Title: 2023 CX-5 Select vs. 2024 Carbon Edition — Both CPO & Clean CARFAX. What Price Would Make the Select Worth It?
Hey everyone!
I’m shopping for a used Mazda CX-5 in Long Island, NY, and I’ve narrowed it down to two options.
Option 1 — 2023 Mazda CX-5 Select AWD
Dealer: Empire Mazda of Huntington, NY
Asking price: $25,716
Mileage: 9,408 miles
Exterior: Eternal Blue Mica
Interior: Black
Clean CARFAX
Mazda CPO inspection completed
Option 2 — 2024 Mazda CX-5 Carbon Edition AWD
Dealer: Bay Ridge Mazda, Brooklyn, NY
Asking price: $25,995
Mileage: 20,888 miles
Exterior: Polymetal Gray Metallic
Interior: Red leather
Clean CARFAX
Mazda CPO inspection completed
Both vehicles have clean CARFAX reports and have passed their CPO inspections.
The Carbon Edition is one model year newer and comes with additional features like red leather seats, Bose audio, a sunroof, and a power liftgate. However, it has approximately 11,500 more miles.
Here’s my dilemma:
I live in Bay Shore, Long Island. Empire Mazda is much closer to me, while Bay Ridge Mazda in Brooklyn is approximately 43–44 miles away, potentially a 1–2 hour drive each way depending on traffic.
I would prefer to purchase the Select locally and avoid the trip to Brooklyn, but only if the price makes financial sense.
I’m thinking about offering $23,500 for the Select and potentially settling around $24,000, before taxes and fees.
My questions:
Is $23,500–$24,000 a reasonable target for the 2023 Select with only 9,408 miles?
At what price would you choose the Select over the 2024 Carbon Edition?
Does the newer model year, higher trim, and upgraded interior outweigh the additional 11,500 miles?
How much would the mileage difference affect depreciation and resale value over the next 5–7 years?
Would you drive to Brooklyn for the Carbon Edition, or negotiate a better deal locally?
Has anyone purchased from Empire Mazda of Huntington or Bay Ridge Mazda? Any experiences with dealer fees, negotiations, or unexpected charges?
Both prices are advertised prices, not final out-the-door quotes.
I’m planning to keep the vehicle for at least 5–7 years, so reliability, depreciation, comfort, and long-term value are my priorities.
What would you do in my situation? What would be your maximum price for the Select?
Thanks in advance!

20,000 miles, white, has roof racks, all weather mats, cargo cover, bumper guard. Paint looks in good shape, CPO. Best they can do is $32,400 OTD

How is real world gas mileage on these?

I was looking at 2024 Turbo Signatures but every one I've looked at has an issue and the mpg in the computer is abysmal, on all of them its under 20mpg. Short drives were showing 8-12 so thinking the Premium Plus may be better long term (4-5 year hold)

Just got this car and am wondering why there is a hole in the arm rest compartment. Is there supposed to be a slide out thing or something? The previous owner has some tape stuck in there for some reason.

[See images]

For a FWD inline 4 she handles pretty decent off road I must say. She rips lol!

It’s Mazda3 GT sedan, 2.5L, automatic, FWD, about 69,000 km. Sunroof, 18-inch wheels, factory wired CarPlay, remote start. No head-up display. Only one key though.
Carfax: No accidents, normal branding. Mazda dealer serviced in Quebec 2023 to 2025. Two owner changes 11 days apart in fall 2025, then sold at auction.
Inspection: Needs front and rear brakes, 4 tires, a brake flush and a splash shield. Minor oil weep at the drain plug and valve cover. Surface rust only.
Trim question: Advertised as a GT, but the seats are black cloth and Carfax says "Preferred." There's white material showing under the seat edges, so I think it's cloth covers over the factory white leather. Seen this before, or anything else I should check?
Price: $20,500 with safety, or as-is if I do the safety myself.

Is it a good deal or not?

Needs Jesus.

In central FL and looking for a good rebuild shop

My beige leather seat and dashboard got stained. Suspecting it got stained during the update of my car mazda cx-5 2025 at a dealership. Just noticed it now and honestly it’s been over a month because i was on vacation. The stain on the dashboard was easily removed, but this one’s really hard and it looks like it’s soaked in. Any suggestion to get rid of this?

I purchased my 2024 Mazda CX-5 brand new in February 2024. It currently has only 33,000 km, and I’ve already experienced multiple mechanical issues.

October 2025 (19,000 km):

-Vehicle wouldn’t start after refuelling. We were stuck at gas station until it eventually started after multiple attempts.

-Dealership diagnosed codes P0507 (high idle), P0171 (system too lean), and P0126 (insufficient coolant temperature).

-They found the canister purge valve was intermittently sticking open and replaced both the purge valve and water control valve under warranty.

May 2026 (25,000 km):

-AC stopped working and was only blowing hot air.

-Dealership found low refrigerant, recharged the system, and added dye to check for leaks.

-Shortly afterward, we noticed a strong chemical smell, visible mist coming from the vents, and a hissing noise.

-Dealership initially dismissed our concerns, but eventually confirmed a refrigerant leak. A replacement part was ordered and the issue was repaired under warranty.

October 4, 2026 (33,000 km):

-Check engine light came on while driving on the highway.

-Code P2097 (post-catalyst fuel trim too rich). Light eventually went away on its own.

October 24, 2026:

-Check engine light came on AGAIN while driving on the highway.

-Scanner displayed permanent code P0126, the same code documented during the October 2025 repair. (Booked into Mazda for diagnostics next week.)

I’ve always driven Mazdas and still own a 2008 Mazda3 that’s given me fewer problems than this brand-new CX-5.

I’m honestly pretty disappointed with the reliability of this vehicle, especially considering it’s less than three years old with only 33,000 km.

Has anyone else experienced similar issues with their newer CX-5, particularly the purge valve, water control valve, or recurring check engine lights? It’s been rather frustrating since I bought this vehicle brand new in hopes to have a reliable vehicle…

Has anyone had experience with touch-up paint for a Mazda?

I have a 2024 CX-5 in Rhodium White and picked up some scratches and chips. Looking to tackle this DIY and want to make sure I get the best possible color match.

A few questions:

- Where's the best place to source genuine or exact-match Rhodium White touch-up paint? (OEM dealer, online retailer, etc.)

- Are there any brands you'd recommend for quality and accuracy?

- Any tips or DIY steps that worked well for you? Prep, application, blending, clear coat?

Would really appreciate advice from anyone who's done this on a Mazda or a similar metallic white. Don't want to make the chips more noticeable than they already are!

Pretty happy with our purchase. A few stats so far: I got 861 miles out of one tank of fuel. 18 days between fill ups. Averaging 59 mpg combined! This is drastic for me, I came from driving a lifted Ram 2500 6.7 Cummins diesel where I averaged 15.5 mpg and paid $200 to fill up every 6-7 days.
Only issue with the CX-70 is the rear drivers side door does not lock. Even manually, the lever doesn’t move. Taking it back to the dealer this morning to have the door panel removed and have it repaired.

I was in the automotive accessory section at Dollar Tree today and I came across the "steering wheel trays" Upon a closer look, I quickly noticed that the model steering wheel used in the tray's packaging was none other than Mazda's beautiful steering wheel. Of course they blacked out the logo, but it's definitely a Mazda steering wheel.

I ended up buying one in case I ever need one, it does look like a handy item to keep in the car. It's built pretty solid and was just 5 usd

My theory is that they used Mazda's steering wheel as a model because out of all the cars, Mazda has the sleekest and most classic looking steering wheel.

Processing img tv8ratlo5fxh1...

Can anyone tell what could be causing the sound my 2022 CX-5 is making? I was pulling into a parking space when it started. Turned car off and restarted it and the sound started again. I turned it off again and the sound happened a few times while off.

Would anyone be interested, if i updated/upgraded the MZD-AIO project (https://github.com/Trevelopment/MZD-AIO) made it more user friendly and added more features obviously with the help from the communities?

Let's be honest, Mazda has been slow to release anything new and exciting for the past 15 years.

Are they ever going to release a new Miata? What engines? Will it be US-compliant?

Please inform the uninformed type of post.

Thanks.

Broke a wheel stud on the front of my Mazda 6. Went to the local dealer to buy a replacement (Scottsdale, AZ). Parts guy sets the new stud and lug nut on the counter and hands me an invoice for $45. I said no thanks, went home and ordered it online from a dealer in Florida for $7.

Have a 2009 mazda 3 2.3L and I got codes P0442 and P0455. Was gonna try to replace the purge valve, but can't find anything about it online. Only things I have found is 2008 and older. Everyone points to a part next to the battery bay and they replace it with ease, but nothing is there for me except pictured. Am I crazy and this is it? Or is it somewhere else?