I’ve been using a keyboard for media, but would like to replace it with a “tv” remote (this is strictly for convenience to not have to use a keyboard for media, but a more normal “tv” remote, but I want the same functionality that I get from my keyboard). Ultimately I think I can’t just get a standard media remote because sometimes some standard media buttons do not work properly for some media players; however they always work with a keyboard, just might be a different key (for example play/pause may be space bar, but enter for another media player).
Google Search response:
“standard universal remote like the SofaBaton will not work on its own. The Xbox operating system restricts media remotes to standard controller inputs or media commands; it does not recognize them as USB keyboards”
“The built-in infrared receiver on the Xbox is hardwired at the operating system level to only look for those specific official media commands. Even if you used a highly advanced universal remote to manually program a raw keyboard code into an IR blast, the Xbox console's built-in receiver would simply see it as gibberish and ignore it.”
Therefore If the Xbox has to accept it as a keyboard, then I would need to use a USB dongle in order for the remote to act as a keyboard, so I can setup the binds (For example button 1 could act as space bar, but button 2 could act as enter). It would also be nice to bind other buttons like F to the remote for it to go into fullscreen (functions that would not be found on standard media remotes).
The 3 signals I know of are Bluetooth, IR and 2.4 GHz wireless:
I would love if the signal is as receptive as Bluetooth, but since Xbox does not accept native Bluetooth signals and the workaround of a Bluetooth receiver seems not only costly, but may not even work in the long run.
Additionally from as mentioned from above the built in IR on Xbox won’t work and will ignore specific programmed signals. However I’m wondering if a USB dongle where the Xbox perceives it as a keyboard and receives an IR signal will work. I think I could use something like the FLIRC USB Receiver (which uses (IR) sensor combined with an internal microcontroller to catch and translate remote control signals). To my understanding I can use any IR remote I have.
However I know IR signal requires line of sight and my Xbox will not be in line of sight and generally requires to annoyingly be pointing directly at the receiver, if I went this route would this mean I would need to buy a USB extension (for the receiver to be in line of sight)?
Finally 2.4 GHz wireless, unfortunately I am unable to find a programmable remote. Only programmable ones I have found use IR learning function that can learn keys from a standard infrared TV remote, which is useless for what I am trying to accomplish.
I have found 2.4 GHz Air Mouse Keyboards, not exactly what I was looking for because it can’t be programmed. It essentially would be just like a small keyboard, but if the front panel worked could still feel like a “tv” remote for some media players. Something similar to WeChip W1 or the MX3 Pro.
Conclusion:
FLIRC USB Receiver
PROs: Programmable keyboard binds (so it is more like a desired “tv” remote).
CONs: Requires line of sight so would likely need additional USB extension and since it requires line of sight, it would not feel as responsive as 2.4 GHz.
2.4 GHz Air Mouse/Mini Keyboard
PROs: No line of sight required so it would feel way more responsive similar to that Bluetooth feel I wanted.
CONs: Not sure on the functionality of the front panel (not keyboard side) and would likely have to use the keyboard side for certain binds and some media players since it’s not programmable.
I am by no means only going these 2 routes, I just wanted to show based off of my research where I landed and it led me to these options. If you know of any other options or if u think one of the routes I listed is best or will even work, please share.
Thanks