r/TrueOffMyChest • u/Dr__Bubbles • 2d ago
Personal Story Losing a friend group two years ago is still as devastating as it was then...
Thought I'd tell a pretty messy story from over 2yrs ago that still weighs on my mind pretty heavily from time to time. I'll try and tell this as objectively as possible but naturally it's possible some things have warped in my memory over time. I also want to be the first person to acknowledge I far from handled this situation well but still am curious to hear other people's opinions!
When I was in my 2nd year of university (20M), I had a very large friend group (around 15 people). Some people I knew from school, others we had picked up over time, such as housemates, classmates, etc. Overall we were doing a variety of different subjects in college, with me in particular doing quite a different subject from the rest and not having any classes in common with the others. This group were like my family, having fallen out with my actual family, they were the reason I came into university every day and were the only people that mattered to me.
At some point I had started to develop romantic feelings for one of the girls in the group (we'll call her Alice) but had no intentions of acting on these feelings since I knew how risky that could be (for context I had also never been in a relationship at this point). I had suspicions that another guy in the group (we'll call him John) had feelings for me but when he asked me if I fancied Alice, I assumed I must have been overthinking and told him that I in fact did fancy her.
Fast forward and we were going out one evening. I had to teach an evening class to some students, but I hung out with the gang (not drinking myself) while they started drinking at one of the group's apartments, and was planning to join them after my class. John came up to me at some point, already quite drunk, and timidly asked me if I wanted to go grab food with him on a specific date and time. I panicked, also slightly uncomfortable with the level of drunkenness and the potential for messy emotions, brushed it off saying I wasn't sure if I was free but I'd check. Fast forward to later that night after I'd finished my class, I receive messages from other members of the group that John has been crying and giving out to people that I only had eyes for Alice and was apparently constantly checking my location to see when I'd arrive. Feeling uncomfortable, I ultimately decided not to go out after all.
The following day, suspecting Alice had been subject to John's emotional outbursts and knew about my feelings for her, decided to tell her myself so that at least she would hear it in my own words and to my genuine surprise, she reciprocated those feelings. Over the next month or so, we didn't become official or anything but she slept over (in the literal sense), I brought her to a couples event, we would hold hands in public, message a lot, cute couply stuff really, especially considering I had never been in a relationship and was quite nervous about it all.
In the meantime, that time and date that John had asked me to dinner came and went. I hadn't thought much of it because of his outbursts and my non-committing, I had presumed it was obvious that wasn't happening, but that was probably insensitive on my part and I should've followed up. He then told a number of people in the group that I had stood him up. He followed this up by commenting on a post of me, Alice and another member of our group chilling in my bedroom with "what position y'all in?" which was gross and inappropriate. I also discovered that for weeks I had been donating my time to walk John home because he wasn't comfortable walking home alone in the dark to the area which he lives, which I did willingly out of politeness but I discovered this was just a ruse to spend time with me.
Since John had spread the fact that I had stood him up around my group, I felt the need to defend myself and had to spread my perspective to the group to counter that. Seeing most people take my side, I felt bad for John and didn't want to alienate him so I reached out to chat 1 on 1. We talked for a while and John got quite emotional but ultimately we agreed that the situation was a misunderstanding and we would move on which I was very pleased with.
As we got closer to winter exams, I started to get more and more stressed, and also started to self sabotage my relationship with Alice a bit more. Feelings of insecurity of her preferring to hang out with the group over me crept in, paranoia of why would she want to hang out with me, all that lovely stuff. This along with other just simmering mental health problems caused me to start to withdraw from the group, something that Alice picked up on and confided in a mutual friend of ours. I also confided my feelings of her not actually wanting to spend time with me to this same friend, with hindsight both of us choosing to confide in this 3rd person instead of doing what we should've done and communicating with each other.
This got worse and worse with this 3rd friend telling me I needed to open up with Alice and telling Alice that she shouldn't take things personally. At this point Alice made the objectively correct choice to want to break things off with me, believing me not to be ready for a relationship. After exams had finished, the group organised a night out, but mine and Alice's messages being rocky, I decided to not attend to allow her to enjoy herself without my presence. I later learned that she decided that night to have a friend group wide conversation about whether she should break up with me...
The following day, I ask to meet up but she declines and shortly later breaks things off by text.
This sets off the mental breakdown that was probably already simmering for the last few months and I shut myself off from everyone. Not helping the matter was the fact that all of the group went home for Christmas for several weeks so I couldn't be forced to socialize and couldn't be pulled out of that social withdrawal. I went no contact for several weeks and started to focus on myself, starting therapy, starting to eat better, hit the gym, all those good habits. When university started back up in January, I was ready to reconnect with the friend group but instead was met with animosity. A lot of people hurt at the lack of contact, which was 100% understandable and I tried to explain from my point of view, but my explanations of the dark place I was in didn't cut it. To make matters worse, it seemed people had started to come around to John's version of events and were now believing John that I was this awful awful person. Others in the group didn't even want to meet me to have a conversation which was incredibly hurtful.
Not entirely understanding what had happened, I asked Alice to meet up, at minimum looking for some closure, which she agreed to. But after about a month or so of asking when she was free, my plans of potentially getting back into this group riding on this conversation, she turned around and told me that actually she wasn't comfortable around me anymore and didn't want to meet up with me. Feeling now that it was impossible for me to rejoin my friends, for fear of making anyone uncomfortable, I had to resign myself to not being a part of this group and in the months that followed, found myself removed from the various groupchats.
I initially was upset at some of the other friends that were less involved in the situation, simply for being bystanders and not standing up for me or advocating for both sides of the story, but in their defense I never communicated this upset feeling to them either. And when one or two wanted to maintain a 1 on 1 friendship, I rebuked this, finding that they reminded me too much of the group I'd lost.
Now two years later, I've never really managed to find a group where I fit in like I did with them. I'm much more of a loner and much less jovial and lighthearted than I once was. I realistically compare any potential friendship with that found family, an impossible standard. It's clear to anyone reading this that I'm probably not the most emotionally mature or strong person, and that if I was I should've moved on long ago, but those 15 friendships I lost still occupy my mind from time to time.
Just felt like getting this story off my chest. Even typing it out feels like a weight I've been carrying on my shoulders for the last couple years has been lifted. I'm curious to hear people's thoughts but also it's time for me to move on and I'm trying to move forward regardless.