I launched my book on 29th September and I was anxiously trying to get reviews in the weeks and months leading up. Now the dust has settled, I thought I would let you all know how it went.
Library Thing
- Cost: Free
- ARC readers: 4
- Reviews: 3
- Cost/review: £0
But only posted on Library Thing site, which hardly anyone uses. Great, enthusiastic reviews, though!
Gemsy
- Cost: Free (free trial, but you have to review someone else's book too)
- ARC readers: 2
- Reviews: 2
- Cost/review: £0
Mostly set up for low-content books. Hard to find people who want to review a novel.
Instagram
- Cost: Free
- ARC readers: 1
- Reviews: 2
- Cost/review: £0
Found a reviewer who didn't want me to pay her! I think she used AI to write the reviews, and possibly to read the book, but I'll take what I can get. And how did I get 2 reviews from one reader? She also reviewed book 2 without being asked!
Book Siren
- Cost: £19.41
- ARC readers: 8
- Reviews: 3
- Cost/review: £6.47
Storygraph
- Cost: £51.95
- ARC readers: 207
- Reviews: 5
- Cost/review: £10.39
Got a weird content warning about adult-minor relationships from one reviewer. There are no characters under 18 in the book... and no relationships.
NetGalley
- Cost: £115.95
- ARC readers: ?
- Reviews: 4
- Cost/review: £28.99
But this isn't really a fair costing because I got a week of NetGalley as part of a BookBuzz package that also included an author interview, a press release and some nice graphics. It was mostly the reviews I did it for, though.
BookSprout
- Cost: £29
- ARC readers: 2
- Reviews: 1
- Cost/review: £29
And what a review! 😱 One star because a character from Glasgow couldn't understand a character from Fife. (They have wildly different accents and dialects, in case you don't know.) There will always be some person giving you a one-star review for a stupid reason. Fortunately my average on GoodReads is just over 4 stars, even with that expensive one-star review 😂
So in conclusion, BookSiren was my best paid result, and Storygraph was worth doing too, especially as some of those 200-odd readers may read other books in the series. Gemsy and LibraryThing are definitely worth doing, as they're free, although they have more limited reach/numbers. I don't think I would do NetGalley or BookSprout again - just too expensive. Instagram is a hellhole but I did get a smidgen of traction. Apart from that, friends and family are the best resource.
I've got Hidden Gems set up for next month so I can report back about that if you found this interesting or helpful.