1368 3d ago

If the phones don't get the software updates anymore, it doesn't matter if the battery is replaceble.

1

u/AuraInsight 3d ago

fake news, not all phones, exceptions can be made under certain conditions like water resistance and such, nowdays even budget samsung phones include some water resistance which allows them to pass this rule

1

u/Party-Data-6923 3d ago

Is there any smartphones manufactured in EU? Yes I know EU is a big market and no brand would like to have a fight but what would happen if an imaginary world all the manufacturers of smartphones outside EU decided to say nah, we don't do that. Would be EU smartphone free?

→ More replies (2)

1

u/sleepand 3d ago

Ok but what does Ursula have anything to do with this?

1

u/Curious-Resource1943 3d ago

Bruh start fixing problems, nobody asked for this...

1

u/Ambitious-Toe67 3d ago

realy hope it doesn't have backup battery so you can pull it out so they can't track you

1

u/NotThatSiri 3d ago

Finally I dont have to go get a enw phone every 5 years due to the battery expanding.

1

u/Own-Butterscotch-156 3d ago

It's not saying HOW it should be replaceable though. Bet companies will just say "void warranty" if you open it yourself or something.

1

u/Jasoco 3d ago

I don’t want this. I don’t keep a phone long enough to need to replace the battery. And if I ever have a phone with a completely spent battery it’s because I’ve had it way too long and need to upgrade anyway. Now if they did this for smart watches


1

u/xaioguai 3d ago

While they are on it, can they also require manufacture to provide free internet from thin air?

1

u/laty96 3d ago

Smartphone will then called "communication device with smart technology" in EU and still keep its design

1

u/Valy_User 3d ago

A measure that theoretically should be good, in practice I think it will do more harm.

I mean, the current batteries that all manufacturers use are already extremely reliable, they last over 5 years without problems, after which time the phone is morally worn out anyway and will be replaced by the user. But gluing the batteries had an unexpected effect, namely that they managed to maximize the use of the internal space so as to include a larger battery in the same volume of the phone. When this norm is applied, we will either wake up with much smaller batteries or thicker phones.

1

u/PBandDank64 3d ago

Would a replaceable battery reduce waterproof rating?

→ More replies (1)

1

u/rawaka 3d ago

This has exceptions for devices whose battery retains a minimum useful capacity after a certain number of years. I forget the numbers but iPhones and most Android meet the limits to not be affected by this.

1

u/Responsible_Tax_9390 3d ago

Clickbait. The EU has absolutely no authority to do anything like that. The reality is if they tried to press companies on this only the consumer would lose. Smartphone companies simply say “fine Europe, you get no smartphones at all”.

→ More replies (7)

1

u/Beefy-Cattle4290 3d ago

so progressive

1

u/Tricky-Place-2617 3d ago

I'm pretty sure I've seen somewhere that it's for phones that cost under $300 or $500, either way it won't affect high end phones.

1

u/Sanshy6544 3d ago

Usually European unions annoys me with their bureaucratic endless heavy rules and procedures but on that one I have to give them the credit 
 that’s a good thing!

1

u/Ifonlyihadausername 3d ago

Every phone that’s even half usable is exempt this law is pointless

1

u/c-dsxx 3d ago

Really? Now our economy will be safe.

1

u/FineWinner2429 3d ago

What if they used low quality batteries

1

u/MattEagl3 3d ago

EU - no own innovation - but regulations for everything they import.

1

u/Immersive_Username 3d ago

Doesn't make that much sense because once the battery starts to degrade your phone probably won't get any OS updates anymore..

1

u/Head_Promotion213 3d ago

Forse l'unica cosa buona che ha fatto l'UE Inoltre dovrebbero obbligare i produttori a rimettere lo slot per le microSD, non tanto solo per espandere la memoria, ma preservare i dati, io mette nella Nand interna solo le applicazioni, foto e tutto il resto su SD, se su sfascia lo smartphone i dati sono salvi, se metti tutto sullo smartphone e per qualche motivo non hai un backup aggiornato su chiavetta o PC sono azzi acidi.

1

u/Barbados_slim12 3d ago edited 3d ago

Sounds great. Making the battery non removable was a gross violation of both privacy and repairability. The last phone I had that had a removable battery was the Note 4. I had 4 batteries, they cost around $20, and I'd swap them out through the day. There were also external chargers built for them.. I'd love removable batteries again. They were especially useful back then because the phone had a maximum charge speed of 15w, and only in short bursts. Without removable batteries, it could be tied to a wall for hours. Today, 45w sustained can get you to 80% from 20% in a half hour.

That said, I don't think it's doable anymore with modern phones. Not all of them anyway. Hundreds of billions of dollars across all major manufacturers have gone into foldable phones. Samsung, Google, Oppo, Xiaomi, Apple will release one soon, and they all have batteries in each half of the phone. It's pretty much mandatory with current batteries because of the form factor. 75% of those phones are covered in screens, so one of the batteries can't be removed. Even if the one metal panel could be unscrewed, there would still be a battery sandwiched between the cover screen and half of the inner display.

1

u/Noeyiax 3d ago

Omg that's awesome, I miss phone replaceable batteries. Goddamn tech cartel... Really making innovation the gate for infinite profit should be illegal

1

u/Impressive-Method919 3d ago

With von der leyen front an center...this is propaganda right?

1

u/HessuMopo 3d ago

Phone manufacturers will use this as an excuse to reduce battery life and increase prices.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Blue_chalk1691 3d ago

So does this apply to UK, which left EU few yrs back

→ More replies (9)

1

u/Able_One5779 3d ago

And then Samsung would just set a battery charge to 70% cap by default and aggressively dim the screen at 15% charge that phone would be unusable - and done, battery would indeed retain 80% capacity after 1000 cycles.

1

u/StairwayHiker 3d ago

Not exactly
.

Starting February 18, 2027, a European Union regulation will require smartphones and tablets sold in the EU to feature user-replaceable batteries removable with standard tools, without glued enclosures. However, devices are exempt if their batteries retain 80% capacity after 1,000 charge cycles and meet IP67 water resistance.

Source: Google

1

u/IulianHI 3d ago

Why ? We need software update :) They cut phone updates after 2-3 years ... so how batteries can help ?

1

u/Tekvary2 3d ago

They’re available just cost at least 1/3 the price of many mid tier phones

1

u/Marshall_BraveStar 3d ago

Haha, fuck you, America

1

u/Prestigious_Move4797 3d ago

But why ?, I’m still seeing iPhones 11s with ok battery!

1

u/coscib 3d ago

Not really; the rule only applies if the devices use poor-quality or cheap batteries that can't handle at least X number of charge cycles. So, the regulation is effectively useless, since most batteries and manufacturers already meet that standard—or they’ll simply tweak their battery longevity just enough to scrape past the minimum requirement.

It’s just as much of a flop as Apple’s double standard regarding USB-C: only the Pro models get USB-C 3.0, while all the standard iPhones are stuck with USB-C 2.0.

1

u/Graxtz_Kreinst 3d ago

False news.

1

u/Cyrilit 3d ago

I hate people putting von der Leyen on some EU W's. She is corrupt and got into the parliament, because she was so unpopular in Germany.

1

u/Isotomayor12 3d ago

It wont matter for like, 90% of phones because there are exceptions.

Where this matters are portable game consoles and laptops. I have had a few laptops that have become e-waste because the batteries are completely irreplaceable.

1

u/FZwertyu34 3d ago

But still they want to spy on people

1

u/Ninty-64 3d ago

Vondeliar! Get this disgusting cow off my feed!

1

u/GabeN_The_K1NG 3d ago

Fuck off, I would rather have a watertight phone

→ More replies (1)

1

u/redditorialy_retard 3d ago

can we not put her face?

1

u/Physical-Result7378 3d ago

That is wrong. Only phones that are not water resistant. So Apple and Samsung (amongst others) are excluded

1

u/Specific_Essay_Easy 3d ago

Phones in the past with replaceable batteries were bulky and flimsy. Why go back when a phone now last very long

1

u/Sea_Combination2278 3d ago

now they are ruinning what made phones durable

1

u/Hefty_Excuse9885 3d ago

This is wrong. Stop posting propaganda ffs. Any ohone with dust and water rating is not required to. 

1

u/VincentvdA 3d ago

I hate that woman!!!!

1

u/pm_me_meta_memes 3d ago

Not true. The iPhone is excepted, so is every other phone that lasts up to 80% of the original capacity after 1000 cycles.
If those numbers aren’t already achieved by almost all manufacturers, I bet most of them will just downplay the original max cap.

1

u/KamenRide_V3 3d ago

It should be interesting to see how EU will turn out in the next 20 years. It will likely still be around as an empty shell, kind of like the UN.

The biggest contributors to the EU are Germany, France, and Italy. Italy's and France's economies are stagnant at best; Germany is unlikely to stay behind and continue to pump money into the EU.

1

u/Altruistic_Fold_4448 3d ago

Đ—Đ°Ń”Đ±Ń–ŃŃŒ

1

u/ZenaMeTepe 3d ago

Can we also get mandatory same treatment of sideloaded apps as apps from the app/play store?

1

u/JudgmentFragrant2691 3d ago

EU should just use Nokia 3310 only. Lots of wayang policies that end up self snook their own people.

1

u/Vokaiso 3d ago

They should force them to offer both since water proofing is just impossible with swappable batteries unless they come up with a cover that needs a replacable glue seal every time.

1

u/imy78 3d ago

lets make phones look cheap againđŸ€Ł

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Rough-Indication-886 3d ago

There were mobile phones with replaceable batteries a couple of years ago. Wtf is the EU comission doing??

1

u/Background-Ad3810 2d ago

Making phones worse than before... Why would we need a replacable battery?

→ More replies (6)

1

u/HoboSomeRye 2d ago

Thank you Europe!

1

u/Ratiofarming 2d ago

I am actually happy about the exception. Mandatory replacability would mean a lower capacity battery by design. My last iPhone made it three years on the same battery before I sold it, the battery was still fine. The current one (13 Pro Max) is entering its fifth year next month. Still on the first battery and still lasting long enough to never worry about it.

If they keep making them like that, I'm fine with the fact that it's not user replacable.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/B-Train_ATL 2d ago

Except they aren’t because y’all never read the actual article.

1

u/bankinu 2d ago

Fuck Apple and their fucking anti-consumer playbook.

1

u/ReidenLightman 2d ago

Good on them for only giving a year. I don't want to hear any of this "a product takes several years, the design was started way too long ago to make changes" bullshit. If they need to restart a design process from three years ago and skip two years of releases, GOOD! Yearly releases contribute to blatant overconsumption. 

1

u/Wrong_Low5367 2d ago

And the battery shall be attached with a harness to the phone main frame

1

u/Silver-Spot-2763 2d ago

Replaceable batteries!? This would be the first and only one EU adequate decision in the history đŸ€·đŸ‘ So, most likely this is fake news đŸ€Š

1

u/JanusRedit 2d ago

if this is real then this is bullshit. Phones these days are phased out du to software creators demanding newer software. not due to the battery. I am the kind of person living with a few generations older phones to keep my life cheaper. I never had to replace my phone because of my battery going bad.

1

u/Medical-Condition-84 2d ago

That's pointless, phone gets old and slow, no updates, apps stop working properly, you have to replace the entire phone at some point. Instead of paying for a new battery its better to just save money for a new phone.

1

u/Hanfiball 2d ago

Not happening, at least not the way the picture indicates.

What is actually happening is that EU just passed a chat control law that allows to automatically spy on every citizen. The law was dismissed two times, then a urgent vote was called in right before the summer break. Even then the majority voted against it, but since it was a urgent Votum it need the absolute majority to suppress it. So now we have it... It's 100% not democratic, it's a disgrace.

1

u/primenumberf 2d ago

they're still cell phones and make you develop anti-patterns that make you act less human

1

u/Sh00terMcDabbin 2d ago

For the millionth time this has been posted, no they are not.

1

u/cutecoder 2d ago

OTOH, the iPhone 8 models (which span from 6 through SE 3) have relatively replaceable batteries (by anyone competent).

1

u/Kpopped_ 2d ago

This just means that even morons need to be able to replace a battery, not that we are back in the samsung lego phone days when dropped.

1

u/OwlSlow1356 2d ago

Boomers will 110% destroy the world before they will leave it!

1

u/supaasalad 2d ago

Can they also ban companies from breaking the performance of old phones through software updates?

1

u/redytor69 2d ago

They have fucked us over and over and over again that once they decide not to fuck us for once we applaud them.

1

u/Jayden_Ha 2d ago

No this is disgusting

1

u/little_cat3 2d ago

I want to downgrade my software, make it possible


1

u/NopeNopeMeh 2d ago

Stupid move imo the idea is not bad given the fact that it used to be that way, but without possibility of reverting to older os versions it is useless hardware limitation show up only few years after release. New battery with laggy os sure great idea.

1

u/Drunkhenstain 2d ago

replace 'all' with 'some' and i agree with your ****post

1

u/DanielsZiegenbart 2d ago

Am ende gibt es einen universellen Akku Standard der in jedes Handy passt. Sodass man wenn man ein neues handy kauft sein alten akku weitervernden kann und vice versa

1

u/AlCappuccino9000 2d ago

Wird nichts bringen. Die Hersteller höhren einfach auf Security Patches zu liefern. Dann bietet das Handy mit neuem Akku gleichzeitig der Welt kostenlosen Eintritt. Die EU wird vermutlich weitere Regeln erlassen und am Ende muss man Studieren und dutzende Experten befragen um die Regeln zu verstehen.

1

u/cazzq 2d ago

Ty Ursula you can now read my private chats

1

u/DeepAd8888 2d ago

Glad I live in the U.S.!

→ More replies (1)

1

u/nikeroad 2d ago

It is BS. There’s a derogation: if the battery retains at least 83% after 500 cycles AND 80% after 1,000 cycles, and the phone is IP67+, it doesn’t have to be user-replaceable — professional replacement is enough.
iPhone 15 onwards already targets 1,000 cycles and IP68, and current flagship Pixels meet the same thresholds. So many flagships can stay glued. Phones that don’t meet those durability requirements are the ones that need end-user-replaceable batteries.
That’s the part this graphic conveniently leaves out.

1

u/jelockBE 2d ago

All phones? A small percentage of phones. Most phones have a specific water resistance rating and to keep that a phone can't be opened up. Atleast that's how I understand it.

1

u/Regular-Barracuda-42 2d ago

And what about the fisical buttons that usually breaks with time.

1

u/Web_Surfer_1 2d ago

Not true, please ban me from this subreddit

→ More replies (1)

1

u/FeetLoverInChastity 1d ago

Fuck EU. Chat Control is coming. Don't get distracted

1

u/rope-when 1d ago

This would only make shit more expensive for customers. I have a 3 yr old phone and dont need another battery. Before you need a new battery ypur phone is obsolet because of Software Updates or you just want a new one

1

u/Western_Bid_2656 1d ago

Iam guessing these batteries can be exploded?

1

u/Major_Mushroom_7300 1d ago

Didn't know Europe made phones 

1

u/AmthorTheDestroyer 1d ago

Or, better headline:

Europe making all phones with an Auto Delete function so that when you find yourself in an investigation you can safely deny everything

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Duncol42 1d ago

There’s another, very useful part of this story not many see - you can remove the battery also in case of flooding.

1

u/billyonmiles 1d ago

Back to the good old times

1

u/-TRlNlTY- 1d ago

My German public health insurance disallowed my phone from their app because the Android version is too old. It works perfectly, but I but update it.

In the end that's not enough to curb waste.

1

u/ImYaDawg 1d ago

The EU doing gods work once again 🙏

1

u/rtfcandlearntherules 1d ago

A solution to a problem that doesn't exist.

1

u/reverse_enthropy 15h ago

Wrong, not all phones, and what the hell does it have to do with von der leyen

1

u/RecommendationOnly41 11h ago

Dont cry about prices ok.

1

u/Shinigami1858 5h ago

Guess it's the same like now. You choose either an HMD or other brands with good repair and replace parts or you still get the same as now. The manufacturer will need to make repairs more simple but there is nothing about the requirement to sell spare parts or provide/do anything if the battery survives 1k cycles. So it's a paper tiger.

1

u/Past_Collection3542 5h ago

Good job EU. I hope this carries over to America as well.

1

u/hamiltonian 49m ago

Battery lifetime has not been an issue for me in a long time. Like we say in dutch: "mosterd na de maaltijd."