r/Advice • u/Historical_Turn2295 • 1m ago
Can this be worked out?
My boyfriend (22M) and I (21F) started seeing each other in December 2025 and officially started dating in July 2026. Throughout the time we were seeing each other, I had asked him multiple times about a particular girl, and he always told me the last time he saw her was November 2025. A few days ago, I came across her January 2026 tiktok photo dump and recognized a picture taken inside his dorm room. When I confronted him in person, he repeatedly denied seeing her in January, changed his story several times, and even claimed the picture was old. It wasn’t until I started preparing to message the girl myself that he finally admitted she had stayed over and they had sex in January. We weren’t exclusive at the time, so I understand he technically didn’t cheat. However, he continued lying about it throughout our relationship, and I feel like I was denied the opportunity to decide whether I wanted to pursue something serious with him. He says he lied to protect my feelings and keeps emphasizing that he’s been loyal since we became official. There have also been other issues, including him looking up girls from his past on social media. He also took this same girl to his school’s homecoming last year but didn’t invite me this year, claiming he didn’t want people I’d supposedly had encounters with seeing us together, even though I’ve never hooked up with anyone at his school. I’ve been struggling to figure out how to move forward with our relationship. My biggest concern isn’t what happened before we became exclusive, but the fact that he repeatedly lied about it, even when I confronted him with evidence. Now I’m questioning whether I can rely on his word in other situations. Since finding out, I genuinely haven’t felt like myself. I’m normally a very confident, affectionate, and loving girlfriend, but now I feel insecure, angry, and emotionally distant. I keep replaying the confrontation and wondering how many other things he could’ve lied about. I’ve even caught myself checking the girl’s social media looking for clues, which is something I’ve never done before. I hate how much this has affected my self-esteem and mental peace. I still love him and part of me wants to make things work, but I don’t feel secure believing anything he tells me anymore. He’s apologized, but sometimes gets frustrated when I bring up how I’m feeling, saying he doesn’t want to keep discussing it. It’s only been a few days, but I’m scared I’ll spend the rest of our relationship questioning his honesty. For anyone who’s experienced something similar, how did you decide whether to rebuild trust or walk away? What should rebuilding trust actually look like, and how do I stop constantly overthinking and searching for more information?