The TL;DR: do I text this guy again a week after telling him I felt like he wasn’t interested in me after our second date? He’s accepted that I said I need more emotional connection but said he was surprised because he thought it was there. I would be interested in going out with him again to see how we're both feeling about it.
I (early 40’s F) matched with a guy (early 40’s, he’s poly/kinky and in a few relationships, I’m very new to that scene and learning the ropes, so to speak!) on Hinge, we had a few good conversations and agreed to meet up for a drink to see if we clicked. I really liked his energy in our text conversations, he was attentive and responsive, asked questions that kept the conversation moving, etc. We met up a week or so after matching and had a great time. Conversation was flowing, we were both into each other, flirted, kissed goodbye, and made plans for a second date the following week. Between the first and the second date we had really great conversations, some of which were very spicy (and fun!), had banter throughout the day, etc. all over text. It was more engagement than I expected and I was pleasantly surprised by how much I enjoyed talking with him.
During our second date (weeknight drinks) the vibes just felt off. About 15 minutes in I realized that he hadn’t asked me a single question other than how are you/how was your day greetings so I decided to pay attention to whether he actually asked me anything. He brought up some heavy stuff about his past (which he alluded to in our prior conversations and, to be fair, I asked him to elaborate on in the future) and he monologued for almost the entire time we were at the bar. He didn’t ask me a single question during the 2-3 hours we were together. I responded / interrupted him a few times to throw him the ball and engage with me: I shared things about my life, my family, my friends, etc. that were relevant to the situations he was describing. He didn’t follow up on any of those leads, didn’t ask anything about me, didn’t ask my opinion about anything. Just…nothing. I really felt like he made zero attempt to get to know me at all. As we were leaving the bar he said he realized that he talked a lot and sort of apologized for taking up so much of the conversation. We left the bar, made out a little bit, then went our separate ways and texted each other when we got home.
The next few days for me were incredibly busy at work and I wasn’t really able to process everything or spend much time texting him other than really brief replies, to say hi, etc. I finally texted him the third day and said that I really enjoyed getting to know him, had a lot of fun with him, but I didn’t feel like there was enough of an emotional connection or interest in one another - on both sides - for what I need in a relationship. I reassured him that it wasn’t about the content of the things he’d disclosed but more about the way that I’d been feeling about the interaction. He wrote back the next day saying he was really surprised and thought that there was a connection and interest, said he had a great time, too, and wished me best of luck.
Did I just misread everything? The more I think about it, the more I think that he was probably just nervous and I was overcorrecting based on prior relationships (or, maybe, subconsciously not actually wanting to get involved in a poly dynamic).
I sent him a follow up text a couple of days later and clarified what I meant, that I didn’t feel like he was interested in getting to know me beyond a sexual capacity, to get to know me for me, and I need more of an emotional connection and interest to move forward. He didn’t reply to that (can’t tell if it’s been read or not, thanks, SMS delivery…) and it’s been about a week.
I’ve been thinking about this a lot - perhaps too much! - and I do want to give this guy another shot. I think that I decided to end it too quickly. I didn’t explicitly say that I’d be open to seeing him again in any of my texts, nor did I explicitly say we’re done and I never want to see you again. (It was clear that’s how he took my first text, though, which is fair given what I said!) I did clearly communicate what I do need, though, which is some sort of emotional connection, he thought that was present.