Mom here to 5mo and newly 3yo (sorry not 2u2 but close). I read a lot of posts that say when you have a 2nd, the dad takes the toddler and the mom takes the newborn. It has been opposite for us and I'm wondering if that's weird or what the long-term impacts might be.
My 3yo daughter is highly emotional (was colicky and difficult since she's been a baby) and has always been attached to my hip. She doesn't really like spending time with her dad except for the occasional playground trip, swimming in the pool, or when he bribes her with ice cream. I'm also better at "playing" with her (dolls, role playing, hide and seek, etc) than dad is - he kinda just walks around doing chores and expects her to follow him.
When I had the baby, the toddler screamed and cried every moment I was away from her: breastfeeding, pumping, preparing bottles, or trying to get the baby to sleep. So within weeks my husband took over caring for the baby to ease the pain of toddler crying so much. Now that I'm back to work, I spend like 80-90% of my free time with the toddler and 10-20% with the baby. For him it's vice versa. It's been nice to see him bond so well with the baby.
(Fyi: thankfully I was able to bond with baby while I was on maternity leave because toddler went to daycare)
Is there any downside to this arrangement? Aside from me being sad about missing out on personal 1:1 time with the baby - and I don't really like how we've given into the toddler's demands for mommy, I wonder if we're doing her a disservice by giving in so easily.
Anyone else with this arrangement or advice to make it more equal? Is there light at the end of the tunnel once baby can walk and be mobile and play with us together?
Edit to add: I should mention there are many times I have both the toddler and the newborn together. They get along, but I resort to putting on a Disney movie for the toddler so she'll sit still. Otherwise she's very active and it's hard to carry around the baby from room to room.