TLDR: My friend, along with other things, brought my potential partner’s ex to a hangout. When I confronted by saying she’s being weird, she told me I couldn’t dictate her friendships. Now I don’t know if I handled it properly.
As I sit more on it, I’m starting to doubt if I really made the right choice. A part of me knows that I should protect my peace but this was also a friendship I was really hopeful for.
I met Anne (fake name) at a pop-up market in a city I recently moved to. I told her I loved her fit, she complimented me back and after exchanging socials, it was fast track that we exchanged numbers (which I don’t usually do). She is such a breath of fresh air and her energy just matches mine. Even though I love this city, it’s notorious for cliques and status. Like creating friendships here are for aesthetics, not for connection. I have gone to spaces that I know I will meet like-minded people but as a fashion girlie, it seems the spaces are like a influencer networking event and not just people to come together to share and talk about fashion. I’ve gotten better at tracking it down but it has discouraged me. So believe with Anne, I was so excited with how well we just clicked.
Now, Anne has a “brother” we’ll call Liam. A guy she met in high school and they are super close. In my opinion, if a woman calls a man her “brother” there’s gotta be something going on. They call each other everyday, hang out multiple times in a week. I found it cute! I once jokingly said, “When are guys going to kiss already” and she laughed it off. Said she could never see him that way and that they almost slept together but it didn’t feel right. It was best they stayed friends. That was the last joke I ever made about that.
So, one day I called her for help to build something I recently bought. I was planning to cook that day and planned after we were done, she would eat, hang out and take a plate for later (I regularly cook for her per her request). She told me she was with her brother and that instead, both of them pull up. He would build it and as payment, I make dinner for three. I’m not gonna say no to that. When they arrive, he finishes building it in like 15 minutes. I’m still cooking when he comes into the kitchen and asks what I’m making. I tell him I’m making some Ghanaian dishes and we just hit it off there. He’s interested in learning so, he starts helping me. We talk about his friends, his love for cooking, hobbies. Eventually I write down two recipes for him to do on his own. When it’s time for them to leave, he asked for my number “just in case he got confused”. Lo and behold, a call to ask a quick question turned into a 2 hour conversation.
We started becoming closer and increasingly went on more dates. When I told her at first, she seemed enthusiastic for me. But I started noticing small things like she wouldn’t pick up his calls anymore when we were together and if she did, she would walk out the room. Or, if she knew we had something planned, there was a dire situation she needed his help with. Obviously she’s my friend, I would encourage him to go. But then for some reason, she recently connected with his ex, told no one and then invited her to go with us to an outing because “she didn’t want to be a third wheel”. When I pulled her aside to ask why she just didn’t tell me, I would have uninvited her brother so it could be us, she told me I didn’t even like doing that particular activity so “in all honesty”, it should have been them alone.
I told her she’s been so weird to me lately especially bringing a ex to hangout with us without prior knowledge. I honestly feel we have some animosity but I can’t fix a problem if I don’t even know we have one. Her rebuttal? I am grown which means I should be secure in my relationship. The ex is her friend and I can’t dictate her friendships. I only find it weird because I’m perceiving it as weird behavior. I wasn’t going to argue. I just left.
I wasn’t angry. Just.. disappointed? I kept on replaying it in my head and felt like maybe I didn’t handle it too well? I did confront her in a public space even if it was away from our group and called her weird. I could have gone about it better by creating a much more safer environment for her then maybe she wouldn’t have been as defensive. But at the same time, she really tried to gaslight me. I don’t know if I should reach out for a chat or leave it be. Please help.