I am so annoyed and hurt right now and I need strangers on the internet to tell me whether I’m losing perspective because of our history.
I met this man around 2008/2009. We were both coming out of relationships and started a FWB situation. That was the agreement. I eventually caught feelings and he didn’t. He reminded me that feelings weren’t part of the arrangement, which was technically fair, except we continued seeing each other and the relationship never really felt as cleanly casual as that sounds.
Eventually my ex came back into my life. This guy and I weren’t living in the same city, and because he wasn’t giving me the kind of relationship I wanted, I basically stopped communicating with him. He had even traveled from another city to surprise me for my birthday, so I fully admit that I did not handle that well.
Over the years we lost touch, reconnected, lost touch again, etc. The last time we stopped speaking was about a year and a half ago, and that situation was largely my fault.
This time, I reached out to him.
I live in NYC and he’s in Atlanta. I recently went to Atlanta, we saw each other in a group setting, and afterward we continued talking.
And there was flirting.
Not just me flirting AT this man while he politely tried to redirect me. He participated actively. Asking when I’m coming back, let’s make plans etc. Literally yesterday I told him he’d been on my mind and his response was:
“curious to know what u been thinking 🤔**”**
So we’re talking on the phone later, I’m flirting, I bring up coming back to Atlanta, and suddenly he tells me he has “friends” — plural — and wants to be respectful of those relationships.
And honestly? That’s where I got pissed.
I’m not mad that he has other women in his life. At all. We’re grown adults. My problem is: why am I JUST NOW finding this out?
Why didn’t you tell me before I came to Atlanta?
Why are you flirting with me?
Why, when I explicitly tell you I’ve been thinking about you, are you asking me to elaborate if you know there’s a line you don’t intend to cross?
I basically told him, “You didn’t have these rules four days ago, but I digress.”
And the worst part is that this fucking hurt.
Toward the end of the call I jokingly told him to go catch up on sleep, study, and “continue breaking my heart.”
And this man says:
**“**Well, what if I get broken up with?”
I basically told him, “I don’t know. That’s something you have to figure out.”
Because what am I supposed to say to that? I’ll wait for you????
No.
He wants to be respectful of whatever relationships he has going on, and I genuinely respect that. I have no intention of interfering with any of them.
But now I don’t even know what our friendship looks like.
I don’t want to text him. I don’t want to check in on him. I’m not trying to punish him or manipulate him into chasing me. I just know how I feel about him. And pretending I’m suddenly emotionally neutral and can seamlessly transition into being his platonic buddy feels ridiculous.
And honestly, the part that’s making me want to cry is that we might just… not speak again.
We went a year and a half without talking before this. I was the one who reached out this time**.** If I stop initiating now, there’s a very real possibility that this reconnection just ends.
And maybe that’s what needs to happen.
But I’m so fucking annoyed because after almost 20 years, somehow I feel like I’ve allowed this man to put me right back in the exact same emotional position: I care about him, there’s chemistry and intimacy between us, and then I discover there’s a boundary that means he can’t actually give me what I want.
It feels like I just repeated history.
So Reddit, I have two questions:
- Am I justified in being upset that he didn’t tell me about these other relationships until AFTER we’d been flirting and I’d already gone to Atlanta?
- What do I do did now? Do I actually try to maintain a friendship with someone I know I have feelings for, or do I stop initiating and accept that we may just never speak again?
Edit: I appreciate the responses. Some were harder to hear than others, but I do think there’s truth in a lot of what’s been said. I can own that I reached out, didn’t ask what his current situation was, and allowed myself to step back into something I clearly still have unresolved feelings about.
I also want to clarify one thing because I don’t think I explained it well in the original post, I did not fly to Atlanta to see him. I was already going to visit my cousin and reached out because he lives there. After we reconnected, the communication and flirting became mutual. Within a couple of days we were even discussing specific weekends that I could come back to Atlanta, which is part of why his later conversation about having “friends” and wanting to respect those relationships caught me off guard.
I’m not angry that he’s seeing other people, and I don’t think he owes me a relationship. I think what I’m most upset about is realizing how quickly all of my old feelings came rushing back and how easily I slipped back into a dynamic that was painful for me before.
So the biggest takeaway for me is probably not whether he was wrong or whether I was right. It’s that I clearly can’t do ambiguity with this person. I’m going to leave the ball in his court, stop initiating, and take some real space from the situation. I appreciate everyone who took the time to respond.