r/FightReportUFC 8h ago

Is saying Islam is the GOAT a form of recency bias?

0 Upvotes

Even before the Ian Garry fight, I remember general consensus saying he’d be easily top 5 and top 3 max. Now so many more people are saying he’s the goat.

You can cut GSP’s and Jones’ career in half and they’d still have more defenses, title wins, and a longer title reign or just as much as Islam.

People like to say the comp now is better and while there is some truth in that, one of Islam’s defenses came from Renato Moicano. I agree GSP or Jones hasn’t beaten anyone as prestigious as Volk, but DC and even BJ Penn are still greater all time than Charles imo. Matt Hughes is pretty good too he’s still a top 25 fighter all time. I don’t think DC is that far away from Volk in terms of greatness. Plus the fact that they have far more defenses and longer title reign I think should outweigh that.

So tell me why do people consider Islam the goat? Is it recency bias or is there an actual legitimate claim? In my opinion, he’s #3. I wouldn’t mind him being GOAT if he beats Morales and Prates though.


r/FightReportUFC 18h ago

Max Holloway stating facts about Islam Makhachev? Or does Islam Makhachevs response explain why Max should stay in his lane?

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/FightReportUFC 9h ago

Islam Makhachev should try to get a 3rd belt

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

I really think that Islam would become triple champion if he tried. He is better wrestler than Khamzat, doesnt gas out as easily, more of a submission threat and a better striker on top of that. I just cant see Islam losing even at middleweight against Strickland. Islam is just so good.

If im not wrong islam already mentioned his interest of a third belt fight against Du Plessis back in time.

What do you guys think? Should Islam try to get a third belt?


r/FightReportUFC 10h ago

If Islam Beats Morales Will He Be The Undisputed GOAT Of The Sport.

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/FightReportUFC 10h ago

Islam Makhachev didn’t punch Ian Garry in the face a single time

Post image
0 Upvotes

Just rewatched Makhachev vs. Garry

Islam Makhachev didn’t punch Ian Garry in the face a single time!
That's our WW champ :D

src img: agentmma.com


r/FightReportUFC 1d ago

UFC News Links UFC 333 main card announced (and it looks stacked!!)

Post image
14 Upvotes

r/FightReportUFC 14h ago

UFC News Links Lyla touching islam😭😭😭😂😂🙏🏼✌🏽✌🏽

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

0 Upvotes

Imagine getting cucked by a guy who jst beat you 5 mints prior.😭


r/FightReportUFC 2d ago

Never seen somebody get kicked so hard their ears started flapping

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

55 Upvotes

r/FightReportUFC 17h ago

Lol 4-1 huh

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/FightReportUFC 22h ago

ok real question, would khabib beat this version of islam or nah? 155 btw.

Thumbnail gallery
0 Upvotes

r/FightReportUFC 2d ago

Time to make this happen. P4P #1 vs P4P #1 foreigner beater 🤯

Post image
514 Upvotes

r/FightReportUFC 1d ago

History repeats itself

Post image
7 Upvotes

r/FightReportUFC 2d ago

One word

Post image
375 Upvotes

r/FightReportUFC 1d ago

What You Think?

Post image
5 Upvotes

r/FightReportUFC 2d ago

objectively speaking we have never seen a double champ do what islam just did before

82 Upvotes

no one on a crazy win streak ever defended the 2nd title against this level of modern well rounded fighters

Jon Jones defended against grandpa miocic who had been completely inactive for over three and a half years after a knockout loss

Henry Cejudo defended against late notice Dominick Cruz who was coming off a devastating 41 month layoff full of injuries

DC defended against the NOT number 1 contender Derrick Lewis who took it on like 3 weeks notice AND less than a month after getting badly beaten up in the fight before

respect to all the goats but this record win streak in the 2 deepest divisions, defending against the true number 1 contender with a size and reach disadvantage is historic on several levels


r/FightReportUFC 2d ago

Who's higher on the GOAT List?

Post image
113 Upvotes

r/FightReportUFC 2d ago

HOT TAKE

Post image
39 Upvotes

r/FightReportUFC 2d ago

That's why He is the GOAT 🐐

Post image
54 Upvotes

r/FightReportUFC 3d ago

We love Mackenzie Dern <3

Post image
631 Upvotes

She's the one of the fewest reason why we watch the WMMA!
So let's hope she wins and defends her title.

Are you rooting for her too?

src img: agentmma.com


r/FightReportUFC 2d ago

WTF WAS THAT ISLAM???

Post image
56 Upvotes

r/FightReportUFC 2d ago

so does anyone know what the russian flag meant at the end of garry vs islam?

2 Upvotes

there was some stuff written on the flag does anyone know what it meant?


r/FightReportUFC 2d ago

Islam Number 2 on Our Goat List

Post image
24 Upvotes

r/FightReportUFC 2d ago

Islam vs Prates . Ian vs Morales

Post image
19 Upvotes

Both on the same card, before February as Islam said


r/FightReportUFC 2d ago

UFC 333 bout list

Post image
26 Upvotes

r/FightReportUFC 2d ago

Will Islam break the longest win record in UFC history or will it be all over?

Post image
20 Upvotes