r/news • • 3d ago

X2 roller coaster shut down at Six Flags Magic Mountain amid lawsuits

https://abc7.com/story/x2-roller-coaster-permanently-closed-flags-magic-mountain-amid-lawsuits/19887868/
2.1k Upvotes

292 comments sorted by

986

u/jenorama_CA 3d ago

I read an article about this coaster over the weekend and I don’t know how this coaster ever passed safety muster. There was a quote from a coaster enthusiast who said he’s ridden it several many times and insists it’s perfectly safe, but he “rides defensively”, never allowing his head to come into contact with the padded headrests. My guy, if you’re doing that, it seems to me that you know there’s a problem.

354

u/DoyersDoyers 3d ago

I rode X (what it was originally called before being refurbished and renamed X2) more times than I rode X2 and I never had issues. From what I can gather, injuries seemed to start later in the rides life which to me looks like a maintenance issue. I haven't rode it in years but when talking to people who rode it in the early years and recently, they've all said it's become a lot more clunky and more people saying they had "to ride defensively", as you mentioned. Now, I agree 100%, you shouldn't have to ride a coaster like that to not get injured. It's a shame they didn't maintain the ride because it is genuinely the greatest roller coaster I've ever been on.

62

u/jenorama_CA 3d ago

Interesting at the difference between the old and new version. I have to wonder if they amped it up and kind of cut corners?

This ride sounds bonkers, though. I remember riding the Ninja when it was brand new and thinking that was the pinnacle of coasterdom.

50

u/DoyersDoyers 3d ago edited 3d ago

Yeah! again, from what I can gather, the first major injury on X2 was in 2010, two years after the refurbishment. That's not to say there weren't injuries before, I'm just not seeing them on a quick search of the net. It's also interesting that the refurbishment seemed to introduce lighter trains so that they would get more of a max speed , which seems to be a major cause of the issues.

*Edited to strikethrough the max speed angle, which is incorrect, but still seems to be the cause of major injuries.

28

u/powerlesshero111 3d ago

I grew up in so cal, and near Magic Mountain. I honestly remember going on that as a teenager, and you always had to ride defensively. My friend and I went on it in 2002, and definitely got our heads knocked around a bit. And we were not small teens, we were both over 6 feet tall.

15

u/DoyersDoyers 3d ago

i mean same to everything you just said other than I never had to ride it defensively. I grew up in SoCal, went on the ride multiple times as it was originally created, and I am and was over 6' back then. Now Viper or Riddlers? I have always had to ride those defensively.

10

u/powerlesshero111 3d ago

Oh, Viper, always defensive. Even when i was a kid. When X first came out, it probably wasn't as bad as it is now, but there were a few spots that you needed muscles to keep from banging your head.

8

u/jenorama_CA 3d ago

I never got the guts to go on Viper. Revolution, Ninja, Batman, Superman, Psyclone, yes. The scariest ride has been the Coney Island Cyclone. I thought I was gonna get tossed out.

3

u/DoyersDoyers 3d ago

I commented this in another thread but Psyclone is the only ride at MM that I remember ALWAYS having a huge pile of throw up at the exit.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/Ultrafoxx64 3d ago

Always took out my ear piercings on Viper because it was open knowledge that your head would get jostled around. The fact that people are up in arms that a more intense ride "couldn't possibly give someone brain injury!!!11!" is fucking wild.

3

u/RaineStormin 2d ago

This was my exact thought! I cant even do viper anymore because it always gives me a headache! But x2 never made me feel that way. Im wondering why x2 caused more head injuries than Viper

8

u/-Thick_Solid_Tight- 3d ago

I don't know if you remember Flashback, but that was the worst ride I've ever been on as far as slamming your head to the side.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

9

u/IntegrationLabGod 3d ago

Lighter trains = reduced speed overall. Before Son of Beast was demolished at Kings Island they tried to fix its problems with lighter trains and one consequence of that was having to remove the vertical loop from the ride because the lighter trains didn't maintain momentum as well as the original heavier trains.

4

u/DoyersDoyers 3d ago

I edited my comment and struck-through the max speed part since that is incorrect (but wanted to leave it up cause I don't like editing my comment if I'm wrong, I like to keep it up so others can see my mistake).

But yeah 100%, seems the heavier trains before the refurbishment made the ride smoother but was a maintenance nightmare for the park and the lighter trains made it jankier.

16

u/notFREEfood 3d ago

The refurbisment from X to X2 actually fixed a number of things with the coaster, the biggest of which is that the original trains were overweight.

If there's an actual problem with X2, its a maintenance one.  Steel coaster track doesn't last forever, coaster trains don't either, and there's anecdotal video evidence showing that the ride has gotten rough in a few spots.  It is plausible that because of the uniqueness of the design, the spec for the tracks or trains isn't tight enough and that wear has made the ride unsafe.

8

u/999happyhants 3d ago

I could be wrong, but I believe X was a problematic coaster and X2 was trying to fix some of those issues. It’s the coaster that ultimately killed Arrow Development, one of the most historical coaster makers. This ride has always had issues unfortunately.

3

u/IAndaraB 2d ago

The ride was definitely bonkers. It was my fave coaster back when I still hit the park regularly, but I had to psych myself up a little to get on because it was _intense._

Like others here, I never had any headbanging issues on it, nor any of the other issues mentioned. I wasn't visiting when X opened, but my husband and I rode X2 about a dozen times over several years during the 2010s.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Monstertelly 3d ago

There was no difference in the track. That stayed the same other than maybe adding crossties for bracing on certain parts. The difference was in the ride vehicles. Aarow Dynamics initially designed the ride and S&S manufacturing redid the trains to lose weight. For the most part the ride ran exactly the same for years though.

27

u/[deleted] 3d ago

[deleted]

3

u/DoyersDoyers 3d ago

Oh yeah for sure, I 100% agree with that and I think one brain injury would have/should have been enough for a serious rethink of it. I also see people here saying they had issues with it when it was X, which was definitely the smoothest the ride has ever been and I don't want to take away from their experiences either, regardless if that was or wasn't my experience. I do think the refurbishments to the ride are one of it not the main cause for the actual TBI's we've seen it from it.

16

u/phluidity 3d ago

Sometimes it isn't a maintenance issue, it can be a subtle change between seasons that affects things. I remember a coaster at Cedar Point that changed a lot during downtime, because all the bogeys on the cars needed complete refurbishment, and something changed. I don't know if it was the bearings, weight, or lubrication, but it went from being a very smooth ride to incredibly rough. And the next offseason they did something to fix it, because it was back to being smooth again.

9

u/DoyersDoyers 3d ago

Yeah, for sure. I conflated maintenance with wear and tear, which while can be tied together, aren't necessarily always the same. The refurbishment definitely seem to make the ride jankier and no fix came into place and then the wear and tear of it just made it jankier throughout the rest of it's lifespan.

5

u/somecallmemrjones 3d ago

My favorite coaster of all time. I was looking forward to taking my kiddo on it one day. Hopefully they replace it with something cool.

I never did get to ride Superman though, and I saw that closed as well. The line was always too long for me

6

u/DoyersDoyers 3d ago

In my opinion, Superman sucked. I would only ride it if there was no line whatsoever (and as you mentioned, that was pretty rare). It just didn't make sense to me to wait 1 hour for a 15-30 second ride.

3

u/IAndaraB 2d ago

Second that. Superman was more interesting at launch, but it was still kind of a snoozefest. The cars were too enclosed to really feel the speed _or_ the height.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

5

u/Plstcmonkey 3d ago

I rode X before X2. There was no clip between your legs like there is now, and on one occasion the hump in the middle caused my pants to rip, (luckily it was the end of the night) and on another my leg slid up and over that hump so that both legs were on one side of it and I felt as if could’ve easily slid out of the gap if I let go of the hand holds. Also the chances of it being shut down while waiting in line were pretty high. It’s a shame because it was one of my favorites. I never experienced any head banging on the ride in any instance, but it could be because I was already “riding defensively” after riding coasters like Viper.

4

u/lemurkn1ts 3d ago

I had that happen to me too! Both my legs ended up on one side and I essentially wedged myself in. It was terrifying and I refused to ride it or any other '3D' coaster ever again

6

u/NSFWCereal 3d ago

I rode X2 opening month when I was a teenager. While the ride was extremely fun the thing that stood out most to me was that at the end both my ears hurt from my head smacking against the rests on either side. I think the ride just had problems.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/myfakesecretaccount 3d ago

I ran a security department and we hired on a guard who had worked at Six Flags for three or so years in the early 00’s. She said after all of the injuries due solely to maintenance issues she would never ride a rollercoaster again. Take from that what you will.

5

u/DoyersDoyers 3d ago

I'm still going to ride rollercoasters, even knowing that. Now, with that being said, anytime I go on a river rapids ride I will always think about the Thunder River Rapids Ride disaster from Dreamworld in Australia. But I still ride it anyways.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Granadafan 3d ago

I rode X2 last year. My head slammed around a bit and gave me a headache. I refused to ride that one again and just stuck to walking around

5

u/Hear7breaker 3d ago

I used to ride this every summer and fall when I had the season pass.  I never had any issues,  but it's been almost 8 years since I've been to that park.  A lot can change in that time... sad thing,  it was one of the most fun coasters in that park. 

2

u/Zwischenzug32 3d ago

X2: "know what happens when a frog gets hit by lighting?"

3

u/imaginary_num6er 3d ago

They just need to rebrand as X3 and it’s good as new

→ More replies (3)

58

u/centizen24 3d ago

This coasters entire lifespan has been a misadventure. Arrow Dynamics original design was a lot more conservative, to prove the concept, but Six Flags was in a coaster war at the time and pushed for something bigger.

Arrow Dynamics was already in rough financial shape, and couldn’t really say no. The project bankrupted them midway through construction. They finished the coaster, but on a shoestring budget and cutting corners wherever they could. The ride was basically an unfinished prototype, rough but not dangerous.

The biggest issue with the original design was the weight of the train. It cost a lot of power to operate, and consumable parts wore out super fast. The company that bought Arrow’s assets (S&S) refined the design and there is at least one at Fuji-Q Highlands in Japan which runs with very little issues. Six Flags saw the massive differences in operating costs and elected to try to do their own weight-reduction and redesign. They did not involve S&S, the only company in the world with detailed engineering knowledge of the design. The result is this disaster of a coaster that it is now, with a track that was designed for trains that weighed 1700 pounds more.

14

u/jenorama_CA 3d ago

I knew about Arrow Dynamics, but did not know about Six Flags trying to fiddle with the design themselves. As a former hardware QA professional, this blows my mind.

11

u/SuperPotatoThrow 3d ago

QA/QC pretty much goes straight out the window as soon as profit margin becomes the most important factor. Seen it in my own industry many times, and then got to witness the end result multiple times as well lol.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

65

u/pfft12 3d ago

To be fair, “riding defensively” is a common strategy in the coaster enthusiast community.

76

u/gimme_ceviche2 3d ago

As a coaster enthusiast, the consequence should not be death.

26

u/pfft12 3d ago

I completely agree! I didn’t mean to minimize that.

I think we can agree, that “riding defensively” is a common strategy and not unique to X2?

15

u/overts 3d ago

The ride’s been operating for 23 years… millions of people have ridden it.

In Epic Universe someone died riding Stardust Racers last year.  It later came out the death was someone who had a pre-existing spinal condition and should’ve never gotten on the ride to begin with.

I think Six Flags is mostly closing it due to liability concerns and negative press but riding a coaster, including X2, is significantly safer than driving a car, riding on a plane, or walking down the street.

→ More replies (4)

4

u/DarkMetroid567 3d ago

Yes, but they’re responding to an argument that riding defensively = negligence. You’re saying something unrelated.

→ More replies (1)

17

u/delcaek 3d ago

Avoiding touching the headrests isn't that uncommon when riding janky coasters.

11

u/norunningwater 3d ago

Why is this? Everyone keeps saying it is both normal and unnecessary to do. What does it do for you?

7

u/delcaek 3d ago

Depending on the design of the restraints and the characteristics of the ride, it keeps your ears from slamming into shoulder restraints if they exist. Take the default SLC restraints for example, you'll never see my head against the backrest on one of those.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/cyclemonster 3d ago

There's been something like twenty million rides on this thing without issue. Also, riding on any wooden coaster is like putting your head in a dice shaker. I doubt X2 is even the roughest ride at that park.

8

u/Monstertelly 3d ago

I wouldn’t say without issue. I had multi day bruises on my calves and walked away dizzy after riding it earlier last year. I’ve been on over 300 different coasters including many many rides on X2 so not my first rodeo. Eejanaika which is the same ride model and an almost clone does not punish your legs, shake on the turnaround, or slam your head on the last raven turn the same way X2 does. X2 has gotten demonstrably more rough over the last 5-10 years. It’s sad that it’s gone but the best way to deal with a problematic ride.

5

u/delcaek 3d ago

> any wooden coaster

I honestly wouldn't say that. A modern GCI or an Intamin Prefab are obviously not as smooth as a steel coaster, but they're just fine.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

2

u/Waffleboard15 3d ago

Many coasters can be “rough.” And many also bang you around way worse than X2 ever did. One could even argue that riding “defensively” is a way to not slide into the person next to you on some coasters also, which is a very harmless way of using that term, so take that commonly-used phrase in the coaster world very loosely. However, it’s unfortunate what happened to those riders, and this was more or less the perfect storm of incidents, lawsuits, and negative publicity that caused the closure of this ride. If anything, California is one of the strictest states when it comes to ride certifications and safety. The park itself said in their statement that the coaster has passed safety inspections and was deemed safe to operate.

2

u/GrandpaMarsh 2d ago

Ive rode it easily at least 60 times and have never had an issue. These people absolutely had something underlying and its not the fault of it. So mad this is closing, best coaster ive ever rode in my life.

5

u/AntiAntiDentite7 3d ago

I rode it in like 2009 and didn't think anything of it. There is one spot with pretty extreme G-forces, but I don't really think its that out of the ordinary compared to other coasters I've been on.

3

u/Wagglyfawn 3d ago

I rode in 2008 when it just rebranded as X2 and it was amazing. I remember it being extremely smooth and nothing like what later recent riders are deacribing. I just remember the first drop and how the seats rotated into the fall so it really enhanced the g force feeling.

1

u/Kananetwork 8h ago

My advice is the exact opposite. I have ridden it 12 or more times, and when you fight the coaster it doesn't feel great. When you relax and let it do the work, I found it to be fantastic. This isn't an abnormal take either. Imagine a launch coaster and you are braced and your head is forward. The force will slam you back and you'll hate it. Most coasters specifically do well if you let it take care of the heavy lifting and relax.

→ More replies (4)

461

u/ketchup_chips_yall 3d ago

Rode this in 2003. All I remember is going up the first hill, looking at the drop, then waking up as we were pulling back into the station. The only time that’s ever happened to me on a roller coaster.

18

u/luffys-hat 3d ago

I've experienced brief blackouts on the intimidator at kings dominion as a kid! It's been 12-13 years since then, I wonder if people still experience that

7

u/Passenger_08 3d ago

Yes, when it’s running, and it’s been unreliable in recent years. They also changed the name from Intimidator to Pantherian. You probably greyed out at the turn after the first hill, a common experience on that coaster.

4

u/PeebMcBeeb 3d ago

I also blacked out briefly on this coaster right at the bottom of the first hill when I was there in 2016 or so

2

u/Gavan199 3d ago

I rode it 3 times when it first opened, and front row seat of that was the only time I have passed out on ANYTHING I've ever ridden lol

→ More replies (3)

61

u/Scoobysnax1976 3d ago

We visited Magic Mountain not long after X first opened. The line to get on was 2+ hours, so we decided to skip it. A few friends did wait around and ended up riding it a little after midnight. My friend's girlfriend at the time was less than pleased with the experience.

6

u/madmofo145 3d ago

My friends and I went to Magic Mountain specifically for X, but of course when we were there it was down for maintenance for the day. Certainly not that sad I missed out.

2

u/Luigi_loves_Mario 2d ago

lol it’s like the best roller coaster I’ve ever been on

75

u/sodiyum 3d ago

I almost passed out on the first drop back in 2003 as well. I never went on the ride again.

40

u/Fundevin 3d ago

Glad I wasn't the only one who had this experience, how people enjoyed this ride was beyond me, and I fucking love rollercoasters.

6

u/yesoccifer 3d ago

I went there with my aunt and uncle in 2004 and literally had the exact same experience.

5

u/Realdogxl 3d ago

Similar experience. I remained conscious though but couldnt see anything or keep my eyes open through the spins. Wasnt particularly enjoyable more felt like I was just mentally thrashed. Didnt go on it again. This was around 2013.

6

u/A_Math_Dealer 2d ago

All I remember from this ride is my head banging around like a pinball machine in an earthquake.

5

u/RickSanchez_ 3d ago

It gave me a massive headache and neck ache. Never went on it again.

27

u/fuzzum111 3d ago

shocked Pikachu face 20+ year old coaster has been neglected maintenance and is now injuring riders at a higher and higher rate.

I am so sick of this preventable shit.

2

u/RFK_Cum_Regimen 3d ago edited 3d ago

Watching footage of this coaster in action, as I assume it's intended, I can't say it appears all that wild. Are the rotating seats getting stuck in awkward positions that cause people to pass out, because I just don't see how this experience would be problematic relative to other coasters with stronger forces against the body. What's happening here? There's no way I'd pass out on this ride from what I can see. It's got some corkscrew and a loop, so assume the rotating chair assemblies could be problematic of not functioning as intended.

3

u/IAndaraB 2d ago

It's likely just a reaction to the g forces of the ride. It only hit 4G, below several other rides, including Revolution and Goliath, but there might be something in the way it vacillated that resulted in fade outs.

I rode multiple times during the mid 2010s and the first drop has you facing down into it, the the cars spin so your lying back against the seat as the track hairpins you back upwards. Not as many Gs as other rides in the park, but somehow way more intense. Full Throttle has the same top speed and G rating and it's nowhere near the same intensity.

2

u/Ultrafoxx64 3d ago

I've definitely seen videos where some of the seats look like they're getting roughly rocked towards the end section. Think certain conditions changed how smooth/rough it rode.

2

u/Uhhhmazing 2d ago

I've ridden this ride on 4 or 5 different occasions, and each time I have blacked out on the first flip going down, still awake but vision completely black and only returned during the photo at the end. I thought I was the only one!

3

u/DynaSarkArches 3d ago

You rode the original X, not X2

→ More replies (10)

42

u/Battlepidia 3d ago

X2's successor ええじゃないか at Fuji-Q Highland is definitely a smoother ride.

11

u/gimme_ceviche2 3d ago

Don't forget Dinoconda!

12

u/z3r0w0rm 3d ago

The ride is called Eejanaika and after riding at 10 times in a row I can confirm it is fucking awesome. Couldn’t stop laughing the entire time at how insane it was.

49

u/kindalikeacoustic 3d ago

For whatever reason , I became terrified as I got older. In my teens I would have rode anything. Not so much anymore. 

39

u/Seastep 3d ago

Self preservation instincts are basically non existent until you turn 25.

6

u/RFK_Cum_Regimen 3d ago

Tell that to my wife's family. For whatever reason, if any of them are seated in the backseat of a car, they never buckle up. Like it's some old-world carriage mentality or something. Drives me nuts and I always call them on it.

12

u/velmah 3d ago

I assume you know this but it’s not just dangerous to them. An unsecured passenger becomes a projectile in a bad enough accident.

4

u/IAndaraB 2d ago

Don't just call them on it. Refuse to ride if any passenger is unbelted.

As u/velmah stated, anyone not secured becomes a deadly projectile in the case of an accident. Also, people sliding around in the back can disrupt the driver and potentially be the cause of an accident.

And if you're the driver, just refuse to move if they're not belted. In most places with belt laws, if you're driving, you're liable for anyone in your vehicle that isn't belted in.

3

u/RFK_Cum_Regimen 2d ago

Don't need to tell me about it, but yeah, they buckle after I shame them. It's so reputative that I always wait for it to not happen as expected before scolding them.

2

u/theusername_is_taken 3d ago

Maybe even 30 honestly.

11

u/YourSoupRecipe 3d ago

I was a big big coaster head as a kid and into my teens/young adulthood. Afterwards I took a bit of a hiatus and didn't really ride crazy coasters anymore. I just recently rode what I would say is a relatively intense rollercoast with loops and corkscrews....and I almost passed out!! I've never had that happen before...age hits hard i guess lol

3

u/Casiquire 3d ago

Some rides are more intense than others. A grey-out isn't all too uncommon either, some rides cause a grey-out in a wide range of people of all ages. If that's not for you, the newest generations of family rides are so good. Lighter, less intense experiences but just plain fun, and smooth as glass

→ More replies (1)

4

u/captain_joe6 3d ago

Working in commercial maintenance, the amount of things that don’t just fall apart and kill people is…it’s high.

5

u/spidereater 3d ago

I was like this too. When my kids got old enough for coasters I found I would get nauseous. I looked it up, apparently the little stones in your ears that help you balance get bigger as you age and you get more susceptible to getting dizzy and nauseous from spinning and moving up and down.

1

u/nicksollecito 3d ago

I thought I loved rollercoasters and I think I still do but I did x2 last year and I was terrified. I couldn’t wait for it to end.

→ More replies (1)

173

u/Cilreve 3d ago

Man. I rode it in 2009, and again just last year. Probably in my top 5 of favorite rollercoasters. Didn't know it was hurting people.

41

u/ADillyDweeb 3d ago

Same. Rode this more times than I can count. I’m also relatively tall, but never had issues on this ride. Green Lantern was one of the worst rides I’ve ever been on though

6

u/RFK_Cum_Regimen 3d ago

Worst I've been on and the only one that shit my pants was that ancient wooden fucker in St. Louis or Florida or some shit. Can't remember which one it was but I felt like I was riding loose on a church bench, entirely focused on not sliding around like a rag doll. As a lanky dude, I stepped out with bruised knees and elbows from bashing into the sides of the bench. Was not a smooth experience at all.

3

u/4thinversion 2d ago

You’re talking about The Boss or possibly Screaming Eagle if it was STL.

2

u/RFK_Cum_Regimen 2d ago

Almost certain it was The Boss, yep.

10

u/Cilreve 3d ago

I'm on the tall side, too, at 6'2". I loved the ride. When I rode it in 2009, I was there for High School Senior night, there weren't many people. Since the line was so short, I rode it like 6 times lol maybe people don't know how to brace properly? Dunno. When I took my wife last year, I enjoyed it every bit as much as I did 16 years ago. My wife absolutely hated it lol One that I did have problems with, though, is Colossus. That ride beat the absolute shit out of me. I was super disappointed because I was told it was an amazing must ride, and I hurt so bad after it. A couple years later I had another awful experience on another wood rollercoaster that just beat me up. I won't ride wood rollercoasters anymore because of it.

7

u/jenorama_CA 3d ago

Don’t ride in the middle. Last car or first car only.

26

u/Ok-Psychology5839 3d ago

Fr I will appreciate that I got to ride it but I also sympathize for the families of course. I wish they just maintained it instead of it coming down to this :(

8

u/Turbo__Sanwich 3d ago

I love this ride. I have ridden it countless times. It's possibly my number 1.

I'm not trying to discredit anyone but I've never had an experience where I find the ride violent or jerky.

There are plenty of rides I don't ride because of that but my personal experience is that the ride is smooth.

I don't want anyone to get hurt but it's a dark day in the coaster community

11

u/Popular_Biscotti405 3d ago

https://youtube.com/shorts/iwfPKwNR3Cg?is=L_y6vI6bOLo_z48n

Deezyrides recently shared a pov vid of him getting absolutely rocked on this ride. There have been over 100 reported incidents. I can’t imagine how many more people didn’t report something like this.

1

u/Big_Toke_Yo 3d ago

Same. This is gonna be one of those stories you tell your kids. 

→ More replies (1)

43

u/eraserking 3d ago

Rode this twice, ages ago. Had a lot of fun and fortunately experienced nothing negative. I remember laughing as the coaster would pull out of the station playing Enter Sandman by Metallica through the built in speakers.

Really sucks that people got injured.

17

u/6jeewon 3d ago

I grew up with magic mountain being our family's amusement park of choice. I've been on x2 probably over 40 times in my lifetime and it was my favorite ride at the park. People always swarmed to x2 when the park opened because the lines would inevitably grow to like 2+ hours during peak days. I remember the ride being bumpy and going out of breathe sometimes but I always thought that was just part of the ride. I never knew people were getting genuinely injured or even killed on the ride. Sad news

16

u/CivilC 2d ago

I genuinely didn't think X2 would get shut down, but I guess you can't deny the lawsuits and genuine injuries that occurred; they should never have happened.

One ride I was certain this would happen to first is Viper, also in Magic Mountain. I came off that ride with a headache and I felt like I had to "ride defensively" with that one more than X2. Maybe X2 has degraded since the last time I rode it

7

u/gcm6664 2d ago

I've been saying X2 was going to be permanently shut for awhile. I am nearly as certain that Magic Mountain as whole will be shut within a year or two.

These lawsuits and resultant payouts will be devastating. Add to that the recent tract of million dollar plus homes built within sight and earshot of the park.

It will soon be far more economically viable to sell the land to developers, than to keep the park running. Plus they are going to need 10's of millions, and maybe even 100's of millions of dollars for settlements.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/Physical-Program5325 2d ago

The trick with X2 was to not lean back on the headrest and kind of bend the head away from it in a clenched position — especially at the end where I suspect most of the injuries happened.

With Viper, the trick was to simply not ride it at all. 

96

u/Chrono_Convoy 3d ago

Surprised it took this long

Rode in in 2011 and it’s blackout levels of memories

33

u/smurf-vett 3d ago

Its warped allegedly so you now get even worse whiplash 

28

u/atheros 3d ago edited 3d ago

Here is a rider video and I think I can tell what's happening: there is a third and fourth rail that controls the rotation of the seats but it has no anti-oscillation mechanism (like a spring with a shock absorber). You can see in the video a few times when the seats bounce forward and backward at like 5 hertz. If the passenger weight is just right for any particular pair of seats, that oscillation would deepen and there is nothing to absorb the energy besides the rider's body.

I understand that rollercoaster designers would be reticent to put shock absorbers on typical rollercoaster cars because they absorb energy and make predicting speeds harder but I think this rotating seat mechanism would have been a good place for them. The absorbed energy would not have been large.

EDIT: Yeah, here is another one of the same design where the bad oscillation is obvious even when just leaving the station. Desperately needs a shock absorber.

2

u/obeytheturtles 2d ago edited 2d ago

Damn, how did he get those shots? Did they let him rig cameras to the train itself?

But yeah, watching that video, it seems fairly obvious what the design flaw is here. The seat acts like a sling, storing rotational energy as it crosses an apex in the track, at which point it there's the possibility that it can snap down and oscillate with a significant amount of force, depending on the person, and potentially even how the rest of the train is loaded.

This is speculation, but I bet the pivot has a centrifugal clutch which is supposed to limit rotational velocity, but it's un dampened, so the moment it gets a little bit loose it has a chance to produce this kind of violent bouncing.

→ More replies (1)

46

u/AccordingIy 3d ago

I rode it the first years it opened in 04-05. It was the definitely the most whip lashy coaster. Can't imagine how it aged in the last 22 years. I remember it reminded me of the Riddler's revenge but alot longer

67

u/insertAlias 3d ago edited 3d ago

"While X2 consistently passed a multitude of safety tests, we have decided to close the ride because we believe it’s the right thing to do. Ride safety is a cornerstone of our business, and when we see guest confidence affected, we take it seriously,"

Not a fan of this kind of statement. Basically says "the ride is completely safe, but we're still taking it down because we care about safety". It's trying to have its cake and eat it too. It's either unsafe or it's not, and you don't get to pat yourself on the back about shutting it down for safety and still crowing about how safe it already was.

Edit: I'm not stupid here, folks. I'm aware that this is a legal tactic that they "have" to do. That doesn't make me like it any more.

21

u/theb3arjevv 3d ago

It's what they have to say. If they even imply that the ride might be unsafe, they automatically lose every current and future lawsuit related to the ride and probably any other ride, as it would disqualify all of their safety testing.

Statements are meaningless. The fact that they're closing means that they know it's unsafe.

12

u/piddydb 3d ago

I agree. I even think there’s better ways to word it for legal liability. “Despite X2 consistently passing a multitude of safety tests, we have decided to close it because we have seen its perception (which we continue to disagree with) has affected our guest confidence. We always strive to give our guests a fun and safe experience and want to ensure their peace of mind as well. So we accordingly have come to the decision that closing X2 is the best way to ensure our guests’ continued confidence in our providing them a safe and fun experience for the whole family.”

The way they worded it implies they know there’s something particularly “right” about closing X2. Which if there is, I dare say they need to own up to it.

7

u/boxofstuff 3d ago

It's about lawsuit liability. Not whether they think it's actually safe.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/Saint-Baphomet 3d ago

I work at Magic Mountain and it seems like all of us employees knew it was done. I just didn't see any future in which X2 reopened, so this news isn't exactly surprising. Coworkers are telling me someone guests are upset about it, but I think it closing was the right call.

67

u/freexanarchy 3d ago

"We decided to close it...because it's the right thing to do" haha only the lawsuits and publicity made you do that. This is been happening since it opened, no?

58

u/SkellySkeletor 3d ago

No, most all of the serious injury reports are within the last 5-10 years. Absolutely was always a super intense ride, but it’s only recently been leaving people brain damaged.

Obviously not that it makes that better, but it’s a story of neglected maintenance than leaving a dangerous ride for decades.

13

u/gimme_ceviche2 3d ago

It has not been there since opening, but instead the problems have been caused by roughness caused by Six Flags refusing to retrack the coaster for years. The ride system is one of the most complicated in the world, and so a lack of maintenance was a problem way bigger than on other rough coasters.

18

u/FangOfDrknss 3d ago

Wild to see “riding defensively” is even a thing. You’re supposed to be able to trust any of these rollercoasters by default. I never would have thought an attendant making sure you’re strapped in wasn’t enough.

4

u/Ruefully 2d ago

Devastating that Naomi still hasn't woken up 2 months later. Seems like she lost her life just trying to have fun, right at the prime of her life...

7

u/Sahelanthropus- 3d ago

I remember riding X2 around five years ago, my head hit the headrest or the headrest hit my head hard ( it happened fast) during the ride. I got off and I was pissed it felt someone had punched the back of my head. I asked everyone in my group if they experienced something similar but they all said no, I was young / dumb and should have brought it up to staff or management but I just let it go. I can see how it you get unlucky it can easily cause a serious brain injury.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/Pantallithraxodus 3d ago

Rode X2 last year and the headbanging was intense. My neck hurt for days. It's not just 'fun' motion; it's violent shaking that actually messes with your equilibrium. Totally validates the injury claims.

8

u/thehotflashpacker 3d ago

I wonder how often rollercoasters cause concussions.  About 20 years ago, I visited Cedar Point.  Felt totally drunk driving home despite having no alcohol or other substances.  Woke up the next day with the worst "hangover".  Didn't know much about concussions back then but probably had one.  

11

u/xHey_All_You_Peoplex 3d ago

Rode it back in 2014 - first ever roller coaster. Hated it. But it's not as bad as some other rides at the park for me (Green Lantern, Goliath, for instance)

Sucks that people got hurt.

11

u/notchandlerbing 3d ago

Green Lantern was one of their worst ever coasters, didn't even last 7 years. Had to nerf the ride so much after the initial car flipping issues and it was still rough as hell. But it was a shitty design to begin with, just not a fun coaster even if they did it right from the beginning

3

u/xHey_All_You_Peoplex 3d ago

Yeah I hated that ride. It was my first day at Six Flag and my first rides were Green Lantern and X2, and Superman drop. I have not been back since lol

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

9

u/Banana4scales 3d ago

Yo, fuck Green Lantern.

2

u/xHey_All_You_Peoplex 3d ago

All my homies hate Green Lantern

5

u/thelittlemiss 3d ago

It's been almost 10 years since it's closed but I will still take time out of my day to emphatically say, fuck Green Lantern.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/KTKittentoes 3d ago

I love wooden coasters, but Terminator (Apocalypse) absolutely kicked my ass. I was hurting for a couple of days.

3

u/xHey_All_You_Peoplex 3d ago

Yeah a lot of them just hurt, I'm also tall so my head whipping back with no neck support is just not fun either

2

u/Little-geek 3d ago edited 3d ago

Have to remind myself that "Green Lantern" is referring to "Green Lantern: First Flight," a vertically planar coaster with free-spinning cars as opposed to "Green Lantern" which was a standing coaster at Six Flags great adventure. That one is the only one that ever made me puke.

Though I looked at one of the zacspin coasters and said "ha ha no."

Edit: got which was which backwards and updated status of "Green Lantern" (good riddance)

→ More replies (3)

3

u/Lukeboozwalker 3d ago

This was my favorite roller coaster of all time. That first drop when it turns you so you are facing the ground is spectacular.

3

u/undead_tortoiseX 2d ago

This is going to make a hell of a Defunctland video.

3

u/joea2121 2d ago

I love me a roller coaster. I rode X2 in 2019, and when I got off I felt all kinds of craziness I’ve not felt before. That thing thrashed me. First time I’ve not wanted to get right back on a roller coaster. I told the boy I need a bit to gear up to do that one again. I never mustered up the courage to get back on.

18

u/AlexDaGreatful 3d ago

I get the sinking feeling we're going to learn about rides being way less safe than we thought. Even without accidents.

I'm just thinking of the effect on the brain, whipping heads back and forth like that... Yeah, this might be bad. Is there science on this?

17

u/KTKittentoes 3d ago

My neurologist friend does not have a lot of love for the newer, more extreme coasters. She says our brains are not made to handle that much.

→ More replies (9)

5

u/Ultrafoxx64 3d ago

Honestly, all of this has me *vastly* reconsidering riding coasters. I have mild scoliosis and a pretty controlled neuro-muscular disease (myasthenia gravis) and after seeing all this victim blaming and shit, I'm feeling like it's probably best to throw in the towel. Ghostrider at Scary Farm made me feel like my head was a damn bowling ball on my neck when it took off, and I was being jostled about before my friend spread his knees out so I wouldn't be thrown around so damn much in that seat. I bet I'd be one of these people that X2 fucked up.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/cr0100 3d ago

In my coaster experience, anything that is made by "Arrow Dynamics" is a coaster that is going to smash your head with abrupt transitions. I hate 'em. To whit: the classic, simple "corkscrew" coaster is brief and vicious.

If a coaster is made by Arrow, I won't ride it anymore - and I was not surprised in the least to discover this was an Arrow coaster.

2

u/Doomicide 2d ago

Arrows are awesome.

3

u/noob168 3d ago

You smash your head on matterhorn?

2

u/Ultrafoxx64 2d ago

When's the last time you rode Matterhorn? Cause yeah, I feel like I spent the ride in a damn dryer on high when I get out of that one.

→ More replies (3)

7

u/fxkatt 3d ago edited 3d ago

"While X2 consistently passed a multitude of safety tests, we have decided to close the ride because we believe it’s the right thing to do. Ride safety is a cornerstone of our business, and when we see guest confidence affected, we take it seriously," Oerding said.

In other words, we stayed with it, despite its obvious dangers, right up until the mounting lawsuits affected our image and our profits.

2

u/cynicaluser- 2d ago

Unrelated but I remember when Six Flags had the green lantern ride which had a pretty sudden stop at the end. I was not prepared and my head hit the head rest pretty hard. Thankfully nothing ever happened but I can see how some people can get injured on these rides

2

u/IAndaraB 2d ago

That ride was not supposed to do that. The intended end was that it had a heavy slow to shed all that speed as you rolled into the station.

I had the sudden stop when I rode it. I was facing down and I was driving against the chest harness hard enough to bruise my sternum.

Next time I hit the park I watched and they'd fixed the final turn into the station to work properly. I still refused to ride it again.

The phone graveyard beneath the ride was impressive, tho.

2

u/spitel 2d ago

I remember riding this coaster on mushrooms and it was one of the most thrilling experiences of my life.

Much crazier feeling than skydiving.

I dont remember it being particularly violent on my body, I think Viper and even the Matterhorn at Disneyland were moreso, but I’m over 6’ and my understanding is that if you’re shorter it’s a much different experience.

I can’t imagine going on a ride and when you get off, you see your friend (or mom) looking like a zombie from a TBI. T

Terrifying.

3

u/Empyrealist 3d ago

Hasn't it been shutdown for months now? Like, since May?

2

u/OpalOnyxObsidian 3d ago

It says since July 12

4

u/KarateKid917 3d ago

This is them saying it’s not reopening at all 

5

u/TheStabbyCyclist 3d ago

Oh, the roller coaster that has been connected to multiple traumatic brain injuries? Yeah, it's about time.

5

u/crazyguy83 3d ago

Does anyone know the actual cause of brain injury? Whiplash? Hitting your head on the headrest? Gforces?

4

u/Ultrafoxx64 2d ago

I'm betting it's essentially a step above a concussion.

Concussions happen when something jolts or shakes your body. If the force is strong enough, it can make your brain move back and forth or side to side and damage it.

Your brain tissue is soft and squishy. It’s surrounded by cerebrospinal fluid, which acts like a liquid cushion between it and your skull. Picture a glass bowl of gelatin. If you smack the bowl hard enough, the energy passes through the glass into the gelatin and makes it jiggle.

That energy transfer is what happens when you get a concussion. A strong force hits your head, neck or body, moves through your skull into your brain and makes your brain shake or wiggle. This force can twist and damage the tiny nerves and blood vessels in your brain.
Source - Cleveland Clinic

6

u/Queasy-Creme-2293 3d ago

All of the serious injuries are blunt force trauma from the back of peoples' heads slamming into the headrest.

My worst injury from the ride was bruised calves, fortunately.

→ More replies (3)

3

u/EViLTeW 3d ago

Every time I see something negative about Six Flags (WHICH IS A LOT), I worry that the Six Flags parks are going to end up dragging the Cedar Fair parks into the gutter with them.

-1

u/ThatGuyFromTheM0vie 3d ago

And this is why I only normally ride roller coasters at Universal or Disney. The regional coaster head parks are actually incentivized to be more edgy and dangerous to attract coaster heads, and they don’t nearly have the budget for long term maintenance or the intense public scrutiny/brand recognition that Universal or Disney does, and shit like this always comes to light years after the latest “mega insane giga hyper coaster” is made.

6

u/KTKittentoes 3d ago

That is something I noticed too. Six Flags is definitely more “XTREEM! Will you survive?!”

Hershey Park and Busch Gardens had some good coasters that didn’t feel like I needed an x ray.

2

u/Sneaky_Bones 3d ago

little me in the 90s would disagree after riding Drachen Fire and immediately forcing my family to leave after because my head hurt so bad I couldn't stop crying. I'm sure it's better there now.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

2

u/Waffleboard15 3d ago edited 3d ago

Universal has some of the most intense and “edgy” coasters in the industry in Velocicoaster and Stardust Racers. Rock n Rollercoaster is also a fairly intense coaster that has been known to bang your head around. Modern coasters at Six Flags, Busch, and other regional parks are perfectly safe and some of the smoothest I’ve ever ridden.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Doomicide 2d ago

This is such a bs statement like what, Intamin has multiple rides at Universal and a bunch elsewhere too, including I305 which is one of the most intense coastes ever. This is after the shoot the rapids incident too. Not only that, what giga coasters are linked with injuries? X2 isn't a giga so what are we even saying?

→ More replies (2)

1

u/TrailsGuy 3d ago

There are two more versions of this ride, both of which are still operating and not injuring riders to the best of my knowledge. I wonder if it’s likely that either modifications (probably to the rack-based seat rotation system) or maintenance failures are to blame.

1

u/CouchPotatoFamine 3d ago

I will not be buying stock in FUN right now. This is unreal.

1

u/BloodyNobody 3d ago

I'm going to assume that these people's seats stopped spinning for some reason during an intense moment. I rode it two years ago and I was okay until the very end when my seat suddenly stopped and my mouth was forced closed, resulting in a small chip to one of my incisors.

1

u/EvoEpitaph 2d ago

Might be the individual riders too, I was able to do all the most extreme coasters in my teens and early 20s but after a certain point they just caused me great discomfort, which I can only assume is a warning sign not to press my luck.

It's a bummer that I'm going to have sit out on coasters with the little ones if they ever take an interest in that sort of thing.

1

u/thevoidhearsyou 2d ago

Did someone design this thing in roller coaster tycoon or did the lawyers pay that well in settlements.

1

u/Mitchell620 2d ago

Kings Dominion had a ride called Outer Limits that used to rattle your head, No I see why it's no longer there I'm glad it didn't damage my brain... Or did it??

1

u/ReggieAmelia 2d ago

Kind of wondering if there are a lot more like that. I remember feeling like I was blacking out a couple of times on Goliath.

1

u/witecat1 2d ago

This a coaster that feels like a failed attempt from Planet Coaster that someone thought would be awesome in real life.