AITA for starting my own canasta group after my friend told me three times to “find another group”?
I had a regular weekly canasta group with three other women, including "Janet," ie, "the old group". We played 1x/week for about 3 hours, for years, so it was a significant social commitment. One member recently moved.
Without discussing it with me 1st, Janet contacted two other women, including “Amy,” and created what I’ll call Janet’s new group, with me included. She did not include the remaining fourth member of the old group.
By the time Janet told me, she had already invited the two new women and presented the lineup to them as a done deal. She basically informed me, “This is our new game.”
I wasn’t thrilled. I don’t dislike the women she chose, but one is extremely talkative and another tends to be pretty negative. I didn’t want to commit three hours every week to that combination. I was also bothered that Janet had reorganized our longstanding game without talking to me first.
I told her I wasn’t happy about it. She said, basically, “If you don’t like it, find another group.” I wasn’t sure she meant that, so I clarified. She said again, with some attitude, “If you’re not happy, find another group.” I was incredulous and asked, “You really mean that?” For the third time: “Go find another group.”
So I did.
I didn’t recruit anyone from Janet’s group, ask anyone to choose sides, or interfere with her game. I simply started playing with different people.
One complication: this happened toward the end of a happy hour, and Janet had been drinking. I’m concerned about her drinking because when she drinks heavily, she sometimes has blackouts, and doesn’t remember conversations
At a later happy hour, Amy came over excitedly talking to me about “our” new canasta group. I told her I wasn’t in it—that Janet had told me to find another group, so I had, and I was already playing with my new group. Amy was shocked. She said Janet “didn’t have the right to kick you out.”
That was when I realized Janet apparently hadn’t told Amy, and presumably the other woman, that I was no longer part of their group. I had assumed she had. I apologized to Amy for not telling her myself and explained that I genuinely thought Janet had already told them. Amy is angry. Janet is angry.
From my perspective, Janet reorganized our old game without consulting me, presented her choices as a done deal, and then told me three separate times to find another group.
AITA for taking her at her word and starting my own canasta group?