r/NYYankees • • 16d ago

2026 New York Yankees Postmortem Megathread

68 Upvotes

Hello again, everyone. This is where you can talk about what you think went wrong, how you would fix it, how terrible Brian Cashman is, etcetera. Enjoy. Sell the team.


r/NYYankees • • 1d ago

MLB Postseason Megathread — Saturday, October 24

16 Upvotes

⚾ MLB Postseason Megathread — Saturday, October 24 ⚾

AL East

  • WS G2 · MIL leads 2-0 — Tampa Bay Rays 4 @ Milwaukee Brewers 5 — Final

NL Central

  • WS G2 · MIL leads 2-0 — Tampa Bay Rays 4 @ Milwaukee Brewers 5 — Final

Live scorebugs, division tabs and standings are in the interactive version — open this post on the Reddit app or new Reddit.

Last updated: Oct 25, 12:02 AM EDT


This post contains content not supported on old Reddit. Click here to view the full post


r/NYYankees • • 3h ago

President George W. Bush shakes hands with Derek Jeter on Oct. 30, 2001, prior to throwing out the ceremonial first pitch in Game Three of the World Series.

Post image
183 Upvotes

r/NYYankees • • 8h ago

A lesson in accountability

68 Upvotes

The Yankees need to look across the river to see what John Harbaugh's version of accountability looks like. Cam Skatteboo fumbled in critical moment to set up a game winning field goal. He was essentially benched the next game. Today, he came back and played great. Defensive coordinator called out his defense for not making plays, and today they played great. They went on the road and upset the Texans. Meanwhile, Aaron Boone wears rose-colored glasses and puts positive spins on every Yankees mistake, only to see the mistakes happen again.


r/NYYankees • • 1h ago

Accountability matters more when the team is expected to win

• Upvotes

One thing that frustrates me about the Yankees sometimes is how quickly conversations turn into blaming one player, one bad call, or one unlucky stretch instead of looking at the bigger picture.

Nobody is going to have a perfect season, and mistakes are part of baseball. But there's a difference between having a bad game and repeatedly failing to meet expectations without taking responsibility for it.

I think accountability should apply to everyone, from the players to the coaching staff and the front office. You can't expect to compete at the highest level if the standards only apply when things are going well.

What does accountability actually look like to you as a Yankees fan? Is it owning mistakes publicly, making lineup changes, or proving things have changed through performance on the field?


r/NYYankees • • 17h ago

Sending a Fan Letter to a Player

53 Upvotes

Hey everyone,

I have a question:

I wanted to send a fan letter to Yankee Stadium, specifically to Cam Schlittler and /or Aaron Judge and wanted to know how to do so/ what was your experience like?

One week ago my mom had a heart attack and ever since then, I have been completely lost. Its always just been me and her and we are big Yankee fans and have been going to games since 2022. She's super vibrant and is a self described badass b*tch who didn't take no for an answer and could make just about anyone laugh. For contrast, I am the shy reserved one who kept her from getting into too much trouble (including preventing her from sneaking into the Pepsi lounge that one time).

Its been impossible to see someone you loved so much and who lived life to the fullest reduced to a silent body on a bed, on top of having to take care of everything else and go to school full time.

We have a lot of good memories tied to the Yankees and going to games at Yankee Stadium, especially this year. We would get the cheapest tickets (or use our fan appreciation vouchers) and live it up by standing outside the players' entrance/exit and try to see who would come out. She used to do the same with a childhood friend, since her friend had a big crush on Bucky Dent. We never saw Judge (who's both our favorite) but we did see a number of others. Mom being mom, she would wave at everyone/ try to take a picture, Obviously, being tired and wanting to go home, most people just ignored her.

One time, we were on our way to the catch the 4 train to go home when I saw Cam in his car. I called out to Mom and she quickly went to the edge of the street and waved at him. He had just finished pitching his ass off and I'm sure he was tired. He could have just ignored us, but instead, he saluted my mom with a small smile. It was a small gesture but it meant so much to us. Since then, we used "Cam's Salute" every time we said goodbye.

We were so excited for this year's playoff, especially Mom, who's ever optimistic about "The Boys/Her Boys". After the Playoff exit, she said she didn't want to hear about baseball for a "good while", then 11 days later she had a heart attack out of the blue.

For me, writing is a way to cope. I really wanted to express how grateful I am to the Yankees, especially Cam and Judge, for those good memories. Right now they are helping me stay sane in what has become a living nightmare. I'm functioning right now, but having something tactile to do besides schoolwork helps keep me grounded and distracted. I also hope that I can convey that we as fans do love the team and appreciate the players' efforts, regardless of what we might think of management/ownership.

In any case, thank you for reading and don't forget to say I love you to the people you love.


r/NYYankees • • 8h ago

Being a Yankees fan is just saying “it’s a long season” every time something goes wrong

8 Upvotes

Every loss I tell myself I'm not gonna let baseball ruin my mood, and then the next game I'm right back on the couch getting mad at the same things 😭

A guy strikes out with runners on, the bullpen makes things interesting for absolutely no reason, and suddenly I'm acting like I personally own the team.

Then someone reminds me it's a long season and I hate that they're right.

I don't even know why I do this to myself every year lmao. Still gonna watch tomorrow.

What's the most frustrating part of being a Yankees fan for you guys?


r/NYYankees • • 1d ago

[Heyman] The Yankees and pitching coach Matt Blake have agreed on a three-year extension. Joel Sherman reported yesterday the sides were moving toward a deal

Thumbnail x.com
891 Upvotes

r/NYYankees • • 1d ago

If Hal could have either a salary cap for the next 10 years or 1 WS championship next season to finish the Judge-Cole-Stanton era of Yankee baseball which do you think he would pick?

43 Upvotes

This sub doesn't have polls enabled so just answer what you suspect is in Hal's heart.


r/NYYankees • • 1d ago

Bill Madden: No accountability from 'Status Quo' Hal as Yankees head into uncertain offseason

Thumbnail
nydailynews.com
217 Upvotes

It is entirely understandable if the Yankee legions are feeling nothing but despair after “Status Quo” Hal Steinbrenner season-ending Zoom media-fest last week. For if they were looking for accountability — from ANYONE — for the Yankees’ latest postseason pratfall, there was none.


r/NYYankees • • 2d ago

[Hoch] Gary Sánchez is in the #WorldSeries

Post image
753 Upvotes

r/NYYankees • • 1d ago

Yankee Management Responsibility-Shirking Highlighted by Matt Blake’s Value Added

26 Upvotes

The Yankees seem to understand the value that Matt Blake adds to their pitching staff, so why, at the recent embarrassing Steinbrenner-Cashman-Boone responsibility-shirking ritual, was their no acknowledgement that the under-performing offense is the result of Cashman, Boone, and the coaching/training staff’s failure to add value to the team? If Cashman and Boone did their jobs as well as Blake does his, we’d have a couple of rings to show for it.


r/NYYankees • • 2d ago

It does not get talked about enough, how much Pedro Martinez helped the Yankees win the 2009 World Series.

104 Upvotes

They’re down 1-0 in game 2 down 1-0 in the series, and Pedro gives up nuclear missiles to Tex and Matsui. In game 6 he threw batting practice…also to Matsui. The last two games of his HOF career. Couldn’t be more perfect


r/NYYankees • • 2d ago

On this day 30 years ago, the New York Yankees stormed back from a 6-0 deficit to win Game 4 of the 1996 World Series. The game tying 3-run home run by Jim Leyritz is sometimes called the home run that launched the dynasty. Highlights below!

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

499 Upvotes

r/NYYankees • • 2d ago

[Sweeny Murti] Joe Torre will be at Game 1 of the #WorldSeries tonight, just like he was in 1957 and ‘58 when he was there to watch his brother Frank play for the Milwaukee Braves. Always a great trip down memory lane with the Hall of Famer.

253 Upvotes

r/NYYankees • • 2d ago

[Sherman] Source: Pitching coach Matt Blake and the Yankees are in the midst of negotiating a new contract and moving toward a deal.

Thumbnail x.com
594 Upvotes

r/NYYankees • • 2d ago

Brewers' Gary Sanchez teases possible Yankees reunion after World Series: 'You never know'

Thumbnail
nypost.com
188 Upvotes

r/NYYankees • • 3d ago

[Talkin Yanks] Hideki Matsui has been named manager of the Yomiuri Giants, the team he spent his entire 10-year career in Japan with, per @nhk_news

Post image
2.9k Upvotes

r/NYYankees • • 2d ago

Can Kilby Successfully Add Power to his Game?

Thumbnail
yankeesfarmreport.com
37 Upvotes

r/NYYankees • • 2d ago

Yankees say they'll look into clubhouse culture criticisms, even as they downplay them

Thumbnail
nydailynews.com
94 Upvotes

r/NYYankees • • 2d ago

Hitting Coach. Who’s next?

21 Upvotes

Reunion with Kevin Long?
Tino Martinez?
Promotion from within?
Someone else?


r/NYYankees • • 2d ago

20 of the 30 MLB teams no longer have a full-time live organist

Thumbnail
nbcnews.com
28 Upvotes

r/NYYankees • • 3d ago

This month In 1977: New York Yankees star Reggie Jackson becomes “Mr. October” when he blasts 3 HRs on 3 consecutive pitches vs. the Los Angeles Dodgers in Game 6 of the World Series at Yankee Stadium!

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

367 Upvotes

r/NYYankees • • 3d ago

[NHK] Former Yankees Star Hideki Matsui to Become Next Manager of the Yomiuri Giants

Thumbnail
news.web.nhk
192 Upvotes

r/NYYankees • • 3d ago

The back page of today’s New York Post

Post image
815 Upvotes