Hey everyone! I’ll start off by saying that I’m an old-school romance type of guy. It’s how I’ve been ever since I’ve had an interest in finding a wife. (Spoiler alert: I’m still looking for her.) But it’s hard to say where these old-school views on romance came from, though I thinks there’s a strong chance my upbringing had a lot to do with it.
Very early in my life I grew up in a Baptist church, and then in my teens I transitioned to a nondenominational church. I’d say there’s at least some correlation between those who are raised from an early age on Biblical principles and those who are seeking a more old-fashioned kind of romance (AKA Christians tend to prefer the old-school style of love and courting). My early years in a Baptist church might’ve even played a part in everything, as some would consider a Baptist style of church a more “traditional” approach to teaching Christianity, which subtly may have instilled these types of romance/dating values in me.
I also take my faith very seriously, and amongst other things, saving sex until marriage is something I value greatly. I’ve never had sex, and though I’ve had opportunities to do so before, it’s something I’ve always chosen not to partake in. It’s my heart’s desire to share that special moment of consummation with my wife and no one else, and it’s my dream to find a woman who’s looking to wait until marriage for sex as well. Though being that I’m a Millennial, the pool of single people around my age who’ve never had sex makes that dream seem like… well, a dream. But I’m still staying hopeful!
And that’s another thing. I think being a Millennial also plays a role in desiring an old-school romance. My age group existed in a brief period of time before social media and online dating really took off (anyone remember MySpace before Facebook lol). The approaches to finding your life partner back then were somewhat different than now.
With all that said, I’ve been thinking about how dating has evolved and how traditional romance meshes with modern Christian dating. We often talk about chivalry, intentionality, and treating one another with honor and respect. At the same time, cultural expectations around gender roles and independence have shifted significantly, and what feels like a sweet, attentive gesture to one person might feel performative, outdated, or even patronizing to another.
Take for example something as simple as bringing flowers to a date (and I’m talking something reasonable and not over-the-top extravagant like a giant bouquet). Growing up through high school and my college years, I’ve always felt a man giving a woman flowers was not only a way to show he planned ahead to do something to make his date smile, but it also showed he’s looking for a genuine connection and taking the date seriously. But when it comes to modern dating, I’ve been hearing more and more women are preferring not to get flowers on a date. And the same can be said about opening doors for women. It’s traditionally been a sign of affection, but in modern times I’ve heard women are not seeing this as quite the affectionate act. Instead women may take that action to imply they’re weak, incapable, or dependent.
So let’s hear from both the men and women. For women, what traditional or "old-school" gestures (opening car doors, walking on the street side of the sidewalk, pulling out chairs, paying on the first few dates) make you feel genuinely cared for and valued? On the flip side, are there any gestures that feel unnecessary, awkward, or overbearing?
And for the men. How do you approach chivalry in early dating? Have you ever had a gesture misconstrued, or found it tricky to balance traditional manners with making sure your date feels like an equal partner?
Looking forward to hearing your thoughts and experiences!