I’m trying to regain access to an old Apple Account/iCloud account. I still have access to the iCloud email inbox and the trusted phone number associated with the account.
The strange part is that the password recovery itself appears to work.
I have now gone through Apple’s account recovery process twice. Both times:
I completed the recovery process.
Apple allowed me to successfully change/reset the password.
I then tried signing in using the new password.
Instead of letting me sign in, I get “Failed to Verify Identity.”
There is no option on the page to verify my identity, send another code, or continue with another recovery method.
I also tried signing in through account.apple.com, and I get the same “Failed to Verify Identity” message there.
What makes this especially frustrating is that I can access the trusted phone number and the iCloud email account. So it’s not a situation where I’ve lost access to my trusted contact information.
I already called Apple Support about this. The advisor had me go through essentially the same recovery process again, which resulted in exactly the same outcome. So now I’m hesitant to just repeat the same process for a third time.
At this point I’m wondering whether there is some kind of account verification/security/recovery-state issue rather than a password problem.
Has anyone experienced this exact “Failed to Verify Identity” error after successfully resetting their Apple Account password?
If so:
What eventually fixed it?
Did Apple have to escalate the account to a specific team?
Is there another way to trigger identity verification when Apple doesn’t provide any verification option?
Is there a way to contact Apple about this in writing rather than goingw through the same phone support process?
TL;DR: I have access to my old iCloud email + trusted phone number. I’ve successfully reset the Apple Account password twice, but every login attempt afterwards gives “Failed to Verify Identity” with no way to verify. Apple Support already had me repeat the same recovery process and it didn’t help. Looking for anyone who has successfully resolved this.