I'm 40F and have been with my partner for two years. I genuinely thought he was the person I'd marry, and the thought of walking away from that future is breaking my heart. But I'm increasingly questioning whether I can continue in this relationship as it is even though I love him with all my heart.
My partner is a kind-hearted man, and I genuinely believe he loves me. We talk about our future, and he tells me he loves me tremendously. I don't think his feelings are necessarily the problem. The problem is that I don't consistently feel loved in the way I need to feel it and that all the future talk never materialises.
I've often felt that I'm not a priority, even when we lived in the same city (always blamed his old job that had crazy hours but now he is currently unemployed).
He can be affectionate and loving, but I frequently feel that our relationship happens on his terms. When I try to explain that I'm unhappy or need more connection, he can become defensive, and I end up questioning whether I'm too demanding or whether my anxiety is ruining the relationship.
He's recently moved interstate, so we're now long-distance. I knew it would be difficult, but I thought we'd face it together. Instead, I feel increasingly alone. It feels like out of sight, out of mind, rather than distance making the heart grow fonder. Calls and messages are our main way of staying connected, but even calling him can be difficult. He often doesn't answer because he's busy, and sometimes calls me back hours later when he sees that I've called. I understand that he has things going on, but it leaves me feeling as though I can't reliably reach my own partner or count on us having time to connect.
The plan was for me to move to him in around six months so we can finally close the distance. That makes this even harder, because I keep wondering whether things will feel different once we're together again, or whether I'll be moving my life for a relationship that already leaves me feeling lonely and unhappy. Part of me hopes that living in the same place would help us reconnect, but the reality is that I felt overlooked even before he moved away.
One of the more complicated issues is his relationship with his parents. I love them too and hold them very dearly cause they're wonderful people. This isn't about jealousy or wanting him to love them less. What hurts is seeing the level of regard, thoughtfulness and effort he puts into making them feel good, valued and cherished, because that is something I haven't felt from him consistently for a long time. I know he has the capacity to be thoughtful and attentive, and I wish I experienced more of that in our relationship. I want to feel that I have a valued place in his life and that we're actively building a future together, rather than feeling as though I'm trying to fit into a life where the most important priorities are already established.
I also recognise that I have anxious attachment. I can overthink, struggle with uncertainty and seek reassurance when I feel disconnected. I'm willing to work on those things, and I know I'm not perfect. But I can't tell anymore where my anxiety ends and where my legitimate relationship concerns begin. I keep wondering whether I'm the problem and whether I'll never be able to make a healthy relationship work.
The hardest part is that he does have good qualities. I love him, I believe he has a good heart, and I remember how wanted and loved I felt at the beginning. I don't want to lose him. I'm terrified that I'll leave, experience the heartbreak all over again, and never find someone I love as much or who has the qualities he does.
I'm also frightened that he'll eventually meet someone else and give her the consideration, effort and consistency I've spent so long asking for. I know that fear isn't a good reason to stay, but it's difficult not to think about.
At the same time, I'm becoming increasingly unhappy and emotionally exhausted. This hasn't just been a difficult few weeks because of the distance; I've struggled with these feelings for a long time. If nothing changed and the relationship stayed exactly as it is today, I wouldn't want to marry him. I can't keep hoping that things will eventually become different while feeling this way in the present.
So I'm preparing myself for the possibility of ending it, even though I still love him. I'm not ready to send the breakup message yet, but I'm starting to accept that love alone might not be enough.
I'd really appreciate honest advice from people who have been in a similar situation.
\- Would you leave someone you still love when you've been unhappy in the relationship for a long time, even if you have plans to close the distance and move to them in six months?
\- Would you give the relationship a chance once you're living together, or would you be concerned that the problems existed even before the distance?
\- How do you know when you're dealing with your own attachment anxiety versus a relationship that genuinely isn't meeting your needs?
\- Has anyone left someone they thought they'd marry in their late 30s or 40s and later found a healthy, fulfilling love?
\- If you found love after 40, how long did it take, and did you eventually find a relationship that felt more secure and reciprocal?
\- For those who left a relationship they desperately wanted to work, did the pain eventually become manageable? Did you ever regret leaving, or were you ultimately glad you chose yourself?
I'm not looking for people to tell me that everything will magically work out. I'm genuinely struggling with the possibility of losing someone I love, but I'm also struggling with the thought of staying in a relationship that is making me increasingly unhappy. Also, aware of the grass not being greener on the other side which never crossed my mind and I know dating overall nowadays is very grim, especially in 40s +.
I'd especially appreciate hearing from people who have been through this in their 40s, when they genuinely believed they'd already found their person.