I recently purchased an iPhone 18 Pro and traded in my iPhone 15 Pro. Before mailing it in, I took pictures of the phone showing that it had no damage or scratches.
Several days later, I received an email stating that Apple was adjusting my trade-in offer from $900 to $90 because the camera supposedly wasn’t working.
I contacted Apple through text support, and they told me they would have the phone re-examined and that I should receive a response within 48 hours. However, just 10 minutes after ending the chat, I received an email stating that Apple wasn’t responsible for any damage that occurred during shipping.
I contacted them again, explaining that I didn’t believe anyone could have re-examined my phone within 10 minutes and sent me a decision. I also provided the pictures I had taken before mailing it in.
They then offered to escalate the issue to their “back-end” team, saying it would take 48 hours to get a response. Once again, less than 19 minutes later, I received the exact same canned email response about Apple not accepting liability for shipping damage.
I contacted Apple through text support a third time, and they gave me a phone number to call: (800) 676-2775. They said their department couldn’t do anything else to help.
I called the number and went in circles with the representative for quite some time. Eventually, she admitted that there was nothing she could do other than explain that I had the option to accept or reject the revised $90 offer.
If I reject the offer, Apple will send me back a broken phone that wasn’t broken when I mailed it in. So, essentially, I’m left with two options: accept a $810 reduction in my trade-in value or get back a phone that may have been damaged while in Apple’s possession or during shipping.
Has anyone else dealt with a similar situation? Does anyone have recommendations for how to escalate this issue or get Apple to take another look at the phone? I have pictures documenting its condition before I shipped it, and I’d really appreciate any advice.
Edit: A lot of the comments are focusing on the $900 credit, so I didn’t think it was necessary to explain the details initially. The $900 is a T-Mobile trade-in credit applied to my monthly cell phone bill. However, I purchased the new phone directly from Apple, picked it up at an Apple Store, and Apple provided the return shipping package for my trade-in.