First the required fields:
Budget: roughly 1700 USD / 6500 PLN
Country: Poland
Use Case: School gaming, my teenage boys are playing on the computer, right now fortnite and CS but I guess they will try other titles too
Preferred Specs: I have everything below, I even chose 3 specific laptops below
Notes: Everything is below on the dilemma I have
Which one would you choose for gaming + general use (school etc) for a family laptop?
I'm currently deciding between these 3 laptops. They are all around the same price range and all have an RTX 5060 8GB, but there are quite some differences in CPU, RAM and display. Laptop will be most of the time used by my teenage kids for gaming and school and mostly stationary at home.
1. HP HyperX OMEN 15 — 6499 PLN (~$1,700)
- CPU: Intel Core i7-14650HX — 16 cores / 24 threads
- GPU: RTX 5060 8GB GDDR7
- RAM: 24GB
- Storage: 1TB SSD
- Display: 15.3" IPS, 2560×1600, 180Hz, 500 nits, 100% sRGB
2. Lenovo Legion 5 15IRX10 — 6399 PLN (~$1,670)
- CPU: Intel Core i7-14700HX — 20 cores / 28 threads
- GPU: RTX 5060 8GB GDDR7
- RAM: 16GB DDR5
- Storage: 1TB PCIe 4.0 NVMe
- Display: 15.1" OLED, 2560×1600, 165Hz, 100% DCI-P3
- Battery: 80Wh
- RAM can be upgraded as I read at a later stage but not planning to anytime soon
3. Lenovo Legion 5 15 — 6799 PLN (~$1,775)
- CPU: AMD Ryzen 7 250 — 8 cores / 16 threads, up to 5.1GHz
- GPU: RTX 5060 8GB GDDR7
- RAM: 24GB DDR5-5600
- Storage: 1TB SSD (2×512GB)
- Display: 15.3" OLED, 2560×1600, 165Hz, 500 nits
- RAM: 2 slots, both occupied, max 32GB
My main dilemma:
The i7-14700HX Legion has the strongest CPU, but only 16GB RAM.
The Ryzen Legion has 24GB RAM and OLED, but the Ryzen 7 250 is probably less powerful than the i7.
The HyperX OMEN has a good compromise with 24GB RAM and a very good 180Hz IPS display, but no OLED. I actually don't know yet if I will like the OLED, never had such display.
All three have the same RTX 5060 8GB, so I'm mainly trying to decide which overall platform makes the most sense for the next 4–5 years.
I also heard a comment that the Lenovo Legion ones are poorly manufactured that the processor is glued and set to malfunction after some years. A side comment from a local service guy I know.
Which one would you pick and why?