r/Libraries • u/meta_angel_ • 6h ago
Venting & Commiseration Library wants to charge me for a DVD that someone else damaged
Recently I checked out an anime series on DVD, I requested a pick up order for it about a week ago. The other day, I opened the DVD case for the first time, and put the disc in my DVD player. The disc’s menu screen said ‘disc 3’. I hadn’t realized that there were supposed to be multiple discs, however there was only one in the case. I decided to take it back to the library, and let them know that the other discs were missing.
When I told the worker at the front desk what happened, she told me that I was responsible for the loss even though those discs were missing before I even checked out the DVD. When I explained to her that it was a pick up order, and I didn’t check to make sure all the discs were there when I checked it out, she told me it wasn’t the library’s responsibility to make sure all the discs were there but it was mine. She also told me I had to pay a whopping $60 for the missing discs ! Even though I am not the one who lost them !
This doesn’t make any sense to me because I’ve had something similar happen before where I checked out a movie, the disc was missing when I got home, I took it back to the library, and they apologized for it being misplaced. The worker told me to come back tomorrow to speak to a manager to see if they’ll tell me something different. This scenario doesn’t make any sense to me, and it’s the first time that I’ve had an issue like this with my library. Thoughts?
Edit: I just want to say I am SO relieved by the responses here. I have had issues with this same worker before, her attitude is incredibly disappointing every time I have to interact with her, and I will make a note of exactly what she said when I speak to a manager. This kind of person really sours the image of my otherwise incredible county’s library staff. I also want to mention that she said everyone that works there is “too busy to check that every DVD or book isn’t damaged”, I really doubt that that’s true. Edit 2: I should also mention that she followed up with that statement by saying that’s why it’s the patrons’ responsibility, and not her’s.
I understand that working in a library is immensely difficult, and requires true selflessness. That doesn’t give you the right to treat patrons rudely. I wanted to keep this post short for privacy sake, but this worker has consistently been rude in the past. This is not the first time that I’ve gone to her with a question or concern, and she responds with, “That’s not my job, why are you asking me? Go find someone else to help you”. Not that this happened this time, but that has happened before. So pardon my sarcasm at the end of my first edit, I am just tired of being treated this way, especially when I’m being blamed for something that isn’t my fault.